Sharon Erickson Nepstad's thoughtful review makes important points. I am gratified by what she describes as my contributions, and no less appreciative of her discussion of areas in which a stronger contribution might have been made. Many of these are questions that my book raises and that I hope future research will investigate.
First, Nepstad asks about the generalizability of my theory, noting that it seems most relevant to self-determination movements. Indeed, I begin the book by stating that I apply my theory only to movements of ethnic or national groups for autonomy or independence (p. 2). Such struggles are among the world's most common sources of bloody conflict. Yet most self-determination movements do not use violence, or do not do so consistently over time. I focus on this puzzling variation. At the same time, I suggest that my ideas can shed light on general dynamics in a variety of movements. I do not claim that my concept of cohesion, based on the elements of leadership, institutions, and collective purpose, applies directly to other settings. As I elaborate in “Precluding Nonviolence, Propelling Violence: The Effect of Internal Fragmentation on Movement Behavior (Studies in Comparative International Development 47 [March 2012]: 23–46), no single definition of cohesion will be appropriate for the full diversity of collective challenges to authority. My conceptualization is well suited for self-determination movements because the quest for statehood, self-governance, or franchise drives them to seek attributes of the states that they oppose. It may be less applicable to movements whose goals or memberships are more amorphous or eclectic. In such contexts, cohesion is likely to stem less from unified leadership than from an overarching collective identity or aspiration. Nonetheless, cohesion will still be important in shaping movement actions.
Second, Nepstad asks whether cohesion is necessary for any nonviolent protest or only for sustained, large-scale campaigns. I explicitly emphasize the latter (see pp. 214–15). I recognize that particular groups or local communities may mount nonviolent protest to the degree that they bring themselves together as a cohesive unit. This protest will remain isolated or localized, however, if the larger movement is fragmented. I elaborate this argument in my analysis of instances of nonviolent protest in the midst of the largely violent second Palestinian intifada (pp. 161–64).
Third, Nepstad would have liked more theorizing about cohesion and fragmentation. My motivating objective is to trace the effect of movement organization upon strategy and tactics. While I also discuss its sources analytically and empirically, I acknowledge that it is beyond the project's purview to develop and test hypotheses in this regard (pp. 11, 20). I identify three elements that constitute movement cohesion, and propose that the more a movement's cohesion relies solely on any one at the expense of the others, the more vulnerable it is to break down under pressure. Nonetheless, I explicitly bracket the question of which element matters most (pp. 11, 226–27). I agree with Nepstad that many outstanding puzzles remain regarding the causes and constituents of movement cohesion and fragmentation. As others research them, they might take cues from questions that I highlight throughout my book and discuss pointedly in the conclusion. For example, are leadership and institutions substitutes or complements in building a cohesive national movement? How do different kinds of social structures aid or inhibit such cohesion? How do various forms of state repression affect a movement's organizational structure, and under what conditions might the same policy have divergent effects?
Nepstad suggests that my theory would have been more nuanced and robust had it addressed these issues more thoroughly. That is possible, but the monograph might also have become considerably longer and less analytically focused. Fortunately, both her work and mine are not only stand-alone investigations but also parts of an exciting research program. Our books and dialogue on these pages point to many critical topics for investigation, and we can both look forward to the new scholarship that continues down this path.
