The traditions of the conversion of Constantine the Great to Christianity and his support of the Christian faith have made him one of the most studied Roman emperors, and a symbol for the Christianisation of the Roman Empire in Late Antiquity. But how to align the many images of Constantine, and how to differentiate between the emperor and his historical traditions? These questions are tackled in different ways by the three books under review.
The bilingual volume (mostly Italian, with four English contributions) by E. dal Covolo and G. Sfameni Gasparro concentrates on Constantine's relationship with the Christian Church. It comprises eleven papers, which fall into two categories. Seven contributions offer summaries of the historical context and of past scholarship of Constantine's Christian policies. Following a brief note on the Severan precursors of the Constantinian shift (E. dal Covolo, 21–9) and G. Bonamente's review of the main arguments found in past scholarship on Constantine's Christian policies (33–63), two papers examine Christian attitudes to imperial power (M. Rizzi, 65–77) and the internal organisation of the Christian community (A. di Berardino, 79–104) before 312. I.-A. Tudorie (106–19) contributes a well-organised discussion of the shape of the Great Persecutions under the Tetrarchy and their impact on the Christian community. Finally, two eminent Italian scholars critically address two central points of the discussion, the nature of Constantine's conversion and baptism (A. Marcone, 239–49) and his relationship to the Christian Church (R. Lizzi Testa, 251–72). Here, Lizzi Testa succeeds admirably in her attempt to offer a comprehensive overview of the chronology and of the legal as well as fiscal contexts of Constantine's actions towards the Christian Church, such as the rights and privileges of bishops and clerics.
The second group consists of five papers which discuss aspects of Constantine's turn to Christianity and of how it was reflected in imperial communications (textual, artistic and in particular numismatic). Three contributions investigate instances of Constantine's relationship with solar worship from 312 to 337. The discussion of the death and funeral of Constantine serves M. Wallraff (121–38) to argue for an intentional ambiguity in Constantine's image between Christian and non-Christian elements. E. DePalma Digeser's investigation of the education of Constantine (139–51) traces the influence of Hermetic Platonic concepts on Constantine's Christian theology and relates it back to Lactantius. N. Lenski's sophisticated study of the portrayal of the sun and the senate in the friezes of the Arch of Constantine (155–96) succeeds in furnishing additional insights into its political message. The other two papers critically assess the impact of Constantine's turn to Christianity following the Battle of the Milvian Bridge in the numismatic record. B. Bleckmann's learned discussion of the representation of the victory at the Milvian Bridge on the medallions emitted in Ticinum between 312 and 316 (197–220) stresses the importance of the military aspects (cavalry and infantry) alongside religious motifs (the Christogram). G. Alteri's study of the reflections of Constantine's conversion in coinage (221–49) highlights the continuation of religious and political traditions alongside the emergence of Christian motifs. The arguments made by Wallraff, Lenski, Bleckmann and Alteri are elucidated by several helpful high-quality coloured illustrations of artworks and coins discussed in these contributions. In addition to a short introduction by the editors (11–19) and a brief conclusion by B. Ardura (273–6), the volume comes with a general index.
With its aim to offer in part a report of the status quo in scholarship on the Constantinian question, only half of the contributions to this volume offer new findings regarding Constantine's Christianity, its reflections in imperial representation and its impact on his dealings with the senate and the military. Still, the summary chapters are well-done and useful starting points for future engagement with the past literature and recurring themes of Constantine's Christianity.
The second collected volume, The Life and Legacy of Constantine. Traditions through the Ages, has a very different aim. Edited by S. Bjornlie, its twelve contributions seek to investigate the formation of historical traditions for the study of Constantine and to reflect on their impact on the different authors and historical contexts. As Bjornlie points out in his introduction (1–25), interpretations of Constantine's policies have been fundamental to historical understanding of his actions and their consequences, and modern readings of Constantine are often influenced by earlier constructions of Constantine and his role in the Christianisation of the Roman Empire. The collected papers aim at delineating some of these traditions in their historical circumstances, reflecting on aims and audiences and drawing on various literary sources and material remains from the late antique period to the seventeenth century.
