The volume under review comprises the published results of a 2015 conference at the Georg-August Universität Göttingen. It includes an introduction by the editors, 11 thematic essays (each followed by a bibliography), and a general index. What the reader will find in this slim volume is a collection of insightful, perhaps fairly conventional, and generally brief essays that are loosely connected to the overall conference theme, “leadership, ideology, and crowds,” which – like the focus on the 4th c. CE – is suitably broad enough to encompass a variety of topics but sufficiently narrow to maintain some cohesion. Further reflections on the individual contributions will follow below, but this review offers an opportunity to consider this volume and its place in the larger status quaestionis of Late Antiquity, which is by now a discrete field with its own historiographical tradition.
Although credit for the popularization of the moniker itself perhaps belongs to Alois Riegl, who deployed Spätantike in the context of early 20th-c. art historical studies, it was Peter Brown and his World of Late Antiquity who inspired a generation of scholars to reimagine later antiquity, illuminating the shadowy decline-and-fall narrative espoused centuries before by Edward Gibbon, a storyline with earlier roots in the European cultural and intellectual tradition.Footnote 1 Even before Brown, broad studies by J. B. Bury and A. H. M. Jones testify to a recognition of the distinct developments of this period, albeit as the later Roman empire.Footnote 2 Jones's work in particular is a masterful synthesis rooted in a deep knowledge of Roman law that remains a standard even today. But there is no denying that Brown's mellifluous prose, vivid descriptions, and almost poetic analysis of the literary and material sources begat a (sub)discipline of ancient studies that has flourished since the final quarter of the last millennium, with eponymously dedicated journals and book series, as well as conferences, paper sessions, and lectures.Footnote 3
One discernible high point in Brown's vision of Late Antiquity was the encyclopedic work that he, Glen Bowersock, and Oleg Grabar edited and published: Late Antiquity: A Guide to the Postclassical World.Footnote 4 That this volume appeared in major chain bookstores in the United States hints at the extent to which some awareness of Late Antiquity seeped even into the public sphere. The impress of continuity and transformation is undeniable in the thematic essays that constitute the first part of their reference work, and it seemed that the Brownian paradigm – dare I say, optimism – was all but given. The absence throughout of the seemingly verboten words “decline and fall” is notable. Still, one of the great gifts that Brown has offered to the field is an antiquity that was much broader and more complex than previously imagined, and his scholarship embraced and encouraged the study of those parts once thought peripheral as integral to the story. Scholars now work with sources in Ethiopic, Coptic, Syriac, Armenian, Georgian, and Arabic, among others, and they have given us an even richer, more nuanced, deeply complex picture of the “end” of antiquity. In many ways, Brown's Late Antiquity was a much more inclusive antiquity ‒ linguistically, culturally, chronologically, geographically ‒ and we are the better for it.
In the same year, Andrea Giardina published an important article that reflected on the veritable “explosion of Late Antiquity,” which was not necessarily a welcome development. His essay was a warning that hinted at cracks in the foundation of Brown's paradigm and the unstable structures that had been built upon it – what Giardina called “traballanti sopraelevazioni.”Footnote 5 The blurriness of “transition” as an interpretive concept has necessarily led to a collapsed periodization, such that the “Middle Ages” nearly disappear, as Late Antiquity transforms over a long time into modernity.Footnote 6 Giardina criticized the tendency toward loose definitions, avoidance of the political, and overemphasis on the sociocultural, among other things. He also explored the extent to which “Late Antiquity” as a field had been a largely anglophone venture since the 1970s, with particular interpretive lenses and respective questions prioritized over others to the marginalization of work by continental scholars.Footnote 7 Giardina criticized the extent to which the sentiments and sensibilities of modernity had been read back into antiquity in the historiography of the field.
