The crisis in southern politics and race relations in the 1890s was an episode of considerable consequence for all three of these books, but each of them approaches this crisis from a different direction and perspective.
In Radical Reform, Deborah Beckel shows how North Carolina Republicans' initiative for change—which included universal male suffrage, legal and civil equality, public schools, and economic development—did not die out after the party lost control of the state in the mid-1870s. Rather, reform persisted throughout the 1880s and 1890s and even broadened as new issues arose. As a result, opposition to the ascendant Democratic Party continued, and it consisted of the still-viable Republicans and their electoral allies, the new political parties created by the reformers. Because a large number of Republican voters and officials were African American, these coalitions were biracial in character, although racism was still much in evidence among white Republicans and their partners in the reform parties.
During the post-Reconstruction years, these reformers were a diverse group. They consisted, in the late 1880s, of advocates of workers' rights who were active in the Knights of Labor, opponents of Prohibition who saw the banning of alcohol as a conformist attack on personal liberty (they created the Anti-Prohibition, or Liberal, party in the early 1880s), and farmers in the 1890s protesting their worsening economic and social conditions through the Farmers' Alliance and the reformist People's Party. Because of these activist reformers and dissenters and their willingness to form electoral alliances with the Republicans, an ongoing, coordinated alternative to the status quo and its upholders, the conservative, white supremacist Democratic Party, was often available. By the mid-1890s, this opposition, consisting of Republicans and Populists calling themselves the Fusion Party, mounted such a strong challenge that it actually won control of the legislature in 1894 and the governorship in 1896. Sadly, Fusion's victory was short-lived because the Democrats were so incensed at their loss of power that they unleashed a massive campaign based on white supremacy, violence, and disfranchisement that eliminated both the Republican and Populist Parties and ensured Democratic hegemony well into the next century. This defeat marked the end of the post-war experience of reform and party competition.
Beckel's account of the struggle to sustain the reform impulse generated by the reconstruction of the state and the creation of the Republican Party offers a distinct perspective on this reasonably well-known phenomenon of a continuing alternative to the Democrats after Reconstruction, not only in North Carolina but elsewhere in the South as well. Beckel's take is distinctive because she focuses on the reformers themselves, introducing a number of unfamiliar but often colorful protagonists who give the story a “bottom-up” angle. The trouble with this approach is that the reformers appear only as individuals, while the reform organizations and political parties with which they are connected remain rather shadowy and undefined. The large number of individuals appearing in the pages of this book becomes hard to follow and differentiate, particularly because the author includes officials in the two major parties, the Democrats and Republicans, as well. This assortment of reformers and politicians is further disaggregated by the book's organization as a chronological narrative, rather than by issue or development. The result is a chronicle that is unstructured and unnecessarily confusing. Related to this is a second problem. Even though the author does, at several points, suggest an overarching explanation or interpretation, it is merely asserted, rather than demonstrated. The motor driving these reform activities is said to be “the pro-democracy movement,” yet this movement is never identified, and any pro-democracy sentiment or vision is not elaborated.
Jim Crow Citizenship, Marek D. Steedman's study of “Liberalism and the Southern Defense of Racial Hierarchy,” makes a contribution to the ongoing attempt by political scientists and historians to identify the political ideology that has been most formative and influential in the history of the United States. Is it “liberalism” as defined by Louis Hartz in his landmark book, The Liberal Tradition in America (1955), a tradition that Hartz called “Lockean liberalism,” in which individuals possessing rights and interests compete freely? Or is it the ideology called “republicanism” that instead emphasizes community and civic virtue, rather than individual competition? Or perhaps there are “multiple traditions,” namely liberalism, republicanism, and also an ascriptive, hierarchical tradition, which are constantly present but either operating independently or interacting with each other in some way, as proposed by Rogers Smith in his Civic Ideals (1997). Steedman who, like Hartz and Smith, is a political scientist, enters the fray by arguing that America's primary identity and tradition has been liberalism, but it has always been restricted by the continuing presence and inclusion of ascriptive, primarily racial, categories. These hierarchical features assume that not all people in America are freely competing and contracting individuals because many social groups have been considered dependent and subordinate and have accordingly been excluded.
As the subtitle of Steedman's book indicates, the nineteenth- and early twentieth-century South practiced a restricted, ascriptive version of liberalism. This started during slavery when, Steedman claims, only those who were heads of household were considered independent and autonomous citizens. By contrast, women, children, and slaves, all of them members of the family and possessions governed and owned by the household head, were deemed dependent and subordinate. This attenuated liberalism Steedman calls “paternalist liberalism.”