Four contributions examine Constantinian traditions in his lifetime. R. Van Dam's learned review of current scholarship on Constantine (6–25) underlines the fruitfulness of new approaches to Constantinian texts and traditions. He notes that positivist approaches to Constantine tend to gloss over discrepancies, rhetorical aspects and contradictions in the Constantinian narratives, and that new approaches, from reception studies, to intertextuality, narratology and the study of orality can furnish important new insights into the construction of Constantine. C. Chinn (26–48) examines the survival and adaptation of classical literary traditions of imperial praise (the pastoral trope of the emperor in the city) in the works of fourth-century panegyrists and poets. E. DePalma Digeser elaborates on her argument about the role of Hermetic ideology and vocabulary in Constantine's religious policy and his theology, including his use of the term ‘homoousios’. H. A. Drake's study of Constantine's intentions in the so-called Edict of Milan and the Donatist controversy disentangles an innovative and self-confident Constantine pursuing his own ideas about how to create a Christian empire.
Four papers examine reconstructions of Constantine in the fifth to the eighth centuries across Europe and the Middle East. K. Sessa's thoughtful study reads the construction of re-imagined stories of Silvester and Constantine in the Acta Silvestri as paradigms for the notion of the Roman bishop as a trustworthy manager of Church property and wealth. S. Bjornlie looks at how contacts with the court in Constantinople influenced interpretations of Constantine's achievements across the sixth century. His study is a highly insightful tour de force through numerous authors and their texts, from Zosimus to Jordanes in the East, and from the Liber Pontificalis to Gregory the Great in the West. K. Baxter Wolf's analysis of three apocalyptic sources from the seventh century continues this quest for ancient traditions of Constantine to the rise of Islam and examines the role played by Constantine as an historical figure and model for the last emperor of Rome. Finally, J. Emerick investigates the handling of the memory of Constantine at the court of Charlemagne, who, refusing to be a second Byzantine emperor, consciously avoided presenting himself as a new Constantine, preferring the image of a Frankish sole orthodox leader.
B. Deen Schildgen's paper on Dante's critique of Constantine opens the third part of the volume, which is devoted to the reception of Constantine (and his donations to the Church in Rome) across Europe between the fourteenth and seventeenth centuries. Deen Schildgen examines how Dante critically engaged with the donation of Constantine to the Church in Rome. As J. Jahner shows in her contribution, Constantine's liberality constituted an important element in contemporary discussions about both the relationship of State and Church and the proper handling of wealth in late medieval England. The two final papers examine Constantine's legacy in material sources. G. Jaritz provides an insightful summary of the main features of the visual representations of Constantine in secular and religious contexts between the thirteenth and sixteenth century. He delineates how as a relatively marginal figure, Constantine often appeared in church mosaics and paintings as a passive companion of his mother Helena and of Nicholas, Bishop of Myra, or as a saint. Manuscript illuminations styled him as a model emperor, and yet his figure was rarely used for contemporary imperial representation. G. C. Gorse's paper turns to Rome and the use of Constantine's memory in the sculptural and architectural programmes of ‘Renovatio Romae’ in the sixteenth and seventeenth century, including the transferral of fragments of Constantine's colossal statue to the Palazzo Conservatori on the Capitol Hill or Bernini's staircase of the vision of the Cross in the Vatican. Rome's handling of the memory of Constantine was, however, also used against the city, e.g. when, after a successful siege, Charles V humiliated the Pope in Rome by riding through the Arch of Constantine upon his formal entrance to Rome.
These papers furnish fresh readings of the historical Constantine, and they succeed well in highlighting the importance of interdisciplinary engagement with the Constantinian traditions across time, which have impacted on how we see Constantine today. Each contribution is followed by a bibliography and a list of editions of the primary sources cited, a welcome addition which will facilitate further engagement with the presented arguments. The volume comes with twenty-five illustrations and a useful index.
