For many scholars in Nepali and Himalayan studies, Maoists at the Hearth is a long-awaited monograph. This is the first book-length ethnography of a village in Nepal before, during, and after the ten-year civil war/“People's War”/“Maoist insurgency” from 1996 to 2006 (hereafter “civil war”) in English. The author, Judith Pettigrew, who has carried out her fieldwork in the village of Kwei Nasa near Pokhara mainly inhabited by Tamu-mai (also known as Gurungs), is one of the very small number of anthropologists who started their fieldwork in hill Nepal years before the war affected their own research area, and have visited the same place regularly, even during the height of the war. To be sure, much has been written on the civil war in Nepal and its aftermath in English as well as in several other languages, notably French, German, and Japanese, let alone Nepali, by various scholars, journalists, and activists. While these books and articles have been, and will certainly be, the inevitable sources to understand the civil war, no book-length monograph exists which situates village-level incidents and changing discourses on the civil war in a particular place chronologically within the multi-layered and fluctuating political and sociocultural contexts on a solid ethnographic basis. This book certainly fills this gap.
As the author discusses in detail in the Introduction, writing an ethnography on “how everyday life and social relationships are reshaped in war” (p. 1) has peculiar methodological and practical difficulties. First, she had to face severe constraints in fieldwork and writing during the war. Often people could not speak openly on the war, and even asking certain questions might jeopardize them. To make detailed field notes could be dangerous both for the ethnographer and for the people with whom she spoke. She had to be extremely cautious not only about the privacy of the people but also with various other tiny ethnographic details, lest they should be utilized either by the security forces, the Royal Nepal Army, or the Maoists. One also had to avoid overgeneralization or oversimplification by afterthought, as “Each time I returned to the village the situation had changed significantly, even when the previous visit had only been a couple of months before” (p. 20). Various moral issues existed as well. The author's basic strategy here was to write this book as a memoir, as her eyewitness account of concrete situations. Throughout the seven chapters of the book, thus, various incidents are arranged chronologically from her first visit to the village of Kwei Nasa in 1991 to a few years after the first Constituent Assembly election (2011).
The title of the first chapter, “The Village of Kwei Nasa in 1991–92,” fully explains its contents. Various ethnographic accounts, on space and place, on death rituals, on emigration and military culture, on the hidden aspect of social life and “inner talk” (norbe taa), and on ethnopsychology (mainly through the concept of saẽ [heart-mind]), are skilfully arranged within the narrative of the trajectory of her field research for her PhD dissertation and her short revisits to the village in the 1990s. For me, each paragraph of this chapter seems like an abridged version of a section of her ethnography of Kwei Nasa, which would have been written if there had been no civil war. In due course, readers are also introduced to several villagers, mainly “politically nonaligned, predominantly middle-aged and elderly, middle-income women” (p. 2), with their distinct voices, characters, and pseudonyms.
In the first half of Chapter 2 the author describes her revisit to Kwei Nasa in early 2000. Maoists were already active in the area by then, though they visited the village only occasionally. The latter half consists of a description of the situation in Kathmandu during her short visit in December 2001, a week after King Gyanendra imposed a state of emergency, and an account of various interviews of people affected by the conflict she conducted with NGO staff, in the Kathmandu valley and several Tarai districts (she was based in Nepalganj) in 2002, juxtaposing voices of various people she interviewed, as well as her own experiences.
Chapters 3 and 4 are the accounts of her short visits to Kwei Nasa, with her new assistant Kamal Adhikari, in July and December 2002 respectively. The situation in the village, as well as relations between villagers and Maoists, had changed substantially between the two visits. Dhan Kumari, the author's “elder sister,” told her, “When you were here in the summer, we were frightened of them [the Maoists]. […] We had four hundred of the ‘red army’ to stay, and we are not frightened any longer” (p. 94). The author describes the various complex repercussions of the Maoists' existence by writing down in detail not only what each villager did and what they told her, but also what the author felt, thought, decided and actually did within the tense and uncertain situation of these short visits. Chapter 5 deals with the further changes of Kwei Nasa during the civil war, mainly through their revisit to Kwei Nasa in December 2005. The comparison of two Maoist commanders shows how strongly the character and basic attitude of commanders affected the villagers' lives.
