Drawing from feminist theory and theatre history, Maya Cantu argues that the Cinderella myth, an amalgamation of a rag-to-riches story and a magical marriage plot, offers a compelling matrix to negotiate theatrically the various economic, gendered, and marital expectations for working women. The myth's popularity was synchronous with the rapidly changing landscape of gender equality in the workplace, shifting marital norms, and women's increased presence in public spheres in the first half of the twentieth century. To describe the enduring resonance of the Cinderella myth, Cantu builds upon Stuart Hecht's “‘Cinderella paradigm’” as a narrational model “‘rather than a story unto itself’” in order to address how the myriad interpretations of Cinderella in musical theatre participated in affirming and subverting societal opinions of working women during what she deems “Broadway's Cinderella Era” 1919–59 (3). As to the broader impact of her work, Cantu deftly advocates for the genre of musical theatre as an important interlocutor in “‘vernacular modernism,’” a term coined by film theorist Miriam Hansen and defined as the inclusion of mass culture in artistic understandings of modernity (7). Additionally, in a feminist historiographical move, Cantu argues for canonical inclusion of the female lyricists and librettists that “openly advanced progressive ideals of women's rights” in their work (8).
The world might best know Cinderella as the glass-slippered, pumpkin-riding princess first made popular by Charles Perrault and later by Walt Disney, but Cantu uses her richly researched case studies to illustrate how the plucky and hard-working Cinderella variations found in her book affect and reflect their distinctively American environments. She begins with the recent resurgence of Cinderella on both stage and screen as an example of how the seemingly “retrograde feminine relic” continues to resonate “with women's dreams and anxieties in an age of vigorous but conflicted twenty-first-century feminism, as well as with class tensions in the age of the 99 Percent” (1, 2). Chapter 1 traces how the immigrant shopgirl as Cinderella was an invitation to 1920s audiences to imagine women's newfound upward mobility caused by the recent suffragette victory, the growing presence of women in the workforce, and subsequent increase in woman-centered leisure activities. Another 1920s Cinderella type was the gold-digging chorus girl variation. In popular culture, the chorus girl was an oft-maligned figure, relying upon her beauty, rather than her work ethic, to win control over men. However, Cantu notes how certain writers, such as Anita Loos, used comedy and camp to subvert the chorus girl stereotype and challenge the fixed definitions of gender and work. Chapter 1 also contains a keen analysis of Josephine Baker's starring turn in the film Princess Tam-Tam (1935), through which Cantu acknowledges the racial limits of the Cinderella myth. A new ball gown may help an Irish-American shopgirl to raise her economic stature through marriage, as it did for the titular character of Irene (1919), but it can only go so far in helping Baker's character, Alwina, overcome a deeply racist society. Chapter 2 looks at the Depression-hardy, “‘tough broad’” versions of Cinderella—“streetwise, vernacular, and not a little ‘vulgar’” (67). Ethel Merman, an icon of womanly grit, is the best-known 1930s Cinderella, as she personified an era when high and low culture, Broadway and burlesque, were becoming harder to distinguish. Merman used both her personal history and performance style to undermine the submissiveness of Cinderella, opening up new possibilities for acceptable nonnormative femininity.
As the United States prepared for and entered the Second World War, theatre and popular culture reflected the country's growing patriotism. The early musicals of the 1940s nostalgically celebrated Americana and the suffrage movement as well as created new images of wartime working women. Directly after the war, cultural feelings about women in the workplace shifted drastically. The latter half of the decade was marked by conservative, early cold-war musicals that demonized the career-focused “Boss Lady” (99) through pop-Freudian theory, forcing her to make a choice between career and marital happiness. Although the late 1940s narrative often provided no possibility of compromise, Cantu argues that the framing of musical theatre allowed for extratextual performances of resisting gendered marital norms, so that certain characters, particularly when penned by women, could perform their submission rather than actually submit. Chapter 4 situates the conservative turn in 1950s Cinderella stories within cold-war containment politics as well as increased media focus on feminine domesticity. However, Cantu also shows the ways in which some musicals, most famously Gypsy (1959), were important in “undermining a feminine mystique that was already starting to crumble” a few years before Betty Freidan published her instrumental critique (200). Cantu ends where she begins, with a short musing on the modern Cinderella and her most recent appearance as Ella in the new, 2013 book Douglas Carter Beane provided for Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella. Ella is a (sometimes black) political activist, whose agency is highlighted when the “lost” glass slipper is no longer an accident but a carefully placed invitation to the Prince—emphasizing the continued importance and adaptability of Cinderella in the American representational economy.
Cantu is at her best when she is interweaving dramatic criticism, historical context, and biographical detail, revivifying the historical figures in her narrative. Chapter 2 is an exceptional example of Cantu's resurrection skills. Its detailed description of Ethel Merman, astute analysis of Merman's personal Cinderella myth, and intricate detailing of Merman's working relationship with Cole Porter are so vibrant that you can almost hear Merman's brassy belt emanating from the pages. Cantu's strong theoretical interventions—for example, her correlation of The Sleeping Prince plotline to a crisis in post-WWII American masculinity in the face of “women's continuing advances in the work force and claims to sexual autonomy” (177)—while sometimes overshadowed by the vitality of her historical descriptions, are sharp, nuanced, and sociologically grounded. American Cinderellas is a lush, captivating, and necessary addition to the fields of theatre history, women performers, and feminism in performance.
