The Indonesian painter A. D. Pirous had a revelation when he visited the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City in 1970. He had thought of himself as an international artist, yet in New York the only works from his part of the world were set aside in a section called “Islamic art.” He realized that the Western audience was unimpressed by non-Western modern artists unless they represented Orientalist primitivism. He decided to pursue a kind of “ethno-aesthetics” in order to shine. This moment was, in retrospect, the moment that this Achenese-Gujarati artist decided to “picture Islam,” a decision that changed his life. The trajectory of Pirous's “lifeworld” before and after this decision (pp. 5, 38) is the focus of this beautifully written ethnographic biography, Picturing Islam, by the anthropologist Kenneth M. George.
From his beginning as a humanist student of Dutch expats creating “bourgeois art” in a Bandung art institute in the 1950s (p. 28), Pirous was later accused of being a “propaganda artist” for the authoritarian “New Order” regime in the 1960s (p. 37), a “world artist” in the 1970s, and eventually a renowned “Indonesian,” “Acehnese,” and “Islamic” artist. Pirous's artistic positions changed in accordance with a series of inspirations, all inter-subjectively articulated with his audience. As such, the constantly shifting lifeworld of Pirous allows George to link decades of ethnographic friendship to larger questions about values, identity, and belonging across a couple of time periods.
The new artistic identity gave Pirous's life a fresh purpose and a new set of responsibilities. George describes this transformation as “a shift in moral and civic vision that led him to claim an Islamic heritage for the nation at large, a move that politically and aesthetically ties together the transcendental discourses of nation and faith” (p. 46). To picture Islam is to create fascinating visual arts that all Muslims can enjoy; even those who do not understand Arabic can potentially feel the awe of human religiosity, as delicately represented in the violet work, Meditation Toward the Enlightened Spirit (2000), that George chose to be on the cover of the book.
Pirous's colorful works hence have not only some “sensuous pull on the eye” (p. 104) but also an “ethical function” with broad appeal for an emerging Muslim art public. Central to this ethical function is the artist's sacrifice of his own artistic subjectivity for the sake of God's oneness. For Pirous, this involved learning correct Arabic calligraphy, ensuring its legibility, and amplifying its values to potential Muslim audiences. But as an artist he is still deeply modernist. He fuses the most exalted Islamic art, calligraphy, with the once most privileged form of Western modernism, abstraction (p. 79). He sometimes makes use of Jawi, the Indo-Malay language in Arabic script, making his art more “Indonesian.” His art then becomes a gesture of self-surrender to God by a person who has a local identity, which serves the ethical function to let all Indonesians and Muslims experience “visual dzikir” (p. 86), mindfulness of God.
The development of Pirous's painterly identity clearly speaks to a larger negotiation between Orientalism, the market, Islamic piety, individualism, and art. This book hence challenges many presumptions about “art”: What negotiations lie behind a finished work? What experiences of learning qualify the viewing of a particular kind of art? How do an artist and audience relate to expressions, oppositions, desires, pains, accusations, worldviews, boundaries, and schools?
Borrowing ideas from Hannah Arendt and anthropologist Michael Jackson, George sees that every person encounters in each moment the making and unmaking of his or her world by being a “who” and a “what” (pp. 5, 38, 104). Like A. D. Pirou, who makes himself an artist who has an Islamic and Indonesian identity, George distinguishes himself as an anthropologist by walking between art, religion, life history, cosmopolitism, and ethnography. Yet by engaging the question of subjectivity throughout the book, a central focus within current anthropological debates, Picturing Islam shows the ethical commitments both of Pirous to art and faith, and of George to art and anthropology.
It is still a rare insight in popular discourse and Western-influenced media that “being Muslim does not rest on unreflective acquiescence to the Qur'an, the hadith, syari'ah law, and religious authorities” (pp. 135–36). This book is another antidote to the representations of Muslims as religious automatons devoid of struggles, desires, and aspirations. Particularly rich in its depiction of the enmeshment of the spiritual, the hybrid, the elitist, and the improvised, the artistic journey documented by this work is another welcome balance to a lack of concern about the rich inner lives and creative expressions of Muslims. This volume also shows that art is never simply about some spontaneous “individual creativity,” but always about positionality, cultural sensitivity, ethnicity, national identity, religiosity, transnational experience, and political thinking. Who creates what art for whom? What does it mean to be marketable? For what aesthetic audience and by what aesthetic standard do we present and approach art objects? In general, the book is good for thinking about art, the market, international stratifications, identity, and community.
