In his landmark 1994 essay “The Problem of American Conservatism,” Alan Brinkley observed that historians have generally framed twentieth-century American history around the “triumph of the progressive-liberal state.”Footnote 1The Right and Labor in America and Making Sense of American Liberalism demonstrate just how fully that paradigm has shifted over the past two decades. In response to conservatives' recent political successes, historians have reconceived the period between the 1930s and the 1960s as a long exception that concluded with the collapse of liberalism and the rise of the free-market right. As Timothy Stanley and Jonathan Bell observe in their introduction to the latter volume, today “the years of profound liberal reform (1932–1966) seem like the aberration and conservatism the norm” (4).
This historiographic revision has been marked by a formidable body of scholarship on the broad ambit of the American right, including studies of grassroots activists, evangelical Christians, academic economists, suburban property owners, and business advocacy groups. Cumulatively, this literature has created a substantial burden of originality for new work on the period of liberal retrenchment and conservative ascent. These two volumes approach this challenge by focussing on questions that have fallen to the margins in recent years. The Right and Labor in America establishes a dialogue between the new historiography on conservatism and long-standing questions in labor history, arguing that such an approach will help us to understand both the decline of trade unionism and the structural and rhetorical underpinnings of the conservative movement. “A commitment to laissez-faire within the labor market,” the editors argue in the introduction, has marked the rise of the right to a still greater extent than the “racial, cultural, and foreign policy issues that receive so much attention” (8). In contrast, the editors of Making Sense of American Liberalism suggest that the time has come for scholars to reexamine the trajectory of liberalism in this period, and to move beyond now-conventional narratives of stagnation and defeat. After all, they assert, liberals “scored successes on many fronts,” at times “flirted with populist themes,” and achieved some remarkable policy goals even in the midst of a broader political decline (10–11).
While the essays in The Right and Labor in America are primarily concerned with the history of labor policy, they draw in productive and original ways on methods associated with the recent turn toward the history of capitalism. Instead of focussing on moments of “labor–management conflict,” they attempt to situate the politics of labor within a thick “cultural, intellectual, and legal” context, exploring how new ideas, rhetorical tropes, and institutional structures transformed the political environment (9). The contributions expand well beyond labor leaders, executives, and federal bureaucrats, exploring developments in management theory, economics, journalism, and state politics.
Many of the essays emphasize the crucial importance of the language and ideological framework in which ideas about labor were expressed. Chris Nyland and Kyle Bruce illuminate the conservative implications of Elton Mayo's “human relations” theory, which – despite being presented as a benevolent alternative to Taylorism – was appropriated by managers as a tool to suppress labor activism. Andrew Wender Cohen shows that in the early twentieth century, protectionism was aligned with a modernizing telos, and questions why tariffs have since become so widely perceived as reactionary. David Witwer explores the muddy terrain between antiunion activism and investigative journalists in the mid-century heyday of “racketeering” charges, arguing that the transformation of public perceptions of unions was related to a decline in journalistic “balance.” Michael Pierce examines Arkansas politics during the 1950s to explain the emergence of a novel and enduring “anti-labor populism,” and Sophia Lee demonstrates how right-to-work litigators leveraged the language of civil rights to argue against trade unionism (exploiting the tensions between labor interests and racial minorities).
This attentiveness to culture and ideology is tempered, in other essays, by an emphasis on structural factors that put labor at a disadvantage in the postwar era. Essays by Nelson Lichtenstein and Alexander Gourse reveal the legal strategies that business interests adopted to suppress unionization efforts, contributions from Elizabeth Tandy Shermer and Tami J. Friedman draw attention to the importance of capital mobilization and regional competition, and John Logan's capstone essay examines how the militancy of business interests precluded compromises with organized labor in the early years of the Clinton presidency.
Although disparate in interest and emphasis, the essays share an elegiac tone, and (implicitly and explicitly) seek to identify moments when organized labor might have taken an alternative path. The editors are quick to observe the reactionary tenor of some labor interests through much of the twentieth century, but remain deeply troubled by the institutional decline of the movement and the political and economic inequalities its diminishment has engendered. By connecting these issues to recent work on conservatism and the growing methodological interest in histories of capitalism, the contributors help push labor history in new directions while returning its foundational problems to the center of contemporary historiographic debates.
The editors of Making Sense of American Liberalism are eager to move beyond such declension narratives to reveal the various ways in which leftist and liberal politics persisted and even thrived through the later decades of the twentieth century. Jonathan Bell looks at the California Democratic Party in the 1950s, when it adopted an optimistic vision that allowed it to rise to power through an “uneasy synthesis” of economic redistribution, managed growth, and social citizenship. Timothy Stanley turns his attention to the 1970s, exploring a brief period of remarkable influence for the Democratic Socialist Organizing Committee prior to its collapse after the defeat of Ted Kennedy in the 1980 campaign. Other contributors engage in vigorous attempts to rehabilitate aspects of liberal politics that have since come under heavy criticism. In contrast to common perception (recently put forward in Robert Self's All in the Family (2012)) that the rise of identity politics fractured the liberal economic coalition, Susan Hartmann argues that second-wave feminism extended and fulfilled the economic ideals of the New Deal state. And Lizabeth Cohen asserts that we should reappraise liberal efforts at urban renewal, exploring the career of Edward Logue as an exemplar of a laudable liberal commitment to using the public sector (in conjunction with private investment) to improve the “social, economic, and political quality of life for as many Americans as possible” (136).
Despite the editors' stated ambitions for the book, many of the contributions emphasize the policy failures of liberalism and its eventual fracturing. Several, including contributions by Ella Howard (on poverty in New York City) and Nelson Lichtenstein (on labor policy), explore the reasons why liberal politicians failed to implement economic programs that aligned with their stated ideals. Others focus on the persistent tension between liberals and the left, and identify points where their political allegiances dissolved. Douglas Rossinow highlights a period between the 1880s and the 1940s when leftists and liberals often overlapped in American political life, due to a shared belief in a “qualitative vision of progress”– a political alliance that grew unstable in the 1930s and dissipated with liberal complicity in the repressions of the red scare (17). Bruce Miroff chronicles the collapse of the close friendship between Hubert Humphrey and George McGovern amid the eruption of a fierce battle over the meaning of liberalism, and Tony Badger explores Albert Gore Sr. as a test case for the disappearance of the moderate southern Democrat amid the new racial politics of the 1960s. These essays align with the tragic narrative arc of The Right and Labor in America, and complicate any attempt to reframe the history of liberalism in more optimistic terms.
Making Sense of American Liberalism should have substantial influence over the coming years, as historians retreat from the historiographic emphasis on conservative politics and seek to reframe our understanding of the postwar trajectories of liberalism. Its contributions are elegantly written and conceived, and cumulatively they raise a host of possibilities for new research on the history of the American left. Future work on the subject, however, would benefit from expanding the fairly narrow methodological ambit of this collection: in contrast to recent histories of conservatism, these contributions focus primarily on high politics and urban policy, and devote little attention to the intersections between political developments and intellectual, cultural, business, and religious history. As The Right and Labor in America demonstrates, such approaches have defined the recent historiography on the right; many of the most original contributions to the history of liberalism in recent years, from scholars including Alice O'Connor, James Sparrow, and David Swartz, have also situated political developments within these broader contexts. Even as the historiography on the conservative ascendancy becomes saturated, its insights and approaches can be leveraged by scholars who seek new approaches to the persistent problems in the history of the American left.
