In this lively and compelling monograph, cultural historian Andrew Haley chronicles the transformation of restaurant culture in Gilded Age America. Haley argues that there was a “deliberate class struggle” over dining that pitted a cosmopolitan middle class against a Francophile aristocratic elite (16). This struggle played out across a number of culinary fronts, including middle-class campaigns against tipping, the use of “cook's French” in menus, and a culinary imperialism that saw the middle class embrace adventurous new foods such as spaghetti, goulash, and sauerkraut in their successful attempt to overthrow the upper-class hegemony over the dining experience.
Haley begins his account with an earlier transformation that can be traced back to the 1820s with the opening of the famous Delmonico's restaurant in New York City. American elites embraced French haute cuisine, rich (both in economic and in gastronomic terms) fare, and elegant restaurants as evidence of their cultural superiority over the rest of American society. In elites’ social Darwinist conception of American culture, their superiority extended even to their palates. Only members of the upper class were sophisticated enough to enjoy foie gras or charlotte russe, while the other classes were best served by the simpler fare reflective of their station. Defenders of the middle-class disputed this, yet while aristocratic restaurants were theoretically open to their patronage, middle-class attempts to imitate their social betters were doomed to failure. As Haley notes, “The elite restaurant was an alien and unforgiving space,” with its expensive, French-language menu, dress code, and specific etiquette capable of tripping up all but the most experienced of diners (44). Individual decisions of middle-class consumers to seek out alternatives—“cosmopolitan” dining experiences, specifically middle-class restaurants, and elite restaurants willing to cater to middle-class consumers and their spending power—reshaped restaurants toward middle-class tastes. By the 1920s, restaurant culture largely existed in its modern form.
There is much to admire in this work. Haley evocatively recreates the world of both the aristocratic and middle-class restaurant, and his use of sample menus effectively illustrates the differences between elite and middle-class dining. He also demonstrates the limits of the middle-class dining revolution with a chapter on the failed middle-class crusade against tipping. Seen as largely un-American and a bribe that only aristocratic elites could afford, middle-class consumers sought to eliminate tips, either through pressure on restaurants or, through the wonders of technology, the creation of waiterless restaurants. The waiterless restaurants proved to be far too expensive or informal for diners, while previously cooperative restaurants balked at eliminating tips, viewing them as a way to keep service fees low. Without support from restaurants themselves, the middle-class dining revolution could only go so far.
By 2000, nearly every moderate-sized town in the United States had an Italian, Chinese, or Mexican restaurant. Perhaps the most interesting section of Turning the Tables is the chapter on the middle-class embrace of ethnic restaurants. Haley argues that their origin was part of a middle-class effort to “colonize” them as an alternative to the haughty aristocratic French establishments (94). Initially the province of self-styled, middle-class bohemians, by the dawn of the twentieth century, eating chop suey or chili con carne became a culinary adventure for urbanites and middle-class tourists alike. The embrace of multicultural cuisine allowed diners to express their superior worldliness in comparison with the French-obsessed elite, as well as the middle-class belief in democratic traditions—in this case, expressed through an egalitarian embrace of food. Paradoxically, Haley further notes that this cosmopolitan ideal failed to significantly change middle-class attitudes toward immigrants. The ethnic dining experience was primarily about the diners having a culinary adventure, not about the culture of their chosen cuisine or forming bonds with foreign restaurant owners.
Haley is largely persuasive in his arguments that the period between 1880 and 1920 saw a class struggle that played out, at least in part, in urban restaurants. However, he overstates his argument in asserting that the struggle over restaurant culture beginning in the 1880s aided middle-class efforts to become a cohesive modern class. A host of scholars have convincingly argued that the urban middle class had cohered much earlier, within the first decades of the nineteenth century.Footnote 1 Haley attempts to counter this argument by describing the middle class he discusses as “the new middle class,” made up of lawyers, clerks, and managers. What Haley uncovers, however, is not the coming together of the middle class, but rather the transformation of the middle class into the consumer class.
Haley also neglects one important dimension in his exploration of middle-class dining culture: space. Did the middle-class effort to unseat aristocratic restaurants include an assault on exclusive spaces in the American city? Did diners colonize ethnic enclaves as well as restaurants in their quest for the best weiner schnitzel? How did middle-class neighborhoods themselves change with the transformation of restaurants? Had Haley developed this element of his story, he may have connected his work to the extensive literature on middle-class efforts to reshape the city during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century and strengthened the urban elements of his argument.
These issues aside, Turning the Tables is a sumptuous dish for anyone interested in middle-class culture of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, as well as an important contribution to the growing historiography around restaurant and food history. It explores the origins of modern middle-class consumption patterns and effectively illuminates a previously neglected arena in which social conflicts between the classes played out.