The last book under review, N. Lenski's monograph Constantine and the Cities. Imperial Authority and Civic Politics, examines Constantine in his time. In his discussion of Constantine's dealings with the cities of his empire (all but Rome and Constantinople, which are reserved for a future monograph), L. sets out to show how the emperor Constantine used the traditional dialectic structures of law and formal communication available to Roman rulers, notably the mechanism of petition and response, to foster affiliation to Christianity within the cities of his empire. Constantine's impact on the Christianisation of the Roman Empire is a recurrent topic of research, yet L.’s approach to it is particularly sophisticated. Influenced by John Ma's study of the articulations of power relations in Hellenistic Asia Minor (Antiochos III and the Cities of Western Asia Minor (1999)), as well as several theories of communication and communicative action (which are laid out in detail in the introduction), L. identifies Constantine's policies towards the cities of his empire as communicative acts, which are located in their full historical, geographical, political and religious context. With the help of his rich theoretical framework, he then establishes for each case the complex nature, goal and motivation of both Constantine's communicative actions and those of his interlocutors in the cities, with a view to establishing Constantine's Christianising messages and local responses to it.
In this he succeeds particularly well in the four chapters of Part II (‘The Power of Petitions’). The first two chapters return to two well-known epigraphic dossiers of the Constantinian period, Orcistus (ch. 4, 87–113) and Hispellum (ch. 5, 114–30). In each chapter, the discussion exposes how Constantine used his responses to petitions to foster his Christianising aims, communicating to Orcistus that their affiliation to Christianity constituted a source of civic authority and a reason to grant them civic status (rather than a reason for imperial sanction, as had been the case under earlier emperors), and to Hispellum that traditional forms of imperial worship could be adapted to Christian concerns. He shows how cities petitioned Constantine to further their positions within the hierarchy of cities, by requesting a new status or the right to establish a new imperial cult. Others asked for the right to carry the imperial name. How this was used by Constantine to further his interests is discussed in detail in ch. 6 (West) and ch. 7 (East). L. concludes his analysis of this form of civic politics by highlighting that Christianity may have played a role in some instances and in particular in the East, yet the principal motivation for imperial patronage was the construction of stable relations with the cities.
The approach also works well in the fourth and final part of the book (‘Alternative Responses to Constantine’), where the discussion turns to examine how different cities responded to Constantine's messages. For this purpose, L. redistributes cities into ‘Engaging Cities’ (ch. 11, 209–29), ‘Resisting Cities’ (ch. 12, 230–44) and ‘Complex Cities’ (ch. 14, 260–78). Engaging cities, like Athens, Termessus, Delphi and Leptis Magna, were willing to engage in a dialogue with Constantine. They did not follow his Christian agenda, but also refrained from resistance. Rather, as L. shows, they approached him with alternative, non-Christian (traditional) interpretations of his messages. In this discussion, L. examines the role of religious concerns in the choice of civic patrons; his investigation of the deliberations of the council of Paestum (221–4) and the comparative case-study of Puteoli and Naples (225–8) are particularly noteworthy. L.’s resisting cities were unwilling to enter into dialogue with the emperor, a resistance which prompted a violent response from an emperor willing to use force and escalate the situation if his policy of entering into non-violent discourse with his subjects failed. L.’s examples include Mamre, Aphaca (Mount Lebanon), Aegeae in Cilicia and Heliopolis-Baalbek, where he traces the result of imperial involvement into local affairs from temple destruction under Constantine to the reconstruction of several cult sites under Julian. The limitations of imperial power are further explored in ch. 13 (146–59), which is devoted to Constantine's handling of the Donatist controversy, and in the final chapter (ch. 14) which elucidates Constantine's dealings with several interest groups (pagan and Christian) within two of the most complex cities of his empire, Alexandria and Antioch.
