It was May 2012, and we heard rumblings about a Senate vote on the Paycheck Fairness Act, a bill long-sponsored by my boss, Representative Rosa DeLauro (D-CT), that would end pay secrecy, strengthen workers' ability to challenge discrimination, and bring equal pay law into line with other civil rights laws. As the lead sponsor in the House of Representatives, the congresswoman immediately mobilized her staff and advocates to ensure that we did all we could to highlight the importance of the legislation, secure the strongest Senate support possible, and—assuming it would not pass in the current political climate—protect the integrity of the legislation for future Congresses and eventual passage. That is where I came in.
I joined Representative DeLauro's staff in December 2011 as an APSA Congressional Fellow, fortunate to find an office where my interest and expertise in women and politics was not only useful, but could flourish through incredible experiences and opportunities to learn from a veteran woman legislator and many integral female members of her staff. My initial role as an assistant to the then-chief of staff quickly changed in February 2012, when she left the office and I was asked to take on her legislative and appropriations portfolio, including labor, education, social welfare, and women's economic issues.
My days began to blur as I schooled myself—with the help of advocates, fellow staff, departmental liaisons, and constituent groups—on the issues I would cover for the congresswoman. I took countless meetings, tracked legislative activity and news, and drafted memos and hearing preparation materials for Representative DeLauro. I knew early on that my fellowship experience was going to be unique from many others', as I quickly became a fully-integrated member of the congresswoman's staff. I worked hard to fill that role without disruption to Representative DeLauro's strong reputation as a fighter for vulnerable populations, especially women and children. To do so, I established strong working relationships with friendly advocacy groups and communities, reached out directly to organizations and leaders in Connecticut's third congressional district, and worked with legislative staff whose bosses shared similar passions to ensure fairness, equality, and opportunity to all Americans.
The appropriations process formally began in March 2012 when the Labor, Health, Human Services, and Education Appropriations Subcommittee, on which Representative DeLauro serves as ranking member, began its hearings with members of the Obama administration (Secretaries Duncan, Sebelius, and Solis) and representatives from affected communities, including veterans and educators. In these hearings and the late-summer subcommittee mark-up of the Chairman's proposed bill, the congresswoman led a Democratic membership consisting of three women members (Representatives Lee, Lowey, and Roybal-Allard) and one man (Representative Jackson Jr.) in fighting to preserve Democratic priorities and protect the interests of Americans in need of jobs, social services, health care, and better access to quality education. Working alongside members of the subcommittee staff, I helped to prepare questions, background materials, and talking points that integrated the congresswoman's priorities as they related to her Connecticut constituents and, in many cases, women and children.
Not long after these hearings concluded we started to hear rumors that Senate Democratic leadership was considering a vote on the Paycheck Fairness Act, building on the energy among progressive women that stemmed from perceived attacks on women's access to health care, contraception, and essential social services. A vote on this well-respected legislation, which had twice-passed in the House, would put Republicans on the record once again voting against women's interests, thus contributing to the “War on Women” being waged not only in Washington, but nationwide.
As the staffer assigned to this issue and legislation, I worked with our chief of staff and legislative director to be sure that we were involved in strategic discussions about the vote and that we engaged our advocacy groups and House members to weigh in and advocate for legislation to protect women's interests and equity in the workforce. At the congresswoman's urging, we organized a meeting among female members, circulated materials about the legislation to all Democratic offices, and helped to organize a hearing for the Democratic Steering and Policy Committee that highlighted the need for equal pay legislation. Throughout this work, I was continually reminded of the essential role of women—from staff and advocates to the members themselves—in elevating this issue, bringing much-needed energy, and presenting unique perspectives and experiences in the public dialogue that was ensuing.
