Not since Johnny Depp's camp portrayal of Jack Sparrow have pirates enjoyed such a good press. Of course, Adrian Johns's characters are not the cut-throats of the high seas – more cut-price wheeler-dealers – but they certainly sailed close to the wind of legality. His scholarly investigation of the disputed ownership of ideas and inventions across five centuries constantly poses a vital question. Do we have more to fear from the pirates or from their property-holding targets (themselves often counteraccused of piracy) and, more sinisterly, from the ‘intellectual property defence industry’ whose anti-piracy policing activities have escalated in scope and technical sophistication during the past half-century? Johns reserves for the concluding chapter an explicit denunciation of the latter's threat to freedom of expression and civil liberties more generally. However, from the moment his dedication trills ‘it is a glorious thing to be a Pirate King!’ we are implicitly invited to view history from the poop deck of the Black Pearl. Turn to the first chapter and you'll find that pirates are everywhere and ‘they are us’ (p. 4). If we're not ourselves ‘seed pirates’, freebooting downloaders of music from the Internet (or even one-time fans of pirate radio), many of us will nonetheless be outraged by the rich corporations who prosecute them, insist that poor farmers buy new seeds annually, plunder the tropical forests for indigenous remedies, or withhold life-saving drugs from those too impoverished to pay their royalty-inflated prices.
Readers of Johns's admirable The Nature of the Book (1998) will not be surprised that he locates the roots of today's digital and electronic controversies in the tussles over ‘literary property’ and control of publishing that arose within two centuries of the printing press's arrival in England around 1471. It was in the 1680s, however, that violators of the Stationers’ register began to be dubbed ‘pirates’ and in the eighteenth century that literary ‘piracy’ acquired a specific meaning. That meaning was spatially determined, in particular by national jurisdictions: as long as an unauthorized reprint of something originally published, say, in London circulated only outside the country it was technically not a ‘piracy’; it only became one when it crossed back into England. Few, at first, drew such fine distinctions as the most profitable works sped back and forth in handier formats and at cheaper prices, perhaps also abridged, epitomized and reduced to a smaller font (in Defoe's taxonomy). However, Irish and American literary pirates devised informal systems to maintain a semblance of internal order – once they had fought tooth-and-nail to capture their foreign booty.
Johns brilliantly explores not only how literary piracy powered Enlightenment (‘No piracy, we might say, no Enlightenment’, p. 50) but also how it became entangled with the politics of union, independence and nationhood in Scotland, Ireland and the American colonies. Jump a century and we find the Edwardian piano boom and new copying techniques stoking a black market in sheet music, which in turn prompted the appearance of pirate-hunting vigilantes and ultimately the prosecution (for conspiracy) of ‘pirate king’ James Willetts – though not before Willetts had testified to a parliamentary select committee on the potential social benefits of abolishing copyright.
Willetts appears to be the least eccentric of the self-interested champions of piracy to whom Johns gives voice – opponents of copyright, such as Sir Samuel Egerton Brydges and Henry C. Carey, and of patents for invention, in particular Robert Andrew MacFie. Johns's chapters on the Victorian patent controversy and on mid-twentieth-century academic critics of patents (Merton, Plant, Polanyi and Wiener) marshal cogent reasons for abolition at the same time as they demonstrate why that has proved so difficult.
On the history of patenting itself Johns is less sure-footed. There are a number of factual errors, including the date of the first, Venetian, statute (1474), the cost of an English patent before 1852 (roughly £100, only £350 for the small minority who extended it to Scotland and Ireland), the initial cost of a UK patent between 1852 and 1883 (£25, only £180 for the 10 per cent who paid the renewal fees), and the identification of the Commissioners of Patents with patent examiners (there were none before 1883). Also, there is insufficient explanation of significant developments, in particular the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property of 1883, which was a very limited first step towards international accord (still incomplete) that required signatories to treat foreigners equally with their nationals in the administration of patent laws and protected priority claims between their jurisdictions.
Most perplexing, however, is Johns's assertion that the Victorian patent system was saved from abolition by its defenders’ insistence that patenting was ‘but one aspect of a deeper, sweepingly fundamental principle … called … intellectual property’ (p. 248, original emphasis), which effectively equated patents with copyrights. Nominally, the Paris Convention protected ‘industrial property’ (i.e. patents, designs and trademarks), but there is much evidence that the British regarded even this as an alien notion and certainly distinct from copyright. Despite the efforts of some Victorian patent barristers, the British judiciary was resolute in its view that a patent was not a form of abstract property but a temporary grant of monopoly. The concept which emerged in the late eighteenth century and still informs British patent law was, as Johns says, ‘of a patent as a public bargain, with a specification [i.e. the revelation of the invention] … as the quid pro quo for a temporary monopoly’ (p. 140). ‘Intellectual property’ remains an alien import with no official standing, a convenient generic term but also an insidious attempt at rebranding by corporate lawyers since the 1970s, designed to strengthen the patentee's hand. Given Johns's stance in support of freedom of expression, it is a mystery why he not only endorses the term but also creates a false pedigree for intellectual property.
