David D. Gow's Countering Development is an ethnography based on annual research trips to Cauca in south-western Colombia between 1995 and 2002. Gow's analysis focuses on three Nasa settlements created when communities were relocated following the severe 1994 earthquake in the Tierradentro region of Cauca. The relocation gave the communities – Tóez Caloto, Cxayu'ce and Juan Tama – the opportunity to envision and embark upon a re-creation of themselves, and they approached it as an opportunity to combat a history of social, economic and political marginalisation.
Gow examines the communities' approaches to development through the lens of ‘moral imagination’. He argues that indigenous critiques of state-led development are not a rejection of development itself. The people in the communities he studies desire development, but they seek to envision a new way of doing it. By envisioning and working to implement forms of development that are attentive to their desire for social justice, recognition and redistribution, the communities are exercising their moral imagination.
Gow also explores the distinct ways that culture entered into the communities' approach to development. Tóez Caloto embraced the possibility of modernisation and successfully fought with state authorities to be able to move to land only a half-hour from Cali. At the same time, it engaged in an intensely self-conscious effort to reconstruct its Nasa identity, perhaps to prove that it really was more indigenous than its more assimilated neighbours and was less willing than the other communities to take outside help in dealing with its new lands. Juan Tama was also self-consciously Nasa. However, it was less modernist than Tóez Caloto, and viewed culture in a less essentialist manner. Cxayu'ce fought for more productive lands than it was originally offered, but did not see its new beginnings as a break with the past. Indeed, of the three settlements, Cxayu'ce maintained the closest connections with its home community and had the least self-conscious approach to being Nasa. It was also the most effective in taking advantage of its new environment. The communities' distinct approaches to culture influenced the form and content of the development they envisioned as well as the strategies they engaged in its pursuit.
In order to delve into the communities' perspectives on development, Gow examines community-driven development plans and the processes behind their creation. The 1991 Constitution granted unprecedented local control to indigenous peoples over development, health and education, but in order to access the funds, communities are required to complete local development plans. In Tóez Caloto and Cxayu'ce, external advisors played a huge role in shaping this community ‘participation’. The advisors did not know the communities well, and did little to incorporate what they actually said during planning sessions into the final plans. Only Juan Tama really had substantial involvement in the creation of its own plan. In this way, Gow shows how ‘participation’ can end up simply legitimating the dominant system, rather than providing for the creation of alternative visions. Still, he observes that writing one thing in the plan does not prevent communities from pursuing alternative strategies in practice.
Additional chapters focus on local knowledge, an award-winning development plan in another part of Cauca, and La María, a centre and alternative political space for envisioning possibilities for peace and inclusion for all Colombians – the Nasa as well as other indigenous people, Afro-Colombians, and the non-indigenous. In the latter chapter, Gow writes compellingly of the possibilities for using ‘indigenous ideas to transform not only indigenous society but the dominant society as well’ (p. 239).
Gow concludes the book by discussing the relationship between indigenous claims and citizenship. He sees the efforts discussed throughout the book as ultimately about the quest for citizenship and recognition of human rights, and suggests that a desire for inclusion is implicit in the struggle for recognition. While this is in many ways a compelling argument, missing is a more complex analysis that acknowledges the dialectical, and sometimes contradictory, relationship between autonomy and inclusion in indigenous activism. Although I agree that looking at development through the lens of human rights has the potential to lead to a more just approach, Gow might have done more to entertain indigenous critiques of the concept of human rights, and the ways in which human rights discourses have been used by states against indigenous peoples. The indigenous relationship to citizenship is fraught with tensions that are different from those of many other groups in society, and I would have liked to see more discussion of those differences and what they might mean for the possibilities for coalition building in Colombia.
Nevertheless, there is much to recommend about this book. By looking at various communities, Gow shows us that it is impossible to talk about one single indigenous (or one single Nasa) approach to development. He also insists on problematising indigenous resistance to top-down development by showing that this resistance does not always, or even usually, entail total opposition to development. This is marvellously shown through documentation of the ways in which the communities creatively engaged state development initiatives and envisioned their own approaches. Gow is also forthright about the many roadblocks such an approach entails; for example, only Cxayu'ce has developed an economy that is able to sustain its families. Economic limitations may make it difficult for the other communities to realise their moral imaginings and achieve recognition, self-sufficiency and mutual respect, even when they are able to participate in the development process. In this sense, Gow's book once again points to the necessity of changing the way development is approached in order to make human rights and social justice a priority. The book is to be recommended to scholars, students and practitioners of development, planning and indigenous politics.
