The editors of Japan at Nature's Edge: The Environmental Context of a Global Power seek to bring Japan into the Anthropocene and the Anthropocene into Japan. It is an ambitious undertaking and largely successful. Environmental historians and scholars of Japanese history or culture will likely benefit from reading this volume.
The term “Anthropocene” has become increasingly prominent along with awareness of global climate change. It refers to a time when human-induced environmental change has become a stronger force in shaping ecosystems than geophysical factors. Whether the earth's geological history has in fact entered such a time is debatable, but the idea functions well as a heuristic device in any case.
The 1958 Conference on Modern Japan produced five volumes that helped define the field of Japanese history in the 1960s and 1970s. Japan at Nature's Edge seeks to revisit Japanese modernization, shifting the focus to Japan's role in transforming the global environment and the environmental consequences of Japanese modernization. Unlike the view that takes Japan's natural environment as a fixed entity constituting the ground of culture, the emphasis in this volume is dynamic interplay between history, culture, and natural environment. Turning the old view on its head, culture and human action drives environmental change, often for the worse. One recurring message in the volume's essays is that unintended environmental consequences have helped constitute today's Japan.
The fifteen chapters of Japan at Nature's Edge are in groups of three in five parts. Most of the volume's authors are historians, but specialists in political science, economics, literature, and anthropology also contribute essays. The voices of scientists are absent.
The essays in “Oceans and Empires” by William Tsutsui, Jakobina Arch, and Micah Muscalino all deal with whaling. They connect pelagic resources with Japan's modern empire, foreign relations, and the global economy. Along with Ian Jared Miller's introduction, this material also calls into question the contemporary claim that whaling is an integral part of Japanese traditional culture.
Essays by Takehiro Watanabe and Timothy S. George in “Changing Landscapes” examine pollution cases in the context of the global economy. Philip C. Brown's chapter examines past and present attempts to engineer waterways. All three essays shed light on unintended consequences that accompany environmental interventions.
The essays in the “Between Bodies” part are diverse. David L. Howell discusses human excrement as a historical force, Andrew Bernstein examines the “bodyscape” of Meiji Japan with particular attention to Mt. Fuji, and Christine L. Marran writes on the social significance of the 2002 appearance of a bearded seal in the Tama River (far from its usual habitat).
The essays under “Vistas and Vantage Points” are similarly diverse. Federico Marcon's chapter about attempts to inventory the natural world in the eighteenth century nicely sheds light on the long temporal roots of the Anthropocene. Karen Thornber argues that literature provides useful windows for apprehending Japan's natural legacies. A long chapter by Ken'ichi Miyamoto provides a detailed breakdown of the postwar evolution of Japanese environmental policy.
In the book's final section, “Triple Disaster of 3/11,” Sara B. Pritchard analyzes 3/11 in light of models advanced by Charles Perrow and Thomas Parke Hughes and ends up criticizing Hughes's model and highlighting the role of unintended consequences. Daniel P. Aldrich examines nuclear policy, and he suggests that 3/11 marked a significant turning point such that citizen activism will actively shape Japan's future.
Perhaps the most important essay is the final one by Julia Adeney Thomas, “Using Japan to Think Globally: The Natural Subject of History and Its Hopes.” The earth and its denizens have entered the Anthropocene, she asserts, and it will mark such a disruptive break with the past that history as typically practiced is losing its ability “to provide imaginaries for the future” (p. 296). Because traditional modes of historical study have given little attention to the environment, they are unable to provide possible paths forward in the face of “climate collapse” (p. 206). Taking the environment seriously will provide new insights into our past that can serve as tools for forging a better future. Moreover, environmentally Japan is currently dealing with issues with which much of the rest of the world will soon have to engage. Japan is therefore an ideal focus of study within the broader environmental turn. In a world that will increasingly demand that societies live within their ecological means, “Japan looks less like a disaster in its ‘decline’ and more like a model for the future” (p. 297).
Japan at Nature's Edge is a thought-provoking and, in places, challenging book that deserves to be read and discussed widely.