Nevertheless, that Brown's Late Antiquity remains the foundation, even if fractured, is further validated by subsequent responses and reactions. Giardina's pushback was rooted in intellectual and historical concerns, but the archaeologists had something else to say, perhaps best voiced by Bryan Ward-Perkins's The Fall of Rome and the End of Civilization.Footnote 8 Careful examinations of the material culture, at least in select locales, can paint a rather different picture wherein patterns of decline, discontinuity, and dissolution stand in stark contrast to the decidedly optimistic Brownian outlook. But Ward-Perkins also demonstrated that place matters. Where we look and what we find really do matter, and archaeological work has “darkened” the once rosy age of transition and transformation, although even this approach is not without problems. If we might critique Brown's overly optimistic vision, rooted in literary sources and more marvelous material culture, we might equally question Ward-Perkins's amplification of certain sites and finds to draw wider conclusions. Nevertheless, the momentum swung back to a decline narrative – albeit with solid, material evidence – and we saw for a time with this “material turn” a proliferation of books and all manner of television programs about the “fall” of Rome or the end of civilization, once again brought about by “barbarians” in various guises.Footnote 9 Once again, a turn of Late Antiquity seeped into the public. One wonders if Giardina's underlying observation might offer some additional insight here: we tend to read our present into the past, and perhaps in a post-9/11 world, disruption and discontinuity of what was thought to be an interconnected global community had greater resonance in our historical thinking.
At the same time, in the first decade of the first millennium, the grand, synthetic works by medievalists Michael McCormick and Chris Wickham put the “Middle” back into the Middle Ages, with the former's revival of economic considerations and the latter's masterful analysis of regional difference and development.Footnote 10 Horden and Purcell's The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean History catalyzed an expansive approach by focusing first on the varied and manifold microenvironments of the Mediterranean to interrogate in turn the broader concept of connectivity.Footnote 11 The work of these scholars and many others has complicated further what and how long we understand Late Antiquity to have been, simultaneously tempering the Brownian optimism, reinforcing the field itself as discrete, and pushing scholarship in different directions.Footnote 12
Still, the perennial challenge of Late Antiquity is that it continues to straddle awkwardly an ever-shifting line between ancient and medieval. The field sometimes looks back to classical antiquity, which seems to inspire interpretations of continuity and relatively smooth transition, whereas at other times it stares ahead, necessarily giving rise to perspectives that emphasize breakdowns, collapse, and abrupt changes. But such binary thinking can ultimately have a stifling effect. Scholars have since recognized that a “one size” approach is too constricting and a more comfortable fit results when we recognize the importance of regional variation, comparative difference, and the value – perhaps even necessity – of different disciplinary approaches and interpretive frameworks. The question of what was/is Byzantium adds further complexity to this conversation, and the same should be said of lively and contested scholarship on late ancient Christianity.Footnote 13 The many intersections that comprise Late Antiquity are both an advantage, fostering cross-disciplinary conversation, and a liability, given that it is often without a departmental home, especially in North American contexts.
We are now in the midst of the “environmental turn” in Late Antiquity. Amid the backdrop of alarming concern over global climate change and its effects on the environment, but also disease and natural disasters, the debate over the impact of environmental factors has led to a proliferation of publications and a robust discussion about methods, interdisciplinarity, data collection and interpretation, and over-determination. Important work by Michael McCormick, John Haldon, and others has considered the relationship between humans and their environment, and the impact of changes in one on the other.Footnote 14 Once again, this historiographical turn in Late Antiquity entered the broader public ‒ in this instance, via Kyle Harper's The Fate of Rome, although there has been notable scholarly pushback to Harper's approach to environmental determinism.Footnote 15 Environmental questions have also reoriented the concept of the “long Late Antiquity,” which previously focused on the Brownian push of the periodization boundary.Footnote 16 Debates over the impact of the Justinianic Plague have generated substantial scholarship as well as public-facing writing, which again illustrates the extent to which present concerns seem to find an impress in historiographical developments.Footnote 17 Furthermore, we had no idea of the coming global COVID-19 pandemic, and it will be fascinating to see its impact on the ongoing conversation about disease and the “end” of the ancient world.Footnote 18
Late Antiquity consequently remains a vibrant and burgeoning field, and its conferences and their proceedings are abundant – although the truly successful one really is rare. Given that an edited volume is ultimately the sum of its parts, to produce one well is no small task. Editors must strike a balance between cohesion and thematic continuity while respecting the freedom of each contributor to formulate and respond to the given topic in their own way. Yet another variable is that the final essays also often yield different results from those originally conceived. Within the larger development of the historiography of Late Antiquity outlined above, the volume under review here fits squarely in the Brownian approach, and its contributions all frame their contents and case studies around the theme of continuity and change. On the whole, each essay offers valuable insight, although together they are not in conversation with each other – a frequent occurrence (if not shortcoming) in edited volumes. There is some engagement with material culture, but this volume is certainly not one with archaeology as a focus. Perhaps this should not come as a surprise because the materiality of Brown's Late Antiquity tends to focus on the impressive, be they monuments and monumental structures, luxurious possessions, dedicatory inscriptions, and well-struck, high-value coins. The remains of rural settlements, transport ceramics, mundane burials, or objects of daily life are largely absent in this book. The same can be said about recent conversations on the environment.