Chapter 6 consists of the author's eyewitness account of the People's Movement in Kathmandu, Pokhara, and Kwei Nasa in April 2006, of her revisit to Kwei Nasa in December 2006, a few weeks after the ten-year civil war formally ended, as well as of the Constituent Assembly election in April 2008 in Kwei Nasa. Chapter 7 summarizes the changing situation of Kwei Nasa after the election until 2011.
As I pointed out above, this book is written in the style of a memoir. This strategy is highly successful. It first of all enables the author to describe convincingly the details of complex, multifaceted, often contradictory, and always shifting “realities” of the village before, during, and after the civil war along the timeline. Though the author used various materials already published in her articles, this book should not be dismissed as a mere set of collected essays. All the data have been selected carefully, rewritten and rearticulated, and are efficiently reintegrated within the scheme of the book. Indeed, the author traces in detail only three visits to Kwei Nasa out of more than twenty during the war. She seems to have exerted her full effort to make this book as compact and accessible as possible without reducing the complexity of the situation. I was surprised to find that it has fewer than 200 pages. The strategy also enables the author to write on particular villagers in detail without pretending that she directly represents the villagers' points of view. By describing the spatiotemporal peculiarity of each and every episode, the author clearly shows us both coevalness and distance between the villagers and the author. This book can thus be also read as a record of how an anthropologist has managed to carry out a sequence of research for many years in a very difficult and unpredictable situation with the help of many people of her main field and beyond. The detailed first-person eyewitness accounts evoke different atmospheres of the difficult times as well. This is significant, as any account of the civil war would be insufficient without considering the shifting contemporary sense of fear, terror, and anxiety, though “forgetting fear” was crucially important in the village in the post-war period (p. 151).
This book not only provides us with a fascinating ethnographical description of villagers and the author during Nepal's civil war. It is also an ethnography of landscape, place and space, of fear, memory and ethnopsychology, of material culture and life world, of language use, and many other anthropological topics, as well as how all these changed during and after the civil war. Though the author seldom refers to theoretical debates on these themes except in the Introduction, theoretical considerations are tacitly encompassed in the author's seemingly straightforward ethnographic accounts. In particular, this book can be read as an attempt to connect the two themes most actively debated in Nepali and Himalayan studies for the last two decades: landscape, space and place, both real and imagined, on the one hand, and politics in the wider sense of the word on the other. The title of the book, Maoists at the Hearth, represents the link very well, as the hearth “is the center of family life and the central structural feature of the house” (p. 36). Kwei Nasa is the village name in the Tamu Kwi (language), which has been imagined as constituting a part of a yelsa yula, a locality with its distinctly Tamu order of things directly connected to the people's life and well-being. In Nepali it is called Maurigaun, and administratively it constitutes a part of Deurali Village Development Committee. During the war, Maoist solders in the village acted without considering the tacit order of Tamu-mai, so the villagers had to reimagine yelsa yula as a virtual world. Although the author does not clearly state so as such, we might say that the Maoists tried to bring the third imagined community to the village, opposing both the existing system and imagination of the Nepali nation-state and the Tamu conceptualization of yelsa yula which includes discriminatory treatment toward Dalits.
More than anything else, Maoists at the Hearth is a solid and challenging ethnography of particular individuals in particular places (mainly Kwei Nasa) before, during, and after Nepal's civil war, observed and written by an engaged anthropologist. Its strength clearly lies in its description and (more often than not latent) analyses of various ethnographic details, rather than generalized observations like “Above all else, people wanted peace” (p. 155). Certainly this ethnography is partial, as is any account of the civil war. The Madhesi issue is not even mentioned, and this lack is ethnographically important. Fortunately, none of the villagers in Kwei Nasa was killed in the village during the war. The author has been lucky in that she carried out her research in a village not very far from Pokhara, though I suppose few other anthropologists dared to revisit their village largely under Maoist control so frequently in the early and middle 2000s. It is a truly unique contribution to the literature on Nepal's civil war, as well as to the burgeoning literature on political fear and violence, which reminds us concretely how the village-level “reality” during the civil war could be far more complicated, entangled, diverse, and frequently shifting, than is generally assumed.
