No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
Sibel Bozdoǧan's much awaited book Modernism and Nation Building: Turkish Architectural Culture in the Early Republic is the first in a promising series published by the University of Washington Press dedicated to exploring the relationship between modernity and nationalism in, preferably though not exclusively, “non–Western” regions, with a special emphasis on cross-disciplinary knowledge. In the absence of even a single English book on Turkish architectural culture in the first half of the 20th century (despite some valuable articles collected in books and printed in journals), the contribution of Bozdoǧan's book to English-speaking scholarship is self-evident. Bernd Nicolai's Moderne und Exil (Berlin: Verlag für Bauwesen, 1998; in German) also recently explored the same period, with a similar emphasis on the relationship between architecture and official nationalist politics, but this work concentrated on the influence of German-speaking architects in the country. Bozdoǧan has chosen a much broader scope and audience. For some, the writer's ambition to speak to the expectations of a multiple audience that includes non-architects, as well as to contribute to the state of scholarly research while simultaneously covering an enormous amount of material unusual for introductory surveys, may seem to limit the book's focus. Yet this is a challenge Bozdoǧan consciously chooses to take on to make the case for the relevance of her topic and historical material to much broader audiences working in cultural studies and in architectural theory, as well as in European architectural history.
Chapters of the book contain overarching information on various architectural topics, including the formal and contextual characters of institutional, recreational, governmental, and residential buildings; architectural education; administrative and legal adjustments in the profession; ideas and ideologies discussed in professional and popular journals and in literary works; official, professional, and popular receptions of modernism in architecture; the role of technological and scientific developments on architecture; and so on. The main thesis that connects these diverse issues demonstrates the strong link between the development of architectural modernism in Turkey and the nation-building policies of Kemalism. Bozdoǧan argues that modernization came to Turkey through the top-down political steps of the official nationalist elite, who related to architecture and town planning as an effective mechanism in realizing their “civilizing mission.” Educating the masses in the city and the countryside in modern school buildings and people's houses; showing the nation how to live in modern garden cities, model villages, and “cubic houses”; telling them how to play sports in modern stadiums and how to spend their recreational time in modern parks; teaching women how to modernize and rationalize their households—these are some of the issues the book handles to demonstrate the multiple ways that symbols of modernity can be disseminated to a whole nation by using the tropes of architecture. The professional architects of the time were also enthusiastic about taking part in this process as civilizing agents. Bozdoǧan demonstrates that most Turkish architects fully embraced the modernizing, Westernizing, and nationalizing tendencies of the official elite, disagreeing with the political authorities only on minor issues concerning the nationality of the authors and their right to build the stone documents for the revolution. So did most of the foreign architects in the country, according to the book, among whose ranks were some of the most critical and anti–Nazi intellectuals of Weimar Germany, including B. Taut, M. Schutte-Lihotzky, and E. Reuter, not to mention literary figures such as E. Auerbach. The book does not stress the voice of an opponent or perhaps even a third group that did not totally agree either with the Kemalist authority or its possible counter-movements. This should underscore both the credibility of the Kemalist project among the professional elite of the time and the difficulty of raising alternative voices.
Among the most decisive arguments Bozdoǧan constructs in the book is the representational nature of modern architecture in Turkey: “in the absence of the industrial and socioeconomic conditions within which modernism emerged in the West, what republican architects imported from Europe remained, in essence, ‘a style.’…[M]odern architecture in Turkey was a contrived representation of a desired but non-existent modernity, not the natural outcome of the country's transformation into a modern society by its own internal dynamics.” (pp. 296–97). What had to be represented through architecture, then? “If fascination with the technological and industrial icons of modernity constituted the futuristic and utopian dimension of the Kemalist revolution, equally important was an archaic dimension through which Kemalism sought to legitimize the idea of a unified Turkish nation” (p. 241). The issue for the architects thus, was to create the formal expressions of both of these aspirations, whose simultaneous emphasis on futurist elements and memory usually acted in tension. Throughout the book, Bozdoǧan shows how Turkish architects, intellectuals, and historians negotiated between and reconciled the expressions of the “modern” (simultaneously perceived as the “Western”) and “national” by asserting the “Turkishness” of the European-inspired “cubic architecture,” the “modernness” of Turkish vernacular architecture, or the “timelessness” and “universality” of European Classical architecture. Such an explanation also allows the writer to go beyond the established historiography of Turkish architectural modernism that explained historical change in relation to stylistic shifts from one decade to another and that treated the “national” and the “international” styles as a binary opposition. The book benefits from being an inclusive synthesis of previous and recent scholarship, including references to Ph.D. studies and even unpublished papers. The writer has chosen extensive and creative primary sources to demonstrate her thesis, including professional, official, and popular magazines, albeit not the official documents from the state archives that could have also been relevant to the topic. The book also contributes to the history of modern architecture in Turkey by bringing together unexplored subjects and documents such as visions of houses in popular magazines, factories, and international fairs.
There is no doubt that Bozdoǧan's book is a comprehensive source for those who are interested in architectural theory and history, cultural and social studies, and the complex modes of relations between modernity and nationalism. It also stands as an exemplary work for readers concerned with the methodological questions of a scholarship that cross disciplinary boundaries.