In River of Dark Dreams Walter Johnson presents an innovative and powerful account of the cotton kingdom in the Lower Mississippi Valley. Johnson has drawn from environmental, social, economic, political, intellectual, and cultural history in order to produce a major interpretative account that challenges the ways we think about US history, Atlantic history, and, indeed, world history. The conceptual ambition of this work, the scope and depth of its analysis, the skill with which it written, and its wealth of insights and hypotheses guarantee that it will be the subject of discussion for a long time to come.
The book is the history of the making of the cotton kingdom, but it is fair to say that it is also the story of the history cotton made. Johnson's distinctive approach combines a broad economic and political analysis with sensitivity to the concern for cultural construction of social relations and categories of thought, and contested social meanings that have emerged after the cultural turn. He conjoins the material history of cotton production with the history of capitalism in order to explicate the forces that transformed and ordered nature and society in the Mississippi Valley. At the same time, he is attentive to the contingent factors and social actions that made such an ordering possible. In this way he skillfully weaves together environment, technology, labor, slavery, race, world market, and political power into a comprehensive interpretation that discloses the historical interdependence of these various relations and illuminates numerous points of intersection that enrich his interpretation. In so doing, he makes a compelling argument for the capitalist character of slavery, the importance of the South for US economic development, and the transnational scope of the Southern Cotton Kingdom.
One of the great strengths of River of Dark Dreams is that Johnson places the working activity of enslaved people at the center of his conception of economy. The growing world demand for cotton transformed not only the economic geography of the South, but slave production itself. The pressures of the world market and the increasing scale of cotton production encouraged quantification, measurement, and calculation of both nature and labor. Johnson traces how planter obsession with the calculus of bales of cotton per acre per hand was translated into the imposition of gang labor and a brutal system of labor discipline that dramatically increased output. He draws an analytical distinction between “work” (the application of human energy to the natural world that produces a material object) and “labor” (the expenditure of the slave's energy for the master that results an exchangeable commodity represented by value and price). This distinction allows him to construct a pathbreaking cultural interpretation of the complex interplay of material process, power, and resistance that shaped the world of work on the cotton plantation.
From the cotton fields, Johnson follows the journey of a single bale of cotton down the Mississippi River to New Orleans and then on to New York and Liverpool. This journey depended upon the collaboration of diverse actors including plantation slaves, stevedores, sailors, factors, and merchants who transported the cotton across the Atlantic and animate the relation between Mississippi plantations and Manchester cotton mills. Johnson further delineates the less transparent movement of consignment, credit, debt, and speculation that mirrored the physical movement of cotton and transformed the bale into a commodity represented by abstract measures of quantity, quality, and price. This double movement at once closed the circuit of the cotton bale and made possible its renewal.
These intertwined narratives are at the heart of Johnson's case for the capitalist character of slavery and for his understanding of the transnational regional history of the South. They demonstrate the manifold and intricate ways Mississippi cotton and slavery were materially and socially woven into the capitalist world-economy, and indicate the interdependence and mutual formation of the plantation and the factory, slave labor and capital (wage labor). Through them, Johnson provides a window through which to reinterpret slavery that takes us beyond older interpretations of the laziness, inefficiency, backwardness of slave labor or econometric models of the profitability and productivity of slave economies. Indeed, his empirically grounded descriptions of the historical interrelation and interdependence of slave production and world market offer the opportunity to reformulate and reconceptualize the relation of capitalism and slavery.
Nevertheless, Johnson has declined to address the conceptual issues raised by his own work. Instead, he briefly rehearses the old market vs. mode of production debates, and then he seems to throw up his hands in frustration. He declares: “What . . . if we set aside prefabricated questions and threadbare tautologies, and simply began with a bale of cotton?” (254). His reaction is in many ways understandable. Market and production, waged and nonwaged labor have been continually opposed to one another in various contexts since at least the 1950s. Each iteration of the opposition of these reified categories has produced abstract, partial, and one-sided accounts that have congealed into orthodoxies. Perhaps this is good reason to bypass these well-rehearsed alternatives. Yet one suspects that empirical narratives that simply describe “how it works,” no matter how compelling and nuanced they may be, will not succeed in preventing new wine from being poured into old bottles. Without addressing the conceptual issues entailed in the problem of understanding capitalism and slavery together Johnson's rich reconstructions will doubtlessly continue to be forced into old frameworks.
For this very reason, Johnson's decision not to address the theoretical implications of his own work represents a missed opportunity. He has put us in a position to go beyond the old analytical and interpretive frameworks that he understandably rejects. However, without a reconceptualization of the problem we lack the tools to fully exploit either his empirical account of the Mississippi Cotton Kingdom or the general formulation of “capitalist slavery” presented in River of Dark Dreams. Imagine for a moment many studies of different slave regions of the Western hemisphere—Barbados, Saint Domingue, Jamaica, Brazil, Cuba. Each study executed with the brilliance of River of Dark Dreams, and each demonstrating the capitalist character of slavery by showing its linkages—material, economic, political—with world capitalism. Despite the undoubted value of such an ensemble of studies, such an approach necessarily excludes from consideration the historical processes that structure the capitalist world-economy as a whole and the relations among its constituent elements. Why did the wealth produced by US cotton slavery prove so central to the structuring of world capitalism while the wealth generated by slave-grown sugar or coffee did not have such wide repercussions? How did processes of world capital-accumulation shape the differences between and relations among the various slave regimes of the Americas or other forms of social production elsewhere in world economy? Without an adequate conceptual framework, such questions slip from view.
While the River of Dark Dreams contains descriptive accounts of particular circuits and linkages, it offers no explicit concept of global capitalism or world economy as a structured historical whole in which to theoretically specify historical particulars. (In this regard, it may be more appropriate to regard this as a transnational study rather than a study of world capitalism.) Beyond ideographic description, it offers no means to differentiate slavery in the Mississippi Valley from slavery in other times and places or to comprehend the making and remaking of slave relations as part of the historical development of capitalist world-economy. Without general organizing concepts, we are unable to theoretically ground particular complexes of historical relations, including slavery in the Mississippi Valley, nor can we go beyond the general terms of capitalist slavery that Johnson posits here in order to register changes in world economy itself. We cannot understand the organization of the world-economic whole by summing up its individual parts.
These comments take us beyond Johnson's purposes in writing a history of the Mississippi Valley Cotton Kingdom. River of Dark Dreams has been justly praised for its powerful argument for the transnational character of slavery in the Lower Mississippi Valley and for the capitalist character of slavery. But good books are often good not only because of what they contain, but because they raise questions and suggest perspectives that go beyond themselves. River of Dark Dreams is a very good book.
