Betsy Konefal's history of Mayan activism in Guatemala from 1960 to 1990 takes as its departure points the fact that scholars disagree about Mayan participation in the country's civil war and that the development of Mayan indigenous activism during the war is poorly understood. Those who read Konefal's book in order to move beyond such disagreements and gain a comprehensive understanding of the first decades of Guatemalan Mayan activism will only be carried halfway towards putting these arguments to rest. Firstly this is because Konefal is rather vague about her own ambitions regarding the larger schemes of history; in a modest introductory chapter she says her work aims to explore ‘how (some) Mayas became, in varying degrees, involved in political activism and opposition to a repressive state’, and to trace ‘how debates around issues of Maya identity and rights evolved … and how resistance was shaped and reshaped by revolutionary insurgency and genocidal counterinsurgency’ (p. 4). Secondly, the book is analytically underdeveloped when it comes to placing the background material into larger frames such as political strategies, structural changes and even individual career paths.
The lack of a clearly defined author's voice and a set of theories concerning the birth of modern indigenous or even nationalist movements in post-colonial societies might be due to a programmatic respect for the fluidity of a social situation or historical moment. Large parts of the text indeed appear to be written in deference to the many strong and surely admirable people that participated in the events covered by the book. Konefal herself notes that the book is ‘heavily dependent on interviews’ (p. 4), that memories are imperfect and that fears of being outspoken remain palpable, but instead of compensating for this by way of, for instance, comparisons, larger surveys or prolonged fieldwork, she is content to note that the many rich interviews provide a nuanced and deep history.
So it is in the terrain of personal accounts that the book finds its strongest justification. Having sat down to research the history of Mayan activism in Guatemala's National Library, Konefal finds a photograph of 22 young Mayan men and women on the front page of the newspaper El Gráfico for 30 July 1978. They were gathered to protest the staging of the festival of indigenous folklore that year, built around the selection of a reina indígena (indigenous pageant queen) and the celebration of indigenous culture as defined by the country's Spanish-speaking elite and military rulers. Two months earlier the army had fired on and killed dozens of demonstrating Mayan agricultural workers in a massacre that was widely regarded as the starting point of the civil war of the early 1980s, but was viewed by the incipient Mayan movement which the El Gráfico picture might be said to represent not only as an act of social and political repression but of cultural and racial repression as well.
Touring Guatemala 30 years later, Konefal identifies 18 of the 22 that survived the war, and around the stories of their participation in the beauty pageants and protests, as well as in political organising work before, during and after the war, she skilfully constructs a tapestry of personal impressions around the greater events that took place. Through her interviews she traces the history of an emerging pan-Mayan identity among a new generation of indigenous people who have left their peasant communities and decided to take part in the building of a greater nation or pueblo, only to realise that they are a pueblo apart in a country moving from a colonial, class-ridden society to a modern and racialised but also multicultural one. The tensions between what during the 1990s became known as the class-conscious (clasista) and the culture-oriented (culturalista) currents of the pan-Mayan movement were not, Konefal holds, as apparent then as after the war. For the young students who utilised the official interest in indigenous folklore to push for a reconstructed Mayan identity, there were no obvious natural divisions between, say, social and cultural marginalisation. Konefal convincingly argues that this bifurcation of the emerging pan-Mayan elite is mostly due to the way in which the activists in question were perceived and recruited by the Left and the Right (read: the army) in a deeply polarised country. Moreover, Konefal has a keen eye for these people's own agency, and she highlights the fact that Mayan leaders from Quetzaltenango – the country's second city, which also contains a Mayan elite – were always sceptical towards the insurgent Left and in the end refused to join any project in which Mayas appeared as merely another sector along with workers, peasants and women.
The focus on personal accounts reaches a moving height with the story of Emeterio Toj Medrano, who in effect became the guerrillas' man in a peasant front organisation, the Comité de Unidad Campesina (Committee for Campesino Unity, CUC), responsible for recruiting Mayas. He was captured by the army, tortured and forced to participate at army-staged press conferences designed to uncover the work of the guerrillas and demonstrate how the latter were duping the Indians, but was able to escape and even return to the guerrillas. It is more than telling to read how under torture Toj never revealed the Maya networks he knew, yet cooperated sufficiently to serve the army in its propaganda war. In the end, the blood of the Mayan raza was thicker than the national projects over which the war was being waged.
The stories of Toj and many other activists, in many different arenas, nonetheless remain personal. True, to some extent Konefal discusses the emergence of parallel beauty pageants for the two pueblos and the birth of pan-Mayanism among teacher students at Catholic colleges, and she allows the reader to glimpse pictures of a Mayan Guatemala. But when it comes to showing how these testimonies are inscribed in the larger processes of a guevarista rebellion and the construction of a counter-insurgent state, the book falls short.
