The cover of The Fire Is upon Us may mislead readers. Its bright red lettering and counterpoised James Baldwin and William F. Buckley Jr. suggest that the book is just about those men and their historical debate. The prologue says otherwise. Within a few pages, Nicholas Buccola introduces readers to its true interlocutors: the 1965 contest at Cambridge Union between Baldwin and Buckley and the debate over race played out in the streets, exemplified by organizer James Orange's arrest in Alabama that same night (5). In one corner, an “epic clash” dramatized with the decorum of “the world's oldest and most prestigious debating society” (1). In the other, the boycotts, blockades, and blood that characterized mass action in the era.
This is how Buccola frames his beautifully researched and written work: it is “the story of how two of the most consequential postwar American intellectuals responded to the civil rights revolution” (7). The book is organized as intertwined intellectual biographies. We watch Baldwin and Buckley grow up, write their first essays as the Democratic and Republican Parties shifted and the NAACP made moves in the 1940s and ’50s; we see Buckley create the National Review and Baldwin write Notes of a Native Son amid the murder of Emmett Till and the Montgomery bus boycott (27–61, 62–76). Buckley writes skeptically of the civil rights movement; Baldwin meets Martin Luther King Jr., deliberates with Malcolm X on television, lectures for CORE (106, 134–37, 179). Whereas in his first book, The Political Thought of Frederick Douglass, Buccola reconstructed a long life into conceptual chapters, this book's narrative invites a broad audience of readers into Baldwin's and Buckley's developing visions.
This story is not without theoretical insight. Though Buccola does not propose any schematic reconstruction of Baldwin's or Buckley's political theories, chapters weave persistent themes, placing the two in parallel long before their debate. Both men were first shaped “by their relationships to their parents” (13). Buckley drew from his mother the belief that one could resist “racial egalitarianism” without being a racist (14). He rejected his father's anti-Semitism but inherited his “antidemocratic individualism” among other conservative ideas (15). Not only these ideas but the very form of Buckley's attachments define his thinking: Buccola shows him to be a strategic, defensive thinker who holds ground rather than cultivating new areas of thought. We see this in the assumed good of individualism and Christianity of God and Man at Yale, his defending the southern “way of life,” and his difficulty outlining alternatives to liberalism (50, 93, 116). By contrast, Baldwin's radical vision emerges from his youthful repudiation of his father's “bitterness and self-hatred”: a disavowal he would recall in “My Dungeon Shook” (17). Rather than accepting old ways, Baldwin rejects staid forms and calls individuals to interrogate themselves and their country. We see this in Baldwin's criticism of Richard Wright, his call for “fearless self-examination,” and his diagnosis of America in Nobody Knows My Name (28, 105, 121).
These threads are subtle—perhaps too subtle—but they present a compelling tapestry of diametrically opposed views of race in America. Though Buccola does not treat the debate as either thinker's telos, he masterfully presents it as a culmination of these developments. Up first, Baldwin described himself as “a kind of Jeremiah” for America, there to “confront his audience . . . with questions that they did not want to hear, much less answer” (254–55). Through close reading, Buccola rehearses the prophet's radical demand for reckoning. With no less clarity does he relay Buckley's response: to interrogate not himself but Baldwin and his audience, to resist any approach to American history that might jeopardize what Buckley called the “faith of our fathers” (294). The entire book is well written and researched, but these chapters make the strongest case for both Buccola's story and my recommendation of this book to any reader.
And yet I see missed opportunity in what The Fire Is upon Us makes of Baldwin and Buckley for our contemporary moment. In the prologue, Buccola proposes the book's second goal: to address “the enduring relevance of the themes of their decades-long debate” (7). In a footnote he adds that as a political theorist, he “go[es] beyond mere description of the ideas of Baldwin and Buckley to offer some analysis of moral status of those thoughts” (402n21). Baldwin emerges the clear winner. Buccola is fair yet unflinching when confronting Buckley's worst convictions and arguments, interrupting his account of the latter's speech at Cambridge to defend Baldwin against mischaracterizations. Though at times heavy-handed, Buccola's pressure is warranted. As he rightly concludes, Buckley's views survived to fester and foment some of the most reactionary views on race plaguing American politics today (366). They are worth combating.
But this book is about not only Baldwin against Buckley, the prologue tells readers—it is about that debate as it occurs against the backdrop of the civil rights revolution. It is this contest that the book does not interrogate forcefully enough. What did Baldwin's and Buckley's intellectual labors mean for the political and legal actors in the streets and in statehouses? Buccola rightly notes that Malcolm X described Baldwin as “the poet” of the revolution (2). But what did that poetry do for Malcolm and others? What did Buckley's apologias mean for southern strategists? Following these writers’ developments alongside the ebb and flow of civil rights activism often involves a disconnect between worlds that is rarely interrogated. For example: within one paragraph, Buccola narrates how Baldwin likely heard news of police brutalizing protestors in Marion the day after their debate, how the following day he went with his editor “to treat themselves” with an exquisite dinner, and how Baldwin there learned of and lashed out at the news that Malcolm X had been assassinated (302). This section of the chapter ends with the “exciting news” that Playboy might pay Baldwin exorbitantly for reprinting his speech (304). No analysis is offered of these juxtapositions, and nowhere does Buccola raise the uncomfortable question implied: that perhaps Baldwin was wrong to propose ethical solutions to political and legal problems. Buccola concludes that “the story of Baldwin and Buckley reminds us that moral righteousness is often not sufficient to gain political power” (366). What then did moral righteousness do for civil rights?
Though this would require more scrutiny of Baldwin than Buccola offers, I am not asking for fair and balanced coverage of the two figures. On the contrary, with this critical distance, the rich story of The Fire Is upon Us could address one final question: What does this 1965 clash tell us of the role of debate itself in racial politics? Buccola's book affirms the historical significance of this event, that the problems considered by Baldwin and Buckley remain unsolved. But is an intellectual sparring match between elite thinkers in an elite forum a productive political response to those problems? Buccola notes that far fewer people would have read the debate's transcript in the New York Times than saw footage from Selma on television that night (309). It seems unlikely that a similar debate today could galvanize political action more than have protests over the killings of Michael Brown, George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and others. Skeptics like myself would point, too, to contemporary reactionary efforts to co-opt practices and principles of rational discourse. Today's racists have evolved their rhetorical methods beyond Buckley's “let us try to understand” the South to claims that “there is blame on both sides” of a clash between white supremacists and counterprotesters in Charlottesville (218). Others make bad-faith appeals to the free speech of “race realists” or reactionary provocateurs. What would Baldwin say to these skeptics? Would he be right?
If my own tone is combative, it is only because I can easily recommend The Fire Is upon Us to readers—and because I know Nicholas Buccola is more than up to the challenge. As he knows and shows well in the book, the debate over race in America did not end with Baldwin and Buckley.
