Palestine has received more attention from historians over the past half decade than any other part of the Middle East. Nevertheless, its historiography is overwhelmingly political and diplomatic, positing sharp divisions between the Ottoman, Mandate, and post-Mandate periods that admit little historical continuity over the 19th and 20th centuries, and conceiving of the modern history of the region as a sui generis narrative unconnected to any of the global movements of the 20th-century world.
Michelle Campos’ remarkable book dealing with the final decades of Ottoman rule in Palestine is a welcome exception. In Ottoman Brothers, Campos traces the idea of Ottoman citizenship in turn of the century Palestine, arguing persuasively that “civic Ottomanism” served as the central discourse through which elites of every ethnic and religious group hammered out their relationships with the Ottoman state, local and regional governments, and each other. Using Ottoman Turkish, Arabic, and Hebrew archival and published sources, Campos investigates Palestinian Arab (Muslim and Christian) and Jewish engagement with the Ottoman imperial project and the constitutionalist idea of the Ottoman citizen in the years between the Constitutional Revolution and the outbreak of World War I in 1914. “Rather than plotting the empire's demise,” she writes, “the prewar Ottoman public by and large was preoccupied with envisioning, claiming, contesting, and implementing what it meant to be an imperial citizen” (p. 7).
Ottoman Brothers begins by establishing the centrality of tropes of citizenship and revolution to Palestinian public discourse in the immediate aftermath of the revolution. Campos investigates the discussions, protests, and political and social reconfigurations around the use of the revolutionary slogan “liberty, fraternity, equality,” focusing particularly on the deployment and sacralization of the term ḥuriyya in newspapers, speeches, and even theatrical productions. The difficulties of producing a new mode of citizenship based on an imperial rather than a national space were evident in continued conversations about citizenship's implications for ethnic, linguistic, and religious minorities in the empire, as well as in the many inconsistencies with which citizenship was applied. Nevertheless, imperial citizenship after the 1908 revolution initially seemed a viable project in Palestine, which was characterized by a high degree of social integration among different ethnic and, especially, religious communities.
In the years following the 1908 revolution, Palestinians of all faiths exercised their imperial citizenship in a number of different ways—usually with the goal of allying civic Ottomanism with agendas of modernity and progress. A boycott of Austrian goods in the aftermath of its annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina, engagement with new and revised models of political representation vis-à-vis the empire, and local efforts at municipal improvement and modernization in Jerusalem all served as modes of working out the extent, practice, and implications of civic Ottomanism. Imperial citizenship, though, faced genuine structural challenges from competing modes of political and social identification.
Campos traces how local, ethnic, and religious communitarian impulses sometimes clashed with Ottoman identification, especially over such issues as military conscription. Mixed spaces like Palestine's Freemason lodges, which included Muslims, Christians, and Jews among their members, sometimes became sites of sectarian and national discord. Jews indigenous to Palestine in particular had to navigate the difficult question of how Ottoman citizenship meshed with their increasing exposure to European Zionism. Ottoman decentralization and Arabist movements also began to offer visions for Palestine's political future that posed potential difficulties for the project of imperial citizenship. By the time World War I approached, the pressures on the concept of civic Ottomanism had already begun to “unscramble the omelet” in a Palestine increasingly divided by sect and ethnicity.
Ottoman Brothers situates itself as a contribution to the historiography on both Ottomanism and 20th-century Palestine—two literatures that have hitherto not much overlapped. It offers a challenge to two major historiographical tropes: first, that Ottomanism collapsed in the face of strongly felt nationalist impulses rising out of the Balkans and the Arab provinces, suggesting instead that civic Ottomanism actually offered a powerfully appealing model for Palestinian political engagement in the years after the 1908 revolution; and second, that the seeds of Arab–Jewish conflict were already present in Ottoman Palestine, suggesting instead that “separation between Jews and Arabs came about as a result of the Zionist–Palestinian conflict—it was not the cause” (p. 19). Both represent valuable correctives to the historical narrative.
Beyond this, Ottoman Brothers offers an important repositioning of late Ottoman Palestinian history into a broader regional and chronological narrative. It demonstrates the essential integration of Palestine within the Ottoman Empire and into global intellectual and political debates of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Further, its themes suggest continuities between the Ottoman and the Mandate periods that scholars have not sufficiently acknowledged. Although the idea of Ottoman imperial citizenship disappeared with the demise of the empire, after the war many of Palestine's most visible figures sought a form of political organization clearly influenced by the concept of civic Ottomanism. Visions of an independent Greater Syrian or Palestinian state, discussed extensively in newspapers, pamphlets, books, and conferences during the early Mandate years, owed a debt not only to Arabist philosophies or to a local Palestinian patriotism but also to the rhetoric of imperial citizenship that imbued public discourse in the last years of Ottoman rule. Campos’ work suggests that the further sectarianization of Palestine that took place during the Mandate period at least partially reflected the inability of a discourse of multiethnic, multireligious, and multilingual citizenship to withstand the dual pressures of a ramped-up European Zionism and the imposition of British colonial rule.
