Sánchez Román's book is among a small but distinguished group of doctoral theses published as monographs this century that provide crucial contributions to the updating of the economic history of Argentina. This statement may seem over the top, as we are dealing with a book of regional history, but, partly due to this, that is what it amounts to. The book shows clearly the extent to which Argentina's agro-export growth during the ‘gran expansión’ was able to pull other sectors of the economy along in its wake. Although based on a different case study, it complements Fernando Rocchi's research into industry, among other works. It overturns, at least for Tucumán, the old orthodoxy that contrasted the Pampa economy's integration into world markets and agro-export development with the industrial and economic trajectory of the interior; the truth is quite the opposite, as the sugar sector, with significant state support, took advantage of the growth of the coastal market and of the modernisation of the economy to become the main supplier to the domestic market. Of course, this argument is not entirely new. Classic studies by Jorge Balán in the 1970s, for example, showed the lobbying strength of the Tucumán elite, and the receptivity of the national political system to certain regional demands. Similarly, the modernisation and growth of the sugar sector were well known. But on the back of a significantly wider literature than its introduction suggests, the book under review provides a systematic, solid and convincing study of the development of this industry and its impact on the provincial economy of Tucumán. It does so by confirming the initial assertion in a style that is both even-handed and well-founded; it does not attempt to shoehorn the argument into a given theory, but rather presents an historical process in all its richness, complexity and ambiguity.
The opening chapter sets out the initial stages of the sector's economic growth in Tucumán (1853–76), indicating from the start one of the main strands of the study, namely the financial mechanisms (still rudimentary at this stage) obtaining in the province. Chap. 2 engages with a long-standing debate about the role of railway development, which reached the province in 1876 by dint of state construction and was subsequently handed over to private capital. Sánchez Román's analysis highlights the complexity of this development, with significant peaks affecting each of the four lines that serve the region, and involving interaction with the authorities at the national and provincial levels as well as the sugar industry and sugar planters. His arguments minimising the impact of the railways on sugar development are not entirely convincing, however. Although it is true that economic take-off came some years after the arrival of the railways, this may be said to be a predictable lag attributable to a range of factors and does not in itself contradict the importance of transport modernisation for growth, as the author knows. The third chapter deals with the development of a financial system in Tucumán and its links with the sugar industry. This shows the importance of state institutions, above all in the early stages of the industrial spurt in the 1880s, and the subsequent growth of the private banking sector, along with more complex mechanisms of industrial finance.
The fourth chapter engages with the crucial issue of tariff protection for the development of the sugar industry, and the role of political elites and the business lobby in ensuring profits in an industry that was hampered by formal disadvantage – a climate that was not ideal for growing sugarcane. This restricted the scope of the product to the protected domestic market, meaning that the 1890 crisis (chap. 5), with its accompanying currency devaluation, had a comparatively limited effect on the sector. By contrast, the stimulus to investment facilitated by fierce protectionism led to an overproduction crisis in the mid-1890s and at the beginning of the twentieth century. The national government again came to the sector's aid, even to the extent of providing export subsidies, until international norms restricted the practice. This led to the province trying to regulate supply by limiting production. Finally, chap. 6 deals with the mature phase of the industry at the beginning of the twentieth century, with a central state less enthusiastic in its support, although far from leaving the industry out in the cold. Again, the emphasis is on the development of the financial market, which, despite reduced government benevolence, managed to sustain a further period of increased production up to 1912.
This panoramic survey is enhanced by judicious use of comparative reference that, rather than seeking to squeeze Tucumán into a broad Latin American model, uses studies of other well-favoured regions, in both financial and productive terms, to illuminate, by way of similarities and contrasts, the process under consideration. It is to be regretted, however, that little attention is paid to other developing sugar industries in Argentina – in Salta, Jujuy and El Chaco – which, although smaller in scale, could provide an excellent opportunity to assess the development of Tucumán and to highlight the factors that helped or hindered the region. Admittedly this omission can be explained by the absence of high-quality publications on the subject, but it is certainly something that ought to be rectified.
The final assessment by the author is that the active part played by the central state in the fostering of the sugar industry, mainly through railway construction, financial mechanisms and tariff protection, led to a dynamic business sector in Tucumán being able to establish a thriving economic hub that underpinned the development of the province, enabling it to outperform several of its neighbours. Against expectations, this subsidised development did not give rise to excessive industrial concentration, or to the total subordination of sugarcane growers, although neither of these tendencies was entirely absent. Sánchez Román, for his part, concludes that protectionism fostered an excessive focus on sugar production, which would in the long term be one of the main weaknesses of the Tucumán economy.
This leads to a question that the author is unfortunately reluctant to discuss in depth. Did the possibility really exist for Tucumán to diversify production to some other equally profitable sector that would have been less dependent on the protection of the state? Surely the sugar rush depended to a large extent on the existence of a local entrepreneurial bourgeoisie, able to achieve the necessary political support to establish an industry despite conditions not being wholly favourable. Was sugar the only option, or were other possibilities overlooked? In any event, the subsidy that consumers on the coast provided to the Tucumán economy by means of state protection was an efficient method of reducing regional rift, enabling the region to share in some of the benefits of the agro-export growth of the Pampas, and was more efficient than the straight injection of public funding.