The abolition of slavery and the granting of civil and political rights to the ex-slaves after the Civil War altered the terms of this structure, and the crisis that resulted was, in Steedman's words, a “crisis of mastery.” This crisis was contained when the masters, who were now employers of their former slaves, gained control over the freedmen's labor through enacting legislation that restricted sharecroppers' rights as laborers and through exploiting their indebtedness as a mechanism for creating dependency. As for the ex-slaves' political rights, Steedman argues that the South's planter politicians were initially convinced that their employees would vote loyally for them (they referred to their votes as “dead votes”), a prediction that quickly turned out (and actually sooner than Steedman imagines) to be completely erroneous.
At this point, roughly the decade after Reconstruction, a second “crisis of mastery” occurred. Despite their employers' efforts to control them and keep them dependent, African Americans continued to claim, and sometimes exercise, their legal and civil rights. They voted continually, despite the intimidation rained down on them. The remedy for this insubordination was drastic, and it was imposed in the 1890s by segregation and disfranchisement. From this new relationship arose a new ideology. Because blacks were now a subjugated social group, Steedman categorizes this ideology rather awkwardly as “civil subordination liberalism.” Unlike the personal and implied “paternalist liberalism” of the slavery era, this new version of ascriptive liberalism was structured and formal. Furthermore, because household heads were no longer responsible for their underlings, the Democratic-controlled state governments of the South, which had just implemented segregation and disfranchisement, assumed the role of supervisor.
Exactly how the southern states would undertake this responsibility was formulated by the region's progressives, who arose in the first decade of the twentieth century in the wake of the disfranchisement campaigns. According to Steedman, these urban, middle- to upper-class reformers accepted the white supremacist Jim Crow system and offered both a rationale and an ameliorative, seemingly benevolent, dimension to the new racial order. They viewed blacks as a “child-race” in need of protection by the state. As “wards of the state,” blacks would benefit from the “civilizing” effect of progressive reforms, such as prohibition of alcohol and access to segregated public education. Although the author does not indicate what else the progressives had in mind to help African Americans, their paternalistic description of them as a “child-race” seems to be sufficient to make the case he is outlining. In effect, he argues that the progressives provided a legitimacy for the new order that mollified white southerners. Furthermore, this new order with its progressive patina seems also to have been acceptable to the rest of the nation because the Supreme Court and other federal institutions as well as public opinion acquiesced in, maybe even approved of, this rigidly hierarchical system based on race. It lasted more than half a century before it was repudiated in the 1960s.
In the book's conclusion, the author regrets that the ending of “civil subordination liberalism” has not resulted in the achievement of “free contract liberalism,” which is the term he uses to describe the unrestricted, non-hierarchical liberalism that had been lacking since the nation's founding. Indeed, categories of discrimination and dependency are still operative and recognized in American society. Rather than being the essence of American identity and citizenship, “free contract liberalism” is therefore, in Steedman's opinion, a goal yet to be attained.
Of course, this synopsis of Jim Crow Citizenship simplifies its content and argument, because the book is not an historical account, but rather a treatise, or formal argument, setting out a theory of American political identity and defending it against anticipated criticisms and counterarguments. Steedman argues his challenging and provocative thesis forcefully and knowledgeably. Nevertheless, several aspects invite comment. In the first place, it is ironic that the liberalism that Hartz depicted as political reality in America has become, in Steedman's understanding, an ideal to be pursued until it is fully realized. Yet Hartz deplored the liberalism he had discovered, not only because of its promotion of individual materialism and acquisitiveness, but also because of its universal acceptance as the norm of American political thought and practice, which produced a conformity that he denounced as “a stifling consensus.”
Some questions also arise from this provocative thesis. First, the terms “paternalist” and “civil subordination,” which Steedman employs as qualifiers of liberalism, are euphemisms that seem to contradict the author's claim that race was the essence of the South's systems of slavery and Jim Crow. Furthermore, the meaning of the nation's apparent acquiescence in the South's system of “civil subordination liberalism” is unclear. Does it mean that the non-South has a similar “civil subordination liberalism”? Or is the South's version, which is so overwhelmingly racial, just a different form of civil subordination from the subordination of women, children, native Americans, and even ethnic groups found outside the South? And finally, the ideal of “free contract liberalism,” where all citizens are free and no longer subordinate in any way, seems unattainable, except in a utopian society.
