This collection of essays should be accompanied by a warning; it does not in some respects deliver “what it says on the tin.” For a start, while the title suggests general coverage of Roman mosaics in rural settings, all but one of the 18 papers focus on the Iberian peninsula. The clear intention of the book is to report on recent research in Spain and Portugal. Secondly, not all the papers concentrate on mosaics; several of them deal primarily with other aspects of the sites examined, such as their excavation history, their architecture, their social and economic functioning, and their presentation to the public. It is, of course, right and proper that the mosaics should be contextualized; but the reader needs to be aware that the aims and ambition of the contributors are not always consistent. Thirdly, accepting that the volume's brief was to review the rural mosaics of Iberia, we may wonder why certain major sites are omitted. It is surprising, for instance, to find no paper dedicated to the villa at Carranque (Toledo).
These provisos stated, we should welcome this publication, which is admirably up to date and performs a signal service in bringing the Iberian material – or a large portion of it – to the attention of researchers outside Spain and Portugal. I will begin by summarizing the book's contents, before going on to examine one or two questions in more detail.
The immediate occasion for the assembling of the papers was a workshop organized by the Institute of Culture and Technology of the University Carlos III of Madrid on March 5–6, 2019. This workshop in turn formed part of a project entitled, none too succinctly, “Patrimonio Arqueológico, Nuevas Tecnologías, Turismo, Educación y Rentabilización Social: un nexo necesario para el yacimiento rural” (producing the rather desperate acronym PATTERN). Within both the project and the workshop a leading role was played by L. Neira Jiménez, who directed PATTERN from 2016 to 2019 and who is the editor of the present publication. We may assume that she is responsible for the most noteworthy of the editorial decisions: the emphasis placed upon the rural site at Fuente Álamo (Puente Genil, Córdoba), which was the main focus of the PATTERN initiative.
Fuente Álamo thus forms the subject of no fewer than 6 of the 18 papers, occupying approximately two-fifths of the volume's pages. Of the sites discussed, it is one of the more richly endowed with mosaics, including some of the most interesting examples, especially of figured work; but we may well ask whether such a large allocation of space was justified. It is odd, furthermore, that the six chapters are relegated to the last part of the book, almost as if they were an afterthought. At all events, they have provided the contributors with ample room to discuss Fuente Álamo in considerable detail, with essays devoted to the history of the excavations, the economy of the site in different periods, and selected aspects of the mosaics, including their iconography and geometric motifs (see further below).
Apart from the essays on Fuente Álamo, there are five papers surveying the mosaics of broad geographical regions: V. Vassal (21–38) deals with pavements of mortar containing inset patterns of tesserae in the south of Gaul (this is the one paper not concerned with Spain or Portugal),Footnote 1 M. Durán Penedo (61–80) with villas in Catalonia, J. P. Bernardes (47–60) with villas in the Algarve, N. de la O Vidal Teruel and J. M. Campos Carrasco (193–217) with the territory of Huelva (the extreme southwest corner of Spain), and I. Mañas Romero (167–78) more generally with strategies for self-presentation among the elite owners of Late Antique villas (see below). These papers are mostly gathered at the beginning of the volume, but the logic of their order defies understanding.
The remaining seven papers focus on individual sites, especially those which allow some consideration of aspects of musealization. F. Limão and R. Pereira (39–45) write on the villa of Santiago da Guarda (Ansião, Portugal), L. Marí Sala and V. Revilla Calvo (81–100) on the villa of Romeral (Albesa, Lleida), S. Azuara Galve, B. Ezquerra Lebrón and C. Villargordo Ros (101–19) on the villa of La Loma del Regadío (Urrea de Gaén, Teruel), C. García-Merino and M. Sánchez Simón (121–37) on the villa of Almenara de Adaja-Puras (Valladolid), G. García Vegas (139–48) on the villa of El Saucedo (Toledo), M. Á. Valero Tévar (149–66) on the villa of Noheda (Cuenca), and I. Fernández García and others (179–92) on the villa of Salar (Granada). All these nominally deal with mosaics, but their approaches differ markedly. For example, the paper on Noheda restricts itself to the scientific techniques used in recording and analyzing the archaeological data.Footnote 2 Similarly, the article on El Saucedo opts for a limited study, namely a virtual reality reconstruction of just one pavement; the overall composition of the mosaic is restored from old drawings and photographs of its constituent elements, reconciling differences of scale, different angles, and different tonalities.
