Sarah Townsend's The Unfinished Art of Theater: Avant-Garde Intellectuals in Mexico and Brazil is a valuable contribution to the fields of theatre and performance studies, global modernism studies, and Latin American studies. A complement to Vicky Unruh's Latin American Vanguards: The Art of Contentious Encounters (University of California Press, 1994), which argues for an interpretation of vanguard movements as activities rather than collections of texts, Townsend reads various Mexican and Brazilian avant-garde texts as performances. Her meticulously researched analysis hinges on a clever multiple reading of the term ensayo (Spanish) or ensaio (Portuguese), which can be translated as both “essay” and “rehearsal.” This approach posits various cultural products—some conceived of as theatrical texts and performances, others explicitly as essays—as unfinished works of theatre. The concept of theatre as an unfinished art supports the overarching claim that avant-gardes reveal the “unfinished or uneven historical transition” to “modern” Mexican and Brazilian cultures (5).
Following an introduction that thoroughly outlines the state of the field of Latin American avant-garde studies and characterizes theatre as a marginal genre within regional vanguard movements, The Unfinished Art of Theater is divided into two parts (each comprising three chapters) dedicated to Mexico and Brazil, respectively. Each chapter focuses on a particular cultural product through a Marxist lens of uneven development, to examine the role of avant-garde art in countries that are modernizing yet retain what Leon Trotsky calls the “‘privilege of historic backwardness’” (5). The examples analyzed are created by canonical writers and artists of the 1920s and 1930s, such as José Vasconcelos, Mário de Andrade, members of the Mexican estridentista movement, and Oswald de Andrade.
In Chapter 1, “Rehearsals of the Tragi-Co(s)mic Race,” Townsend examines Mexican writer and educational administrator José Vasconcelos's famous essay The Cosmic Race alongside his lesser-known work Prometheus Triumphant, a series of brief essays written in the style of unstageable drama, which she sees as the key to understanding Vasconcelos's more famous work. Chapter 2, “Primitivist Accumulation and Teatro sintético,” traces the theatrical history of the futurist “synthetic theatre” through Italy, Russia, France, the United States, and finally a national anthropology project in Mexico known as the short-lived Teatro del Murciélago. Townsend argues that the synthetic theatre that recovered local folklore to present to foreign visitors demonstrates a “creation of emotional and cultural capital” (79) akin to Marx's primitive accumulation. Chapter 3, “Radio/Puppets, or The Institutionalization of a (Media) Revolution,” examines the fate of Troka the Powerful, a radio creation of the Mexican avant-garde estridentista movement, arguing that the mysterious character's hybrid existence as both pure voice and material puppet sheds light on the relationship between the avant-garde and Mexico's progressive policies of the 1930s.
Chapter 4, “Parsifal on the Periphery of Capitalism,” is a study of Mário de Andrade's participation in the 1922 Week of Modern Art in São Paulo, the birth of Brazilian Modernismo, using depictions of Mário de Andrade that allude to his queerness and nonwhiteness as a metaphor for what Roberto Schwarz calls Brazil's “ideas … ‘out of place’” (9) and leads to its modernist movement. Chapter 5, “Phonography, Operatic Ethnography, and Other Bad Arts,” examines Mário de Andrade's ethnographic operatic creations and analyzes the tension between the author's fascination with the technology of the phonograph and his turn to the “‘primitive’” (177) to create a national opera. Finally, Chapter 6, “Total Theater and Missing Pieces,” argues that Oswald de Andrade's unstaged play O homem e o cavalo (The Man and the Horse), is not, as most critics contend, so much an example of total theatre as a Benjaminian Trauerspiel that must be examined within the context of international avant-gardes, which must themselves be examined as “part of a global totality” (248) of social and political relations.
Townsend is a skilled and engaging writer whose narrative skills are highlighted in The Unfinished Art of Theater. In each chapter, the author manages to string together disparate fragments of artistic history in a captivating chain that masterfully contains theoretical reflections, artistic relationships, and textual analysis. The conclusions are based on extensive archival research in Mexico and Brazil, and throughout the book, helpful illustrations from various archives enrich the reader's understanding. Even as each chapter is a self-contained wonder, the bridges between them must be built by the reader. The relationship, for example, between Brazil and Mexico seems to hinge entirely on historical similarities and Vasconcelos's visit to Brazil, which leaves the reader wondering whether similar conclusions could be drawn from a study of avant-gardes in Argentina, Chile, Peru, or Guatemala. A critic's work, however, is always “unfinished,” and this question may be answered by others or in future works by Townsend herself. The Unfinished Art of Theater is a significant contribution to the field of theatre and performance studies and will be of interest to anyone invested in global modernisms, sound studies, or Marxist conceptions of artistic production. It relates to current debates on the role of art in politics and sheds new light on the theatrical works analyzed.
