In Desrosiers v. Governor of Massachusetts, plaintiffs, represented by the New Civil Liberties Alliance (“NCLA”), filed a lawsuit on behalf of seven businesses, two places of worship, and a private school challenging Governor Charlie Baker’s (“Governor”) decision to shut down “non-essential” businesses. The central issues in this case are whether the Massachusetts Civil Defense Act (“CDA”) provides authority for the Governor’s declaration of a state of emergency and whether the emergency orders violate the federal or state constitutional rights of the plaintiffs.Footnote 1 Oral arguments were held on September 11, 2020.
I. THE DESROSIERS CASE
On March 10, 2020, the Governor declared a state of emergency in Massachusetts. At the time there were about 100 confirmed COVID-19 cases in the State of Massachusetts.Footnote 2 The number of confirmed cases reached almost 10,000 by mid-April and more than 70,000 by early May.Footnote 3 On March 23, 2020, the Governor authorized the continued operation of “essential services.”Footnote 4 The order allowed businesses involved in the distribution of food and beverages, provisions of health care, law enforcement, telecommunications, energy, and transportation to remain open.Footnote 5 This order temporarily closed the physical workplaces and facilities of all other businesses.Footnote 6 The Governor depended on the authority granted to him by the CDA to declare a state of emergency and issue emergency orders.Footnote 7
Massachusetts passed the CDA in 1950 at the beginning of the Cold War when the United States was worried about military threats from the Soviet Union.Footnote 8 The law gives the Governor the authority to declare a state of emergency when the state is threatened by attack, riots, fires, flood, earthquakes, drought, or other natural causes.Footnote 9
In June, the NCLA filed a lawsuit against the Governor over his emergency orders.Footnote 10 The plaintiffs were all affected by the Governor’s order to close non-essential businesses. The central issue in the case is whether the CDA provides authority for the Governor to declare a state of emergency and issue emergency orders pursuant to the emergency declaration, and whether the orders violate the plaintiffs’ Federal or State constitutional rights to procedural and substantive due process.Footnote 11
Plaintiffs argue that the Governor does not have authority under the CDA to address the COVID-19 crisis and that the response should be coordinated on a city-by-city basis, with local boards of health deciding what to do in their communities.Footnote 12 Their argument is based on the canon of statutory interpretation, ejusdem generis, that precludes the phrase “other natural causes” to cover a pandemic. Additionally, the plaintiffs argue that the CDA only allows the governor to act in events of a “limited duration” and that interpreting the Act too broadly would give the Governor immense power with little to no limiting factors.Footnote 13
Conversely, the government argues that “the CDA gives the Governor extensive authority to protect the Commonwealth during a civil defense emergency.”Footnote 14 Moreover, the COVID-19 pandemic has killed more than 8,700 Massachusetts residents and, the government argues, is precisely the kind of emergency that warrants a state-coordinated response by the Governor under the CDA. Additionally, the government argues that “civil defense” is defined broadly under the Act and that the COVID-19 pandemic is a “natural cause” that threatens the public health of Massachusetts residents.Footnote 15 Lastly, the government argues that the “limited duration” argument should not be given substantial consideration because times of war are not limited to a particular duration and the COVID-19 orders will only last as long the state of emergency remains in effect.Footnote 16
II. ORAL ARGUMENTS
The Supreme Judicial Court (“SJC”) heard oral arguments on September 11, 2020 to decide whether the Governor’s orders were sanctioned by law.Footnote 17 The plaintiff’s attorney focused on the definition of “other natural causes” and the scope of “limited duration.”Footnote 18 The justices hinted that “other natural causes” could cover a global pandemic and that a “limited duration” needed to be a reasonable amount of time.Footnote 19 Responding to the argument that the pandemic did not have a “limited duration,” the government repeated its argument that the CDA clearly covered times of war and that war is not inherently limited to a particular duration. Footnote 20 Furthermore, the government argues that whether the Act applies should be determined based on whether the emergency still exists.Footnote 21
Nevertheless, multiple justices acknowledged the enormous delegation of power given to the Governor under the CDA and inquired into how the court should be expected to limit that power over time. The Honorable Scott Kafker acknowledged the emergency time component to the statute and asked how the court should be expected to analyze the Governor’s actions over time if another year or two passes without a COVID-19 vaccine.Footnote 22
