Ranging from Susan Fast's essay on the U2 3D film to Dana Gooley's exploration of concert life in 1848 Vienna, from historical to ethnographic study, and from performance studies to musicology (and back), Taking It to the Bridge builds bridges between disciplines. The volume began as a project of the Music as Performance (MAP) working group of the Association for Theatre in Higher Education (ATHE), whose members wanted to connect musicology to their own disciplines of theatre and performance studies. The project of bridging these disciplines is admirable, although, as is acknowledged by several contributors, there currently exists less of a chasm between performance studies and musicology than in decades past.
For lack of space, this review will highlight selections from the volume's fifteen essays. Daphne A. Brooks's ‘“Bring the Pain”: Post-soul Memory, Neo-soul Affect, and Lauryn Hill in the Black Public Sphere’ is a standout contribution, densely theoretical and elegant. Her analysis of Hill's voice, persona, and post-Miseducation career situates Hill's powerful alto within ‘a poetics of post-soul affect, a structure of feeling that tells us something about the historicity of a generation of black subjects at a particular moment in time’ (p. 188). Brooks's essay is one of several covering black popular music, welcome additions to a still-too-thin literature. Margaret F. Savilonis's essay on Labelle and Parliament reads glam through an intersectional lens that addresses not only gendered, but also racial, identity. Jason King's contribution on Michael Jackson's This Is It reads ‘Jackson's heart-on-your-sleeve sentimentality’ (p. 205) as a sign of the artist's utopian ‘presentation of black performance as labor rooted in shared collective good feeling’ (p. 229). On the fringes of what musicologists categorize as popular music, Ingrid Monson writes about superstar xylophonist and composer Neba Solo in Mali, Aida Mbowa on jazz singer Abbey Lincoln and the envoicing of historical protest through wordless screaming, and Joseph Roach on the evolution of jazz funerals in New Orleans (a lone classic essay amid the newer scholarship).
Philip Auslander's contribution, also jazz-focused, interrogates the function, performance and reception of improvisation and repetition. His object of analysis is a Miles Davis/John Coltrane collaboration. His central claim is ‘that the audience experiences jazz improvisation first and foremost as a social characteristic of jazz performance rather than an ontological characteristic of the music’ (p. 57). Yet his insights are equally useful for scholars of non-jazz, and even non-musical improvisations. This broad appeal is true of most of the essays in the collection, and indicative of the increasingly prominent idea that musicology and performance studies have much to say to one another.