On June 5, 2012, I coordinated a march of female (and one male) members of the House of Representatives to the Senate chambers to demonstrate their strong support for Senate passage of the Paycheck Fairness Act. As I stood in the Rayburn Room with my boss—the mastermind and passionate sponsor of this effort, Representatives Berkeley, Bonamici, Christensen, Edwards, Schakowsky, Van Hollen, and Lilly Ledbetter—the namesake of the law protecting women's ability to challenge unequal pay in court—I could not help but be awed and inspired. I directed the group through the Capitol halls, past unsuspecting tourists and ahead of the media flurry focused on the marching legislators, to the Senate chambers, where each member took the opportunity to speak to reporters about the need to pass the Paycheck Fairness Act. As the debate and vote began in the Senate chambers, the House members took a seat in the back rows and staff and advocates like me sat in the Senate gallery. While we already knew what the outcome would be—the bill would be defeated by a vote of 58-47—we savored the words of Senator Barbara Mikulski. I felt enormous pride to work for Representative DeLauro, whose excitement could not be contained as she clapped in support of the Democratic Senator's passionate plea for support.
Despite this defeat, we knew that our fight for this and similar legislation to address pay inequity would continue. Representative DeLauro had introduced the Paycheck Fairness Act for eight congresses and this would not be the last.
My work in the congresswoman's office continued full-speed throughout the summer, including finalizing and introducing legislation to restore equal employment protections to workers after the Wal-Mart v. Dukes decision, continuing appropriations work, and monitoring efforts by executive departments to put Americans back to work, promote education reform, and address gender inequities in labor and employment.
Unlike many of my peers, I approached the end of my fellowship with a great deal of inner conflict about whether I should stay on Capitol Hill or retain some foothold in academia through my work at the Center for American Women and Politics (CAWP) at Rutgers University. My experience was so incredible and opportunities so abundant that it was difficult to turn away from the feeling of being on the frontlines of public policy, especially on issues so personally and professionally important to me. But, I also knew that my time in Washington, DC, taught me much about women and politics that I could use in research and work to promote greater inclusion and participation of women in public life, participation that proved essential in pushing an agenda and providing perspectives within the Beltway that would benefit women throughout the country. I returned to CAWP this fall armed with information, experiences, and energy to make sure this happens.
Below, I outline some important lessons I learned through the APSA Congressional Fellowship Program that will continue to inform my work as a scholar and practitioner of women and politics.
LESSONS LEARNED: WOMEN IN THE CONGRESSIONAL INSTITUTION
Scholars have taken great pains to determine appropriate methods to measure the impact of women in legislatures, from cataloguing and comparing legislator behaviors (e.g., bill sponsorship, roll-call votes, and floor speeches) to surveying legislators about legislative preferences and their perceptions of gender difference. In addition to these measures, scholars and advocates have frequently cited anecdotal evidence of the difference women make, highlighting stories of women's efforts in areas like health care, violence against women, and international women's issues.
Each of these measures was evident as I observed the efforts of Representative DeLauro and many of her female colleagues. The congresswoman was the lead sponsor on multiple prominent pieces of woman-centered legislation like the Paycheck Fairness Act or the Equal Employment Opportunity Restoration Act of 2012. She spoke frequently on the House floor about how budget cuts or conservative legislative efforts would affect women, often joining members of the Democratic Women's Caucus for “Women's Health Wednesdays,” a half-hour of floor time dedicated exclusively to highlighting women's issues in the Congressional Record. The congresswoman frequently made public statements about news and reports related to women's equality, and herself spoke frequently about the different experiences and impact of women in Congress. Finally, one need only look back to a spring 2012 hearing on contraception to see the role of women legislators in protecting and advancing women's voices in the legislative process. Addressing the injustice of an all-male panel speaking as authorities on women's reproductive health and choices, representative Carolyn Maloney (D-NY)—with support from male and female colleagues on the dais—repeatedly asked the committee chair, “Where are the women?”
However, many of these measures of impact are limited and sometimes overestimated, while other avenues toward shaping legislative policy are overlooked. First, measures like roll-call votes and bill sponsorship are often informed much more strongly by other factors like party and/or committee assignments than gender, making it hard to find statistically significant differences between male and female legislators. Self-reported measures through surveys and interviews may better get at real differences, but scholars are well aware of the challenges of determining how one defines “women-friendly” or “women's” issues.