In the introduction, the volume editors, together with J. W. Drijvers, begin with a discussion of the leader par excellence – the emperor – and an imperial leadership style that underwent a significant transition in the 4th c.: the crux being the growing interdependence of imperial and ecclesiastical administrations. Increasingly, emperors and bishops deployed ideological and rhetorical strategies to consolidate and control the “crowd.” They cite “systematic medium analysis” as the basis for their methodological framework, which argues the need to analyze “different ancient media such as coinage, monuments and literature into their own context and medial discourse before combining them” (13). This approach enables the contributors to “demonstrate how these sources allow for ideological differentiation and diverse messages to different types of audiences” (14). They also want to combine top-down and bottom-up perspectives to balance traditional approaches that overemphasize elite points of view. Although such a framework seems innovative, it would have been more helpful if each contributor had intentionally and directly engaged with this methodology, as well as with each other's studies.
V. Jaeschke attempts to make a distinction between tetrarchic capital cities ‒ places such as Nicomedia, Thessalonica, and Trier ‒ and other residences, including retirement locales such as Spoleto (modern Split) and suburban and rural villas. By examining the building types at each, Jaeschke argues that the presence of a palatial complex in proximity or adjacent to a circus was a primary feature of a capital residence, which in turn reflected the ideology and the ceremony of tetrarchic rule. The circus was one of the only places where an otherwise distant emperor appeared in public and interacted with the crowd. The archetype was, of course, Rome with its Palatine complex; hence, its repetition in the various tetrarchic capitals speaks, on the one hand, to a continuity of architectural design; and on the other hand, to a transition away from the one Rome to many, wherever the emperors resided.
Panegyrics are the focus of A. Omissi's essay, which considers these speeches “from the point of view of the orator” (35) to understand who wrote them and why, and how panegyrics were a medium for interacting with emperors. Omissi studies examples from the Panegyrici latini: Libanius, Themistius, and Symmachus, among others. He shows how orators such as these deployed various rhetorical techniques to influence imperial behavior and elicit specific responses, be they favors or forgiveness. The composition and delivery of panegyrics are classic loci of inquiry for the high culture of Late Antiquity, and Omissi's discussion exhibits once again the impress of continuity throughout. Orators and emperors maintained a cultural and political practice with little discernible difference between pagan, Christian, and other.
Coins communicate ideology, and numismatic analysis remains useful for understanding how Roman emperors wished to broadcast a public persona or platform via seemingly mundane objects. Changes in the symbols and images they carried and in the meanings they conveyed can mark sometimes subtle, sometimes sudden shifts in messaging. E. Manders examines a specific set of coins issued during the reign of one of the tetrarchs, Maximinus Daia. It is the last known set minted by individual cities (Nicomedia, Antioch, and Alexandria). The imagery of the coins reflected the favored deities of each respective community, and together, they have been interpreted as a deliberate response against the increasing favor toward Christianity exhibited by tetrarchic rivals Constantine and Licinius (and Galerius). But Manders reconsiders this scenario by eschewing any anti-Christian motivation (because the images were typical for earlier tetrarchs) and exhibiting continuity with established tetrarchic practices.
E. Herrmann-Otto explores the relationship between emperors and their subjects through an examination of imperial legislation as a medium of communication and influence. Her argument recognizes that the deployment of rhetorical framing in laws issued by Constantine marked a shift from the practice of the tetrarchs. Hermann-Otto questions to what extent hiding behind his legislation is a Christian ethical and moralizing rhetoric, with the ultimate goal of shaping and influencing the behavior of subjects. Case studies of laws issued by Constantine raise several questions about the emperor's goals ‒ be they moral reform, the shifting of societal mores, or adumbrations of Christian ethics ‒ and the use of language that couched his pronouncements in terms related to these ends while hiding other motivations and agendas. We see here a transition in the language and perhaps the pragmatics of imperial legislation – hence, a classic locus of late antique inquiry.