The third book in this review is Shawn Leigh Alexander's An Army of Lions, which is an institutional history of the Afro-American League, 1890–94, and its reconstitution in 1898 as the National Afro-American Council that then continued for another decade. These two institutions can be considered the nation's first civil rights organization. Some of its leaders are well known to historians, such as the organization's founder, T. Thomas Fortune, as well as Ida B. Wells-Barnett, William Monroe Trotter, Bishop Alexander Walters, Mary Church Terrell, Congressman George H. White of North Carolina, and not least Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois. Most of them are the subjects of full-length biographies, even multi-volume biographies in the case of the last two. But the organization they formed and led has been treated as a marginal force in the history of black protest. Alexander's study is a much-needed corrective to this regrettable oversight.
Judging from the notes to Alexander's book (unfortunately there is no bibliography), one of the reasons for this neglect may be the paucity of documentation of the council's proceedings and deliberations. The author, however, combed the personal papers and biographies of the major figures and added to these sources the coverage by contemporary African American newspapers, which reported on the organization's annual conventions and published its press releases. The result is a very thorough account of the council's history, which demonstrates convincingly that organized protest against black oppression did not begin in 1908 with the Niagara Movement. Instead, it had commenced twenty years earlier when the assault was launched on the post-emancipation gains and rights of African Americans, primarily in the southern states where most blacks lived, but also outside the South and at the national level.
Faced with such a massive attack operating on many fronts, the founders of the Afro-American League considered it essential in 1890 for African Americans to make their resistance known in no uncertain terms and that this response be centralized and coordinated. To this end, the council gathered and disseminated information about the numerous episodes and instances of resistance; it grappled with the strategic question of how blacks should resist; and it created a central organization, with an executive committee and also a national convention that met annually, along with the formation of state and local branches. Of course, the kinds of direct action that arose in the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s, such as civil disobedience, community mobilization, and marches, were not even considered as appropriate civil rights tactics in this earlier phase. Instead, this civil rights organization engaged in a broad range of peaceful agitation by encouraging local boycotts against discriminatory institutions both public and private, by mobilizing opinion against lynching and mob violence against blacks, by publicly denouncing and actively countering hostile Jim Crow legislation, and by using the court system where cases challenging the constitutionality of segregation and disfranchisement could generate publicity and hopefully produce significant, even decisive, remedies. Soon, court cases became a major activity of the council because there was more chance of convincing a court than a legislative body of these measures' unconstitutionality.
The Afro-American Council was clearly, as Alexander demonstrates, an organization of significance. At its 1903 convention, for example, the nearly 400 delegates represented ninety-eight state and local branches. Moreover, the national leadership contained notably talented and respected members of the black professional elite, mainly newspaper editors, lawyers, and educators, alongside a few clergymen and public officials. These people comprised a who's who of black Americans, although businessmen were noticeably absent. Unfortunately, this group of significant and articulate people with ideas of their own soon became prey to competition and rivalry, leading to dissension and division. This became particularly severe when Washington became active in the council after 1900 as part of an attempt to contain the council's influence as a rival to his own more conciliatory agenda and his Tuskegee Machine.
The organization encountered several other problems. First, its leaders found themselves unable to make contact with the majority of African Americans and constantly lamented the lack of grassroots support. Second, the Afro-American Council was unable to obtain sufficient funds to finance its operations adequately or to support its protest activity to the degree that was needed. Finally, the council's agitation produced few successes. Their efforts to stall, let alone stop, the momentum of the assault on African Americans' civil and political rights made very little impression. This ineffectiveness must have contributed further to the frustrations and divisions among the leaders. Although the author does not offer an overall evaluation and explanation of the council's lack of success, it would seem that the situation confronting the council was so overpowering and the financial resources available to blacks so minuscule that any hope of stopping, even slowing, the juggernaut was negligible.
Despite this lack of success and the demise of the Afro-American Council in 1908, the struggle to protect African Americans from white oppression did not come to an end, for the Niagara Movement continued the fight. Many of the council's leading figures were prominent in the Niagara Movement, and its civil rights approach to resistance, especially its strategy of using the courts to challenge Jim Crow, was adopted by both the Niagara Movement and the NAACP. Rather than being replaced by these two organizations, Alexander argues that the council merged with them in terms of personnel and civil rights strategy. Thus, the Afro-American Council played a founding and formative role in the civil rights protest movement against Jim Crow in the South and against racial discrimination more generally at the beginning of the twentieth century. Shawn Alexander's An Army of Lions has therefore restored the council to its rightful place, an important achievement.
