This work provides a detailed discussion of Iran's foreign policy, with a central focus on Iran's political, economic, and religious significance not only in the Middle East but also in the broader Muslim world. The author discusses Iranian domestic politics and its affect on the country's foreign policy in detail. She does a very good job of looking at the Iranian leadership's philosophical justification for using alignments within the Muslim world to enhance Iran's influence and draws on pivotal states theory. Developed in the mid-1990s, this theory is a post Cold War strategy for addressing challenges to the United States by focusing on important developing states that are influential in particular regions as well as in the larger international system. The author justifies the validity of the theory by arguing that it allows policymakers to prioritize challenges facing the United States while advocating political and economic reform in the region. This is very significant, as Iran is often treated as somewhat of an anomaly, being an overwhelmingly Shiʿa nation within a Sunni-dominated Muslim world. This approach acknowledges that, despite the political rhetoric from some quarters, Iran must be considered a major actor in the Muslim world.
The introduction deals with the period from 1997 to 2005 and provides the reader with an overview of Iranian politics. It is a very good chronology of events that will be informative both to experts as well as to readers less versed in Iranian politics. The chapter begins with a discussion of attempts at progressive change during the Khatami era and where they fell short, culminating in the election of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in 2005 and the resurgence of the political conservatives. The author provides an excellent summary of the reform movement of the 1990s and its limitations. She also discusses political divisions within the country and the factors that led to a conservative backlash, the halting of reforms, and the erosion of Iran's political institutions in the aftermath of the parliamentary elections of 2000. Maloney argues that the main problem with the reformists was that they did not utilize their popular support when they had it. As a result, they became isolated and eventually marginalized. Part of the problem, she argues, was that the reform leaders were not comfortable dealing with public opinion and with mobilizing street protests and therefore could not maintain mass support over time. The author also discusses the ramifications of the Ahmadinejad government for Iran's domestic and foreign policy, and focuses on the interplay between domestic and foreign policy in particular. Under Ahmadinejad Iran became much more active in its foreign policy, embarking for example on policies that directly challenged the United States, such as supporting Hamas and Hizbullah, as well as building up Iran's nuclear program.
The second part of the book analyzes Iranian foreign relations and provides the reader with a broad assessment of the growth of Iran's influence in the wider Muslim world. For example, it includes a concise yet detailed account of Iran's relations with the various Shiʿi groups of Iraq, a matter of considerable importance for understanding the politics of modern Iraq. The author similarly discusses Iran's relationship with the Gulf Shiʿa and its impact on the countries of the Arabian peninsula, a topic that is especially important given current political events in the region. This section also deals with the motivations behind Iran's nuclear ambitions, the history behind nuclear and missile development, and this development's international implications. In addition, Maloney discusses Iran's development policy and its attempts to buy influence with developmental aid, a subject that proves very important in looking at Iran's position among its neighbors, particularly the relatively new states of former Soviet Central Asia as well as Afghanistan. Finally, this section examines the influence of the Iranian government's cultural and religious institutions, in the process providing an overview of the development of Iranian political/clerical institutions and their impact on politics and society.
The third part of this work deals with Iranian domestic politics, examining the role of youth, women, the economy, the impact of changes in the region on Iranian politics, and the greater implications these changes have had on the Islamic world. It provides a solid comparative analysis of Iranian politics and society that gives the reader a good vantage point from which to study other case studies in the Islamic world. Especially interesting is the limitations of reformist political leaders who failed to harness the support of young people. In addition, this section examines the populist policies of Ahmadinejad and his attempts to gain political favor through the redistribution of state resources. This latter discussion provides a good comparative case for other developing countries attempting to balance development with fairer redistributive policies while allowing elites to manipulate the process for their own political gain.
The last section of this work deals with Iranian relations with the United States. The author provides several sound recommendations for American policymakers, most centrally that Iran needs to be further incorporated into the international system. While the author acknowledges that engaging Iran will not be an easy process for the United States, she argues that doing so is very important to American relations not only with Iran but also with the broader Muslim world. The work discusses the importance of looking at the realities of U.S.–Iran relations. Too often, provocative actions and statements have clouded the relationship between the two countries, thus inhibiting meaningful negotiations and lessening the prospects for more positive contacts going forward. This work argues that American foreign policymakers need to get away from this trap and focus less on ideology and more on Iran as a strategic problem that must be managed.
Well written and researched, this book is strongly recommended for scholars of Iran as well as those who focus on the Muslim world in general. It will also benefit researchers of American foreign policy. In addition, the work integrates a discussion of comparative and international politics that will be useful to scholars focusing on both of these areas. This book is also valuable for understanding the centrality of Iran as a major country in the Middle East, as well as in the larger Muslim world. It is an especially useful case study given the current situation in the Middle East where many countries are in the grip of political change.