J. Curran takes on the topic of Jews in Late Antiquity by first invoking “two incontrovertible truths” (81) about the modern study of Jewish history: first, our understanding of Jewish belief and practice is connected to the advent of earliest Christianity; and second, the Holocaust has necessarily obliged modern scholars to explain how far back the hatred that perpetrated it extends. Recognizing that terminologies deployed in modern contexts are fraught with racialized ideologies, Curran focuses on the actual ancient designation, iudaioi, and examines a series of textual traditions in which they appear: Christian adversus iudaeos writings, imperial legislation, and finally attestations of the so-called Patriarch of the Jews. He finds that not all is as may appear, and a “complex picture of Jews in the first century of Christian imperial rule” (94) emerges. Yes, these sources express hostility against iudaioi through Christian polemic, but they also provide cover for continuities. In the adversus iudaeos literature – for example, of John Chrysostom – many Christians “sitting down” with iudaioi was a source of episcopal anxiety, and such writings were intended to disrupt unacceptable social behavior. Some legislation that condemned Jews for such practices as proselytizing were mitigated in other laws, rooted in a long Roman tradition of recognizing the legal status of the Jews.
Leadership is the focus of G. de Kleijn's contribution, which combines ancient and modern theorizing about the nature of leadership. On the one hand, “classical criteria” are evident in ancient writers who viewed the four Platonic virtues of courage, justice, temperance, and wisdom as benchmarks for evaluating a ruler. On the other hand, de Kleijn deploys modern theories of leadership: personal and positional power, transactional and transformational leadership, and the “warrior model of autocracy” (104). Given the brevity of the volume's essays, de Kleijn can only offer one case study – the emperor Constantius – and by both standards, the sources find him lacking. Ammianus Marcellinus, other 4th-c. portrayals of Constantius, and Zosimus provide the snapshots, and perhaps we could say that Constantius represents a continuity of ineffective emperors. There is much more available material on Constantius, and some discussion or recognition of the perspectives of Athanasius would have been welcome. Clearly, this essay is part of a larger project with a promising methodological approach.
Of all the contributions, that of the late M. Sághy (to whom the volume is thoughtfully dedicated) engages most meaningfully and intentionally with the theme. She explores the disputed episcopal election in Rome of 366, in which two deacons, Damasus and Ursinus, were chosen to succeed Liberius. A series of violent riots saw murders by the supporters of Damasus, who was apparently successful in recruiting gravediggers, gladiators, and charioteers, plus a wider swath of the lower-class population. Sághy presents the victorious Damasus as an absolute master of crowd control and manipulation. By connecting himself and his faction to the martyrs of Rome via visual and textual media, he was able to draw on the legacy of those who died for Christ and associate his side as the rightful “community of the elect” and the “friends of God” (123‒24), living and dead. Damasus initiated a building program of suburban shrines, memorials, and underground centers of worship at the catacombs, thereby recruiting a crowd of witnesses whose holiness was shared by the bishop and his followers. Commemoration of the dead became less a family practice and more a communal affair, and Damasus ensured a long afterlife for his project – throngs of pilgrims continued to visit, reenacting and reinforcing his ideological message of unity, sanctity, and orthodoxy. His epigrams, drawing on classical paradigms, nevertheless reflected a transition toward greater accessibility and reach, enlarging the crowds that fell under the sway of his vision.
C. Angela Cvetković examines episcopal leadership by first invoking the example of the “Illyrian trio” of Germinius of Sirmium, Valens of Mursa, and Ursacius of Singidunum, the latter two of whom dominated church politics in the mid-4th c. CE by virtue of their close relationship to Constantius. By calling them “scheming politicians,” Angela Cvetović suggests that there was little discernible difference between these bishops and civic leaders – clearly a nod to continuity. The main focus of the article, however, is another Illyrian bishop, Nicetas of Remesiana. He was known primarily through his relationship with Paulinus of Nola, who praised Nicetas as a different sort of bishop who embodied spiritual virtues and ascetic practice. But the necessities of ecclesiastical politics, especially over doctrinal matters, compelled him to function also as a political player to shore up support in the West for his own pro-Nicene position and allies in Illyricum. Even a virtuous monk-bishop – a new ideal in the late 4th c. – still had to play the game of power politics.
