With several books marketed as introductions to hadith already available, one might ask whether there is need for another such work. Existing introductions include translations of classical texts, such as Eerik Dickinson's translation of Ibn al-Salah's handbook An Introduction to the Science of the Hadith (Reading: Garnet, 2006), as well as modernized presentations, such as Muhammad Zubair Siddiqi's Hadith Literature (Cambridge: Islamic Texts Society, 1993) and Mohammad Hashim Kamali's A Textbook for Hadith Studies (Markfield: Islamic Foundation, 2005). These largely track the classical Muslim curriculum, which introduces novice students to the field by familiarizing them with its terminology, protocols of transmission, and standards for transmitters. What the literature has been missing, however, is a more panoramic survey of the field of hadith that elucidates not only its theoretical ideals but also the ways in which these ideals have been pragmatically translated into practice as well as the historical and continuing significance of hadith for Muslim civilization.
The reason for the lacuna lies in the unwieldiness of the subject matter. Whereas the Qurʾan is a single work that is generally considered to originate in the lifetime of Muhammad, hadith are dispersed in myriad collections and their authenticity has been the subject of perennial debates. As a result, not unlike herbivores, hadith scholars must gather and digest vast amounts of material in order to function. For Western-trained academics, this inevitably means that they will never be able to claim a command over hadith literature comparable to that of their classically trained Muslim counterparts, who have spent decades memorizing hadith, charting mental maps of their transmitters, and acquainting themselves with transmitter biographies. At least partly in compensation for this disadvantage, Western studies of hadith have tended to dispense with the densely layered classical scholarship and to analyze hadith reports in isolation, primarily concerned with the question of their authenticity.
Jonathan Brown's new book on hadith goes beyond such a piecemeal approach. It is the first introduction that properly deserves the epithet thanks to the breadth of its coverage and the confidence with which the author moves between an internalist account of hadith scholars’ efforts to grapple with their tradition and Western scholarship on the subject. The book is framed as a quest narrative, which subtly suggests to the reader the immensity of the topic and the pressing need for further research on it and implicitly criticizes the ease with which previous authors have touted allegedly certain conclusions.
The first chapter of the book discusses the role of Muhammad and the reports regarding his life, as well as some basic terminology. Chapter 2 provides a concise but remarkably comprehensive account of the collection and transmission of hadith throughout Islamic history. It explains methods of oral and written transmission and traces the development of the various genres of hadith scholarship.
In Chapter 3, Brown gives an engaging account of the process by which Muslim scholars evaluated hadith reports and of the changing assumptions that have underpinned this activity. The chapter, which is based on Brown's groundbreaking articles on the subject, shows that the process of evaluation was neither methodologically rigid (Brown fruitfully compares it to the work of a reporter seeking to verify a story) nor historically unchanging, as he demonstrates by identifying periods of greater and lesser rigor.
The bulk of hadith scholarship has been done by Sunni Muslims; accordingly, Brown generally treats the Sunni position as the default one. Commendably, however, he does not neglect the extensive tradition of hadith scholarship in Shiʿism, dedicating Chapter 4 to a discussion of the historical genesis of both Imami and Zaydi hadith works. His coverage of the latter is particularly fortunate, since this small but significant group has been all but ignored in modern scholarship.
Chapters 5 to 7 discuss the role of hadith in law, theology, and Sufism, respectively. Although these chapters are relatively short (perhaps even too short), they establish that the discourses of hadith, law, and theology overlapped extensively and gave rise to two rival systems of hadith categorization: one promoted by hadith scholars, the other by theologians. Many of the debates regarding hadith in the realms of law and theology are rooted in these partly incommensurable systems of categorization and their differing epistemological ramifications. Sufism, in contrast, possesses an independent fount of authority in its experiential dimension and in the charismatic figure of the shaykh. This enables it to avoid to some extent the rigorous formalistic methods of hadith assessment applied in the other fields.
Chapter 8 leaves the internalist account of hadith in the Muslim scholarly tradition and turns to Western debates on the authenticity of hadith. In an insightful introductory section, Brown summarizes the history of Western epistemological approaches to history in general and the Bible in particular, which have significantly informed the study of hadith. For the sake of clarity, he categorizes Western approaches to hadith into four roughly diachronic stages, which he labels the Orientalist Approach, the Philo-Islamic Apology, the Revisionist Approach, and the Western Revaluation. His subsequent discussion of these approaches is the clearest and most even-handed account written on the subject yet.
The ninth and final chapter tackles the role of hadith in Muslim debates about modernity and authenticity—a daunting topic, since hadith occupy the central ground in these debates. Brown identifies four dominant positions, namely, those of modernists, modernist Salafis, traditionalist Salafis, and late Sunni traditionalists. His wide-ranging discussion of these positions is not (and does not claim to be) comprehensive, but it provides a helpful sketch of major trends and thinkers as well as their interconnections and avenues of influence.
The success or failure of an introductory work such as Brown's can be assessed in terms of two potential uses. First, does it serve as a reliable and useful guide for novices to the subject area? Second, by synthesizing and portraying a whole area of study, can it give new impulses and generate new avenues of inquiry for subsequent scholarship?
As an introduction for beginners, Brown's book is both erudite and highly readable. Brown has a knack for recounting memorable anecdotes that consistently remind the reader that the hadith tradition is no monolith of faceless avatars but rather a collection of often idiosyncratically brilliant individuals. Such anecdotes complement analytical sections that contextualize developments in the field of hadith and situate them within wider historical currents affecting the Muslim world. Most important, the text manages to explain why, over such a long period of time, some of the greatest scholars of Islam have dedicated themselves to this field and, by extension, why the reader should care about it.
As for the second function, the book does a great service to Western hadith scholarship by providing a holistic picture of the Muslim hadith discourse as an intellectual activity. This portrayal balances the predominant but one-sided tendency to analyze chains of transmission as a disembodied subject matter and to ignore those who selected and assembled these chains—the great hadith critics. Brown thus challenges us to see medieval Muslim hadith collectors not simply as a variety of native informers but rather as critical scholars in their own right: separated from us by time and epistemological assumptions but possessed of expertise and insights that we disregard at our own peril.
Jonathan Brown's remarkably learned, engaging, and wide-ranging book will certainly find favor with students of all levels, but it is also accessible to educated lay readers and offers a fruitful read for specialists. More than a decade ago in the pages of this journal (31: 275–76), Daniel Brown (no relation) concluded a review of John Burton's An Introduction to the Hadith (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1994) with the words, “A book worthy of the title remains to be written.” Now it has.