Although the strongest studies to date have sought to combine multiple measures of impact to make up for the weaknesses of any one variable, I recommend greater attention be paid to members' communication efforts and outreach to constituents and media, style and substance of engagement in committee hearings and on the floor, and, when possible, communications with and lobbying of federal agencies and departments. In a hyper-partisan Congress, a member's bully pulpit is sometimes the strongest weapon for pressuring the party in power, so the communications strategies used are well worth greater observation. The questions asked to experts and government officials in committee hearings often reflect unique perspectives and priorities, and I saw first hand the willingness of a member to stand up for women with agency heads and officials in her own party when it came to issues related to women's health, economic security, and civil rights.
These measures attempt to objectively describe how men and women differ in legislative behaviors and priorities. However, what is too often understudied or explained is why women legislate or behave differently than their male counterparts, especially when it comes to policymaking. Traditional explanations for gender differences include recognition of women's unique life experiences and feelings of responsibility to represent all women in an institution that remains overwhelmingly male. There is no reason to question the veracity of these explanations, but I recommend further investigation into others that became clearer to me during my time on legislative staff.
No member of Congress is an island. In a highly professionalized institution, members rely on their legislative staff and advisors to help shape and secure their policy agenda and priorities. The priorities, expertise, attentiveness, and responsiveness of legislative staff, in addition to their own unique identities and experiences, may well influence many of the traditional measures of impact used in political science literature, at least at the congressional level. Greater attention to the role of staff and the gender disparities therein might well contribute to our understanding of legislative processes, priorities, and outcomes.
Members and staff alike are also reliant on advocacy organizations that play an essential role in keeping offices informed of and alert to their priority issues. In the world of gender politics, the role of women's advocacy organizations cannot be denied, nor their relationships with women legislators underestimated or overlooked. In my relatively short tenure on Capitol Hill, I established strong relationships with women's organizations that frequently appealed to Representative DeLauro for assistance with outreach, communications, and legislative efforts, often looking to her as a standard-bearer on women's issues and a sure-bet supporter. Additional research would be useful on the strategies and approaches these organizations use in appealing to legislators for assistance and support. Researchers should ask whether targeted lobbying of women members contributes not only to women legislators feeling a special responsibility to women, but also to gender differences in the objective measures of legislative impact. Finally, these groups might be asked about their appeals to male legislators and how responses differ—if at all—between male and female members and their staffs.
My time in the 112th Congress demonstrated that partisanship and power must not be underestimated in any investigations of legislative behavior and impact, especially as they relate to gender. The opportunities for any members, especially women, to have an impact are at least partly determined by their institutional power and influence, often through party and committee leadership and/or seniority. As more women earn leadership posts, specific attention should be paid to their ability and approaches to alter agendas and dialogues. Finally, although the role of partisanship in shaping legislative behavior is well-recognized, scholarship on gender difference always needs to be careful to not paint “women's impact” in broad brush strokes. The current political climate and increased diversity among women in office necessitates better unpacking of how scholars define and discuss women's issues, and how those may differ from the legislators' own definitions. Investigating party-gender dynamics also provides an opportunity to explore whether there is any shared affinity among women across the aisle and how the institutional dynamics may foster or impede acting on it.
My tenure in Washington, DC, was only 10 months—and a tough 10 months of preelection paralysis at that—but it was long enough to show me that women do make a difference in the halls of the United States Congress and in 2413 Rayburn House Office Building. It also taught me that as scholars we could do a better job at investigating and explaining how, when, and in what ways women's representation matters. Those explanations not only advance scholarship, but aid advocates and organizations working to increase the numbers of women in politics and government. As for me, I came to Washington, DC, as a woman hoping to make my mark in Congress and can only hope that I did in some small way. No doubt, I learned from the best.