The justices also asked about other governors’ declarations of states of emergency and judicial interpretation of their orders.Footnote 23 Comparable cases have been filed in other states. Recent decisions in Michigan and Pennsylvania might prove to be persuasive authority for the SJC to consider.Footnote 24 There is a major difference, however, in situations between Massachusetts and Michigan. Governor Whitmer of Michigan has faced opposition from state lawmakers, while the Massachusetts Legislature has not challenged the Governor’s orders.Footnote 25 The Michigan Supreme Court relied in part on a Massachusetts SJC advisory opinion from 1944 to reach its decision.Footnote 26 The 1944 opinion stated that a governor could not use their emergency powers to repeal or amend anything they wanted without legislative approval.Footnote 27 Additionally, the Pennsylvania federal court concluded that Governor Wolf’s orders violated the rights of free speech and assembly protected by the First Amendment.Footnote 28
III. LEGAL IMPLICATIONS
The immediate legal implications of the court’s forthcoming decision regarding the Governor’s authority to declare orders under the CDA would likely impact currently closed businesses and limitations on re-opened businesses. Alternatively, if the emergency ends then the case may not need to be decided and questions regarding the governor’s authority during a pandemic may be left unanswered. This outcome, however, seems unlikely given the recent rise in confirmed COVID-19 cases across the state.Footnote 29
As of October 5, 2020, lower risk communities in Massachusetts were permitted to enter step two of phase three of the Governor’s reopening plan.Footnote 30 Lower risk communities are cities and towns that have not been a “red” community in any of the last three Department of Public Health weekly reports.Footnote 31 This next phase allowed indoor and outdoor performance venues to reopen at 50% capacity, allowed arcades and other indoor recreation businesses to increase capacity to 50%, and permitted access to fitting rooms in retail stores.Footnote 32 The limit for indoor gatherings remains at a maximum of twenty-five people for all communities, including places of worship.
The court’s decision also has implications for any future orders the Governor may impose if COVID-19 cases continue to spike in the coming months. Many communities in Massachusetts are already being considered high risk again for coronavirus infections.Footnote 33
There remains much uncertainty around the scope of the Governor’s powers during an emergency. If the court decides the Governor had the authority to declare a state of emergency and that his subsequent orders pursuant to the emergency declaration were lawful then the court will be setting a precedent of granting broad deference to governors during established emergencies. This precedent would grant extensive and highly flexible powers to the Governor with, arguably, little to no limiting factors. As Justice Kafker acknowledged, there is an emergency time component to the relied upon statute and there is confusion about how to legally analyze a governor’s emergency orders with the passage of time.Footnote 34
One possible solution that the Commonwealth, and states elsewhere in the United States, can consider in response to this problem is to establish an automatic judicial review process for executive orders issued by governors during times of crisis. The ancient Romans established a way to sidestep checks and balances during emergencies when strong leadership was needed.Footnote 35 The Senate was able to vote to grant absolute power to one man, a dictator, for a temporary period of six months or less if the crisis passed.Footnote 36 Theoretically, the temporary dictator could be prosecuted for an abuse of his powers when he gave up his office, but this was uncommon and rarely happened.Footnote 37 This limitation could have helped ensure that the leader did not abuse his authority.
In a similar manner, the SJC could review the Governor’s orders at the end of the pandemic and decide whether an abuse of power took place. Additionally, the state could limit the Governor’s emergency powers to six months, or another established reasonable time, and decide whether an emergency still exists at the end of the established time period. If an emergency persists beyond the time duration that requires the governor to continue using their flexible authority to address the ongoing crisis then the court can extend the authority for an additional time period.
The SJC’s forthcoming decision will likely continue the conversation about the scope of the Governor’s powers to issue orders for an emergency of an undefined duration. Lawmakers may want to consider establishing limiting factors to this extensive power to reduce the risk of an abuse of power.