Violence perpetrated by crowds stirred by speeches of powerful bishops is a well-explored theme, and scholarly interpretations have invariably focused attention on the charismatic individuals. However, J. C. Magalhães de Oliveira aims for a bottom-up approach through considering the crowd itself. Eschewing the idea that a bishop or aristocrat could manipulate the masses at will, Magalhães de Oliveira emphasizes the need to “be more attentive to the dynamics of contention,” the factors that “inhibit, promote or channel collective action” (153). In the first case study – violent action at the Donatist church of Bagaï in North Africa – we see how those who fought against imperial intervention were motivated to defend their community. The second case study presents Augustine's effort to demobilize a crowd in Carthage that was railing against paganism and demanding action from a council. The mass was already motivated to act violently, even protesting Augustine's attempt to defuse, which forced him to switch his tone and seemingly affirm the crowd's antipagan sentiment. At the same time, Augustine, using masterful rhetoric, presented himself as their shepherd in order to assert control over the crowd, and in turn to co-opt its energy and check any action. According to Magalhães de Oliveira, such a technique was “already employed by traditional elites for centuries before Augustine” (158).
M. Icks is concerned with the (in)visibility of emperors and how the appearance and availability of rulers to their subjects reflected a paradoxical dynamic: on the one hand, the assertion of imperial power by public display; on the other hand, the danger of the public gaze, potential criticism, and even attack. Icks conceptualizes this in sexual terms: the former as dominance and the latter as penetration. Late antique authors, especially panegyrists, reveal the tensions between the “splendid” public appearances of emperors, which had become wrapped up in ostentatious ceremony, and the desire for an accessible monarch. As emperors became more godlike and distant, they still needed to be available frequently. So a princeps clausus, such as a Tiberius of old, ran the risk of alienating his subjects by his invisibility, and the panegyrists and authors of Late Antiquity were especially critical of such emperors. Consequently, emperors remained subject to public gaze, as in the early Principate, and had to maintain tight control of their image, appearing when necessary and increasingly in the trappings of a distinctly late antique imperial splendor.
Finally, M. McEvoy begins her contribution with the hilarious image of the emperor Arcadius living “the life of a jellyfish” (182). Synesius of Cyrene critiqued the son of Theodosius for indulging in the pleasures of the body, cloistered in the imperial palace at Constantinople with his enablers. Ancient and modern assessments universally pan Arcadius for his mediocrity, especially in comparison to his soldierly father. Yet, McEvoy collects numerous examples of Arcadius's appearing in public, and she reminds us that this was a new phenomenon, given that few prior emperors spent so much of their reigns in the capital. In other words, Arcadius was a kind of transitional figure in imperial relations with the public in Constantinople, and his rule represents a “juncture, the crucial moment of change” (194), from martial to civilian emperors.
Perhaps a firmer editorial hand could have cultivated a greater sense of cohesion among these essays and a more conscientious engagement with the volume theme and methodological framework articulated in the introduction. I often wonder to what extent conference proceedings could offer a more interconnected collection if each author had the opportunity to read the contributors of others; there is nary a cross-reference. A conclusion or epilogue by the editors also could have tied together the findings of each essay with the volume theme and methodology. Nonetheless, each contribution enriches our understanding of the changes taking place in the 4th c.
As an edited collection, this volume undeniably reflects the impress of a “Brownian” perspective on Late Antiquity, which, one might say, is a rather traditional approach these days. Material or environmental concerns are largely absent, and archaeologists will find very little on the surface. Nevertheless, Late Antiquity as a discrete field of research would not exist without the formidable model presented by Peter Brown (and indeed, Edward Gibbon), and the hermeneutics of continuity and change exhibited in this volume will undoubtedly be part of the conversation in others. But historiography is never static, and subsequent turns in the study of Late Antiquity have challenged, reimagined, and added nuance to older paradigms. Ultimately, the most innovative and visionary scholarship will engage with the monumental and the mundane, the literary and the material, the environmental and the anthropogenic. There is always room, however, for research in the interstitial spaces, and both text- and material-minded readers of this book will certainly find value for plotting the turns still to come.
