Adolfo Bronstein and Thomas Lempert are Professors of Neurology with an interest in ‘dizziness’. They have produced a book for the ‘non-expert doctor who sees dizzy patients’ with an accompanying CD-ROM.
The book begins with two chapters that are essential reading on vestibular physiology and the clinical examination of the dizzy patient to allow the reader to have a degree of understanding of the problem-based chapters. These seem well written and understandable.
The following chapters are meant to be read ad hoc to better understand specific symptom complexes such as single episodes of vertigo, recurrent episodes of vertigo, positional vertigo etc. The thought behind this seems very sensible but I feel that for the non-specialist doctor seeing dizzy patients it can be misleading in places. For instance, in the differential diagnoses within the single episode of vertigo chapter, acute brainstem/cerebellar lesion is higher on the differential list than the first attack of Ménière's disease. In the chapter on recurrent episodes of vertigo, migrainous recurrent vertigo is at the top of the differential list and psychogenic dizziness appears to be an afterthought. This may well reflect their own practice and the type of patients that they see, but does not offer an appropriate perspective on the most frequently occurring conditions for the non-specialist.
The CD-ROM does show some interesting eye movements that once seen will never be forgotten and insight into the specific examinations conducted during the assessment of a dizzy patient.
This text has attempted to approach the diagnosis of dizziness with a symptom-based approach but it has a feeling of not truly representing the most common problems that may be encountered. I think that algorithms would have been helpful for the non-specialist doctor to work towards a diagnosis within each of these chapters. It is a book that may interest some ENT doctors to see how a neurologist thinks!