The overall standard of the articles is impressive. The pair on Romeral and La Loma del Regadío both provide methodical and detailed presentations of the architectural layout and decorative program, besides reporting on the measures taken to conserve and showcase the visible remains. The paper on Almenara de Adaja-Purason is outstanding, discussing one of only two or three Spanish villas where the plan and floor decorations are known in sufficient detail for extensive inferences to be drawn on the functioning of spaces within the residential area. The authors here combine an excellent analysis of the mosaics in their architectural context with a careful search for parallels in other villas of the region. They rightly dismiss the idea that the mosaics were laid by the same workshop as those in the nearby villa at Prado.
I will conclude by referring to two particularly challenging papers. The first is I. Mañas Romero's discussion of the ways in which Late Antique villa owners asserted their identities in their floor and wall decorations. In the most obvious form, this self-presentation consisted in mosaic inscriptions naming the patron or wishing him health and happiness. Alternatively, the allegorical or mythological figures shown in mosaics or wall paintings were envisaged as paradigms for the behavior or virtues of the dominus. Such self-promotion has been discussed and broadly accepted by other writers, but M. R. takes it further than her predecessors, positing physiognomic likenesses in many of the supposed paradigm figures. Thus an Achilles might be given the features of the villa owner, or a series of anonymous busts can be interpreted as portraits of members of his family. I am not entirely convinced. For one thing, most of the portraits are not sufficiently distinctive to be identified as such; and particularly when they depict females in recurring panels of a geometric framework, they are more likely to have been conventional fillers. A set of four female “portrait” busts at the corners of a mosaic in the villa of Baños de Valdearados (Burgos), so far from depicting members of the owner's family, could simply be personifications of the four Seasons, an inference which is supported by the Dionysiac themes in the remainder of the pavement. The busts admittedly do not appear to have had seasonal attributes, but the number four alone could be enough to confirm the identification. Elsewhere, in a villa at Olivar del Centeno (Cáceres), I find the idea that figures of Silenus and a maenad in a Dionysiac scene should represent the owner and his wife slightly implausible: it is difficult to believe that the comic figure of the elderly satyr would offer an appropriate role model.
The second challenging paper is one of those that does not deal with mosaics: J. Bermejo Tirado, F. Moreno Navarro, and L. Colominas, “Economías domésticas y patrones de consumo en la villa romana de Fuente Álamo: estudio comparativo de las fases altoimperial y tardoantigua.” Whereas previous studies of the villa have concentrated on the architectural structures and decorative programs of the more monumental phases, ascribed to the Late Imperial period, very little attention has been given to the earlier (High Imperial: mid-1st to late 2nd c. CE) or later (Late Antique: 5th c.) phases. The authors accordingly carry out a comparative study of these earlier and later phases, using the evidence of artifacts from the archaeological deposits explored in recent excavations. The evidence in question is analyzed by function, following the criteria of household archaeology, and this leads to a number of interesting observations on differences between the economies of the two periods. It emerges, for instance, that items related to industrial or agricultural processes are absent from the High Imperial phase, whereas the Late Antique phase has yielded finds typical of household multi-craft production. The statistics of pottery, on the other hand, paint a picture of continuity: the proportions of tableware, for example, remain broadly similar across both the chronological phases under review.
The one factor that gives pause is the small size of some of the samples upon which conclusions are built. In assessing the evidence for industrial and agricultural activity, much depends on an iron rake assigned to the Late Antique phase; and one may wonder whether seven teeth from a single horse are sufficient to justify inferences about possible relations between Fuente Álamo and the Roman road network. Nevertheless, it is refreshing to have the more mundane finds properly assessed, and to see their potential for adding insights, even if speculative, into the economic functioning of the villa fully exploited.
