Thanks to the enduring fascination with the dictator's life and death, Caesar's political and military legacies have long attracted more attention than his reputation as a man of letters. As the editors explain in their insightful introduction (1–9), before the ‘historiographical turn’ of the late 1970s and ’80s, even those scholars who sought to rehabilitate the texts of Caesar found themselves working under the shadow of his personality. In the last two decades, however, several studies have successfully brought into light the literary complexity of Caesar's Gallic and Civil Wars (hereafter BG and BC). An appreciation for Caesar's style and abilities as an author has in turn fed into and opened new approaches to his fragmentary works. It is this growing body of scholarship upon which the Cambridge Companion builds, offering a much needed overview of Caesar's writings in the round, while pointing out avenues for future research.
Part I begins by exploring the connection between literature and politics. K. Raaflaub (13–28) sets the scene by surveying Caesar's main literary achievements before presenting the case for reading the Commentarii as part of a larger ‘propaganda campaign’. Caesar presented himself as a model for imitation, he argues, and from there we can understand how he conceived of the exemplary Roman leader. This idea is usefully picked up and expanded in the second chapter, where C. Krebs (29–42) discusses the means Caesar had at his disposal to keep in touch with Rome whenever he was away. Thus he places Caesar's Commentarii within a larger communications network, looking at their interaction with other forms of media, to explain how he stayed ‘on message’ in promoting his ancestry, values and allegiance to the people of Rome. The focus on Caesar's writings as promotional material continues in the third chapter (43–57) as W. Batstone reflects on the operations at work behind the creation of the ‘myth of Caesar’ as well as its effect — a phenomenon he terms Césarité. In the final three chapters, other aspects are brought into consideration. J. Rüpke (58–67) makes shrewd connections between Caesar's own priestly offices, writings and his use of literature to make his reforms ‘palatable’ to contemporaries. A. Riggsby next turns to geography (68–80), providing a nuanced study of the forms and consequences of spatial representation in the BG and BC which places equal importance on the use of space, while A. C. Johnson (81–94) engages with the rhetoric of ‘otherness’ through which Caesar simultaneously crafts ‘nostri’: a portrait of his Roman readership, as seen through Caesar's eyes.
Part II follows up with various explorations of genre, rhetoric, language and style. D. Nousek (97–109) paves the way with the all-important question of what Caesar's Commentarii actually were, arguing that we might find a home for them within the genre of historiography. In so doing, Nousek provides a useful framework for reading the chapters that follow: Krebs’ chapter on Caesar's style (110–30); L. Grillo's examination of Caesar's use of speeches in oratio recta and oratio obliqua (131–43); A. Corbeill's exposition of Caesar's use of wit and irony (144–56); and another chapter by Grillo (157–69), which offers three case studies to demonstrate the fruitfulness of applying literary approaches to passages of BG. For many readers, the close readings in these chapters will represent the best of what the volume has to offer towards an appreciation of Caesar's literary merit: his eloquence, brevity, precision and the cohesion of his narrative. Yet these gems continue in Part III, as the scope broadens from the Commentarii to bring Caesar's fragmentary works into consideration.
In all the chapters of this section, the authors make a virtue of contextualising material we have largely lost by grounding it in the intellectual, social and political culture of Caesar's day. Thus G. Pezzini opens the section by examining Caesar's contribution to the Latin language, as well as his attempt to standardise it through his treatise De Analogia (173–92). H. van der Blom presents an informed reading of the fragments of Caesar's speeches (193–205), set against the backdrop of his education, career and self-promotion as a people-friendly politician. S. Casali has less to go on: just seven lines of Caesar's poetry survive and only a smattering of information (206–14). Yet even here it is possible to see Caesar the intellectual at work, joining the debate on the canon of Latin playwrights. Corbeill's chapter on Caesar's Anticato (215–22) examines a different type of debate, this time over the memory of Cato. But Caesar's reliance on the hackneyed topoi of invective damaged his case. As R. Morello goes on to demonstrate in the final chapter of this section (223–34), Caesar fared better in the management of his epistolary environment. Only six of his letters survive within the significantly larger corpus of Cicero's correspondence Ad Atticum. Read within the ‘narrative(s)’ of the books that contain them, however, they provide a telling insight into Caesar's wider use of the medium, as well as the potential for manipulation it afforded him.
A unifying factor of many of the chapters so far has been the often unique and brilliant uses to which Caesar put the spoken and written word. In Part IV, then, it is Caesar's sources and Nachleben that receive attention. In the first two chapters, L. Pitcher and M. Chassignet respectively look at Caesar's debts to the Greek historians (237–48) and his Roman predecessors (249–62). The former opened up narrative possibilities and a whole treasure trove of topoi, while the emerging Roman taste for memoirs and autobiographies alongside more traditional forms afforded Caesar scope to produce his own ‘atypical work’. These are engaging chapters, as is J. F. Gaertner's study of the wider Corpus Caesarianum, which makes its own valuable contribution to the vexed question of the authorship and composition of the four supplements to the Commentarii (263–76). In the next two chapters, C. S. Kraus (277–88) and T. Joseph (289–303) examine Caesar's reception in imperial Latin literature. Kraus begins with some of the more general ways in which Caesar's influence on Livy's prose may be felt, before moving to moments of precise intertextual interaction in Tacitus’ Germania and Agricola. These literary engagements with Caesar continue in Joseph's examination of the epics of Vergil and Lucan, where the death of Pompey is used, alongside other passages, as a test case for measuring the two poets’ responses. More than anywhere else, one here reaps the reward for reading the Companion from cover to cover. But even for the ‘dip-in’ reader, the extensive cross-referencing between chapters, coupled with the editors’ provision of a comprehensive set of indexes, will encourage a deeper engagement with themes and ideas that spread across the volume.
The opportunities for further reception studies in this field are vast, as the final two chapters attest. J. Thorne presents a valuable overview of how various authors, ancient and some modern, have used Caesar's Commentarii in their own accounts of the Gallic and civil wars (304–17). To conclude, H. Schadee takes a closer look at the Nachleben of the commentarius form in general before examining two rare, yet specific imitations of Caesar's writings: Wishart's Commentary detailing the campaigns of Montrose, and Napoleon Bonaparte's Memoirs in Aid of the History of France (318–32). As the editors explain in their introduction, these topics have been selected ‘exempli causa; several of them surely await a monograph treatment’ (8). Indeed, M. Dimitrova's Julius Caesar's Self-Created Image and Its Dramatic Afterlife, published in 2017, would have come out too late for inclusion here. But in picking up precisely where our current volume breaks off, Dimitrova's examination of the influence of Caesar's self-representation in the Commentarii on theatre and opera confirms the very timeliness of this Companion. More than this: the volume is well edited, it offers a dazzling array of insights about its subject, and the writing is consistently of high quality. The Companion will render Caesar more interesting and enjoyable to any scholar who, despite the recent surge of admiration for his literary accomplishments, still privileges his status as a man of power over his reputation as an author, orator and scholar.
