Over the past couple of decades previously dominant models of state power as centralised, hierarchical and bureaucratic machines have been eclipsed by theories of ‘governance by networks’. Public administration began to be posed as a problem mainly of coordination and reciprocity across multilateral threads of public, private and voluntary sectors (and/or civil society) rather than one determined by top-down command and control systems imposed by unilateral state power. Collaboration, empowerment and partnership became terms used routinely to foster a self-image for the ‘networked polity’ at every scale of governance, whether local, regional, national or trans-national. Network governance conjures up perceptions of loose coalitions, contingent connections and porous institutions, adaptable, pragmatic and responsive to changing environmental conditions. Horizontal relations based on ‘soft power’, trust, inter-dependencies and social capital can also appear more ethical than vertical relations of coercion, command, subordination and hierarchy.
It is not just that ‘governance’ has replaced government, but that post-national societies in their entirety are more networked, dispersed, plural and fluid, stimulating new, contingent configurations of policy, politics, cultural, economics and society, a thesis put most comprehensively by Manuel Castells in his opus The Network Society (largely ignored in this book). Clearly, the use of network as a metaphor for society expressed the coming to cultural dominance of emerging information and communications technologies, just as at earlier stages of development we had ‘industrial society’, ‘the technostructure’ or ‘the machine age’.
In a sustained counterblast against the pretensions of network governance theory, Jonathan Davies proposes that it should instead be re-cast as a species of neoliberal ideology. Although variants of network theory have been around since at least the 1930s (longer if Georg Simmel's social geometry is taken into account), Davies traces the more recent paradigm shift towards ‘post-traditional governance theory’ formed out of a range of apparently disparate academic theories, from Urban Regime Theory and ‘adaptive leadership’ studies all the way through to Marxist refuseniks like Hardt and Negri.
As it entered the field of governance and policy, network theory, like neo-liberal political economy, acquired the air of a self-fulfilling prophecy, exercising what Pierre Bourdieu called a ‘theory effect’. Not that that neoliberal ideology is in any way coherent or its influence unidirectional. Network governance theory too often rests on unwarranted assertions, weak evidence and flawed reasoning to build a picture of social disorganisation, historical discontinuities and contingent associations. This optic too often neglects or relegates the force of structural continuities and causal powers in the reproduction of class, capital and state.
Few academic theories proved to be as influential with policy makers and politicians as Anthony Giddens and Ulrich Beck's ‘reflexive modernisation’ thesis. Emboldened by the retreat of organised labour, New Labour adopted the secondhand language of Gidden's Third Way. Here positive group-speak about consensus, collaboration and partnership aimed to transform the language of class, solidarity and resistance into what Ulrich Beck termed ‘zombie categories’. With the decline of class-based ‘industrial society’ and with the satisfaction of material needs more or less guaranteed, deracinated individuals now feel more exposed to increased levels of ontological insecurity, brought on primarily by environmental risk. Ontological security is re-established, Giddens argues, when individuals fearlessly respect difference in plural networks founded on mutual trust.
Not all versions of network governance are self-confirming. Foucauldian research on neoliberal governmentalities indicates some of the ways in which domination is inscribed into the techniques of ‘government at a distance’ to produce self-policing subjects. Nonetheless, Davies notes that studies in a Foucauldian vein tend to displace the role of state power as a directly coercive force and understate the play of oppositional resistance. Critical versions of network governance are threatened with ideological recuperation, as when managerial ideology adopts the language and practices of new social movements in an attempt to restore profitability to ailing corporations.
In an attempt to place definite limits on this danger, Davies outlines a classical Marxist conception of the state-capital nexus. Network governance ascends to policy hegemony in conditions of neoliberal political economy. This does not mean that state coercion is suspended. By returning to Gramsci's approach to hegemony and the state, governance ideology can be shown to be plagued by insurmountable limits and contradictions, both in reality and intellectually. Under the coercive logic of accumulation and a pathological propensity to societal-wide crises, a systemic logic is imposed on the state. Using Gramsci's idea of the ‘integral state’, Davies indicates how certain nation-states, notably the UK, actively transformed the classical Keynesian welfare state by deploying the blunt instrument of coercion, as during the British miners strike of 1984–85, to pave the way by the 1990s for network ideology to become the common sense reflex of neo-liberal public policy.
Drawing partly on Bourdieu to buttress Gramsci's ‘integral state’, Davies also claims that a radical gap, ‘a fatal flaw’, exists between network governance as a self-justificatory ideology and the clash of class interests in a reformulated capitalist political economy. Whenever hegemony stalls, institutional domination, pure and simple, lies ready to hand. An ability to shift from soft governance to hard government enables public managers to instil rigid discipline and conformity contrary to the consensual partnerships and flexible creativity advocated by network ideologists.
Social network analysis remains a vital weapon in the social science armoury, as Davies rightly insists, although he is less interested in developing it as a methodological tool than in making a general theoretical critique of network governance as neoliberal ideology. Other work, such as John Krinsky's (Reference Krinsky2007) molecular study of workfare and collective action in New York city, demonstrates the value of social network analysis for a Gramscian approach to contentious social policies. Davies concludes with a call to arms for a critical scholarship in contact with oppositional movements. By restoring Gramsci's notion of the integral state, Davies lays out a powerful critique of current calls to order in social policy and public services.
