Women made their first widespread entry into the paid labor force during the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Most scholarship on this subject has focused on women in the industrializing cities of the Northeast and Midwest. By examining parallel developments in Los Angeles, Eileen V. Wallis's new book, Earning Power, extends knowledge of the characteristics of women's work in large cities, while suggesting that the key themes in women's labor history from the 1880s through the 1920s have a national reach even as the particular details vary according to local conditions.
New railroad lines opened in the 1880s, connecting Los Angeles to national networks of trade and transportation. Manufactured goods traveled from east to west in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth century, as did people and ideas, with clubwomen arriving from Boston, settlement house workers from Chicago, and labor organizers from New York City. These migrants to Los Angeles established new branches of existing organizations beset by many of the same problems: Middle-class reformers were often condescending to the white working class women whom they chose as their objects of assistance; and wage-earning women had difficulty asserting their interests in trade and labor unions dominated by men.
The late development of manufacturing in Los Angeles (which did not really pick up until after 1900) and its relatively large Asian and Mexican population created a distinctive racial hierarchy. Native-born white women gained access to the widest choice of jobs, including coveted positions as saleswomen. The benefits of whiteness extended to European immigrants, who found greater access to white collar positions in Los Angeles than in eastern cities. Meanwhile, most Asian, Mexican, and African American women were lumped together as “colored.” The small population of Asian women had particular difficulty finding employment, although Asian men often worked as domestic servants or ran small businesses. Elite Mexican women characterized themselves as Spanish in order to distinguish themselves from the “colored” masses who labored as servants, seamstresses, or cannery workers. African American women, who often migrated to Los Angeles with some savings, dealt with segregation by opening their own small businesses and forming their own networks of social support.
Wallis takes a broad view of her subject matter, considering women employed in any kind of income-generating labor, from teaching to domestic service. Wallis also includes working men's wives who mobilized to support drives for the union label as well as female real estate developers and petty entrepreneurs. Although this sweep is impressive, the variety of women encompassed in this study makes it difficult for Wallis to draw conclusions from her data beyond observing consistent trends of gender, racial, and ethnic inequity.
Wallis addresses issues of occupational segregation throughout the book, arguing that “racial exclusion and subjugation offered white female workers in Los Angeles some very real material advantages, from inclusion in some unions to the attention of social reformers” (8). Like their counterparts in San Francisco, white workers in Los Angeles invoked the “yellow peril” in their organizing drives. In the 1880s, white cooks, waiters, and waitresses established a strong union by boycotting restaurants that hired Asian workers. The strategy backfired in 1914, when the city council forbade the employment of white women in Chinese- or Japanese-owned cafes. In the 1910s, L.A. workers in steam laundries attempted to gain public support for their organizing drives by characterizing Asian laundries as dirty and dangerous to public health.
Racist appeals added to the fragmentation of the labor force and failed to address the real divisions between male and female workers, which included a large wage gap and male dominance of union leadership. However, the United Garment Workers (which reached peak strength in 1915) took a new approach: By hiring female organizers and reaching out to workers across lines of ethnicity, it formed one of the stronger unions in the city.
The Merchants and Manufacturers Association (M & M) strongly opposed any workers' attempt to organize. The M & M exercised considerable sway with the Los Angeles City Council, which required permits to speak in public parks and made picketing illegal. The strong anti-labor bias of the city's major newspaper, the Los Angeles Times, further hampered workers' efforts to gain public support for their unions. Despite the establishment of a city labor federation and major organizing drives launched by socialists and trade unionists from the 1890s through the 1910s, the M & M largely succeeded in its objective of making Los Angeles the open-shop alternative to San Francisco. The dispersed geography of the city created additional impediments to effective organization.
Wallis considers the politics as well as the economics of women's work. In 1911, working women joined a successful statewide campaign to win votes for women. The Wage Earner's Suffrage League held the first open-air suffrage meetings in Los Angeles. They creatively circumvented city laws against picketing and public speaking by singing in public parks and handing out doughnuts tagged “Votes for Women.”
In keeping with national patterns, the cross-class coalition of women that formed around suffrage quickly fractured. However, women's enfranchisement, along with the election of Progressive and Socialist candidates, led to new protective labor laws in California. Organized labor opposed the low minimum wage for women, fearing that it would undercut union wage rates. Unionized workers, however, benefited the most from the legislation because they were able to exercise some influence with the state's Industrial Welfare Commission. As in other states, protective labor legislation excluded domestic and agricultural workers, suggesting a national unwillingness to view households as workplaces or to interfere with the exploitative labor practices that drove the expansion of commercial agriculture.
Earning Power illuminates an important and as yet understudied chapter in the story of urban women's work in the United States during the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Wallis demonstrates how gender and ethnicity shaped patterns of economic development in Los Angeles, and how politics and economics informed each other.