The three chapters of Part I focus on Constantine ‘the sender’ (‘Constantine's self-representation’). Ch. 1 (27–47) recapitulates four phases in the transformation of Constantine's images in coinage, official communication and titulature. Ch. 2 (48–66) delineates the four main characteristics of his public image: light, triumphalism and victory, divine favour, and dynasty. If these messages were sent to all subjects, in ch. 3 (67–83) L. then examines Constantine's attempts to shape and control Christian interpretations of his role in the Empire. The discussion concludes that in contrast to the often-changing public images examined in the earlier chapter, the Christian face of Constantine remained relatively stable.
Part III, ‘Reconstructing the Ancient City’, examines imperial involvement in urban life and, ultimately, in the transformation of old cities into places of Christian worship. The discussion draws predominantly on more abstract reflections of Constantine's communication, that is literary, legal and archaeological evidence. The first chapter (ch. 8, 167–78) looks at urban financial arrangements and argues that Constantine transferred wealth (statues, property and land) from pagan temples as well as revenue-producing municipal property (here, L. refutes G. Bransbourg, AnTard 16 (2008), 255–96) to the imperial fisc, and that he redistributed direct grants of some of its revenue to the Christian communities. Ch. 9 (179–96) looks at imperial promotion of church building in Rome and throughout the Empire, noting the lack of epigraphic evidence for these constructions. The chapter attractively proposes that differences in shape and style do not necessarily reflect the lack of an overarching imperial building policy, but are rather the result of how this policy was enacted, namely through petition and response. Ch. 10 (197–206) traces Constantine's policies of redirecting power from traditional local power-brokers, the municipal elites, to the local bishops. The question of the audientia episcopalis, manumission, the use of the cursus publicus and exemption from curial liturgies are reviewed. L. discovers an ‘overzealous Constantine’ (201) who enacted revolutionary measures, some of which proved to be impractical and had to be modified by his successors.
The discussion is enriched by many helpful maps, tables and forty-nine halftone figures; L. also provides new English translations of the Orcistus and Hispellum dossiers, and there is a useful general index.
Much of this is well-trodden ground, but with his new theoretical framework and his command of the primary sources — literary, numismatic, material and epigraphic — L. is able to produce thought-provoking new readings of well-known sources and problems. L.’s aim is clear: to reveal the purposeful Christianising content of Constantine's communications. Sometimes there is the impression that written primary sources are perhaps taken too much at face value, as reports rather than speech-acts with their own agendas and audiences. To some readers, some of his conclusions may at times also appear to be over-positivistic or over-stated (a ‘giant step’ is taken when turning bishops into new civic leaders, 206; a ‘massive scale’ of wealth is poured into the Christian Church, 182, which wins ‘tremendous financial advantages’, 175).
But none of this is to distract from the fact that this elaborate study of Constantine's communicative agenda is an impressive achievement. The range of topics and material covered and their detailed treatment is admirable, as is L.’s clear and accessible prose. As a result, his monograph offers a fine expert discussion of Constantine's engagement with the various cities of the Empire, and is a highly recommended read for the study of Constantine and of Roman emperors more broadly.
In sum, the three books under review offer a wide range of many nuanced interpretations about Constantine's Christian agenda and its reflection in the historical traditions. The authors convincingly demonstrate that there are many Constantines, and that engagement with his images is able to produce fine studies about the nature of imperial rule, Constantinian traditions and the Christianisation of the Roman Empire. They also show the difficulties in separating the man from the myth, in particular if the investigation has a Christian focus, and there is the suggestion that in this context, the separation is not always possible or fruitful. One important issue, I think, is either missing or does not receive as much attention as it may have in these otherwise fine investigations. This is the question of the role played by subsequent late Roman and Byzantine emperors in the creation or distortion of the images of Constantine and his (Christian) achievements in Late Antiquity, which will have influenced later readings of his actions. Certainly, many discussions in Costantino il Grande, The Life and Legacy of Constantine and, in particular, Constantine and the Cities are necessary reading for specialists in the study of Constantine, in the history of Late Antiquity and in the Christianisation of the Western world more broadly.
