When I was conducting research on race and racism in a favela in Rio de Janeiro in the early 1990s, I found that people identified themselves through a variety of different registers. The language used to describe ‘identity’ was slippery. The hurt, however, conveyed in stories about encounters with racism, was hard and immovable. The whole tangled issue of race and racism is notoriously thorny not just in Brazil but in Latin America more generally, a region in which the ideologies of mestizaje/mestiçagem have long extolled ‘race mixture’ and denied the significance of race without, at the same time, erasing racism. In the new multicultural century, the apparent puzzle of racism without races, of identities without boundaries, seems only to intensify.
Pigmentocracies is the result of a five-year collaboration among a group of 12 international social scientists, called the Project on Ethnicity and Race in Latin America or PERLA, led by Princeton sociologist Edward Telles. Initiated in 2008, this singularly ambitious project was aimed at generating a quantitative bird's eye view of ethno-racial identity and its impact in Latin America's four largest nations: Brazil, Colombia, Mexico and Peru. (In addition to the book, the project has generated an expanding suite of peer-reviewed papers on diverse topics and a useful website hosted by Princeton at https://perla.princeton.edu/.) The book is composed of chapters devoted to each of the four countries (authored by localised teams) as well as introductory and concluding chapters. Densely illustrated with scores of figures, the chapters are intended to stand alone but many scholars will appreciate the comparative rewards offered by the project's shared methodology.
In addition to its groundbreaking (but strictly quantitative) data sets, Pigmentocracies advances several important conceptual claims, among them, the argument that scholarship on the region is hampered by the failure to consider black and indigenous populations together, and the related but more novel assertion that skin colour (rather than ethno-racial labels) is the likely prism through which discrimination occurs in Latin America, and is therefore the best variable to use in the measurement of inequality. A unique strength of PERLA is in the multiplicity of means used to generate and measure ethno-racial identity. In both open-ended and fixed-response questions, respondents were asked about ethnic self-identification, about ancestors, customs and language, and about racial identity. Respondent-generated data were fortified by two assessments made by survey workers: classification of the respondent via fixed choice categories (white, mestizo, indigenous, black and mulatto) and classification via another of PERLA's signature innovations, the colour palette. In an effort to generate more objective classifications, survey takers were asked to (surreptitiously) compare respondents' skin colours to a card containing a palette of 11 graded shades (reproduced on the book's cover). Readers familiar with the delicate racial etiquette of the region may be perturbed by the implied objectification. Telles and his collaborators concluded that it ‘would be a small price to pay for the benefits of better understanding how colour shapes inequality in the region’ (2014, p. 13).
Significant portions of the book thus engage correlations between one or another of these ethno-racial data sets (e.g. self-identification terms versus skin colour) with a variety of variables related to socio-economic status (e.g. years of schooling, occupation type and income levels). But that is not all. A different set of survey questions asked whether respondents had either witnessed or experienced discrimination associated with identity, and identity was further broken down into that associated with language, with social class, and with skin colour. (It is critical to remember that such questions do not measure actual events but rather, respondents' perceptions of events, which is anything but straightforward in social environments characterised by silence and shame around racism.) Each chapter also presents data on respondents' preferred explanation for the continuing poverty of target minorities. (The close-ended options ranged from ‘they are treated unfairly’ to ‘they are less intelligent’.) Additional questions (and chapter sections) address whether respondents support multicultural policies.
Among the book's most provocative findings are those relating to its central thesis: that despite the public ideologies of mestizaje, Latin Americans continue to behave as if race is real, and race is substantially about skin colour, not social class as has so often been argued. Striking support for this thesis (as well as unexpected results) can be found in the fact that in Mexico, those self-identifying as mestizo are of higher status (measured in terms of years of schooling, for example) than those self-identifying as white. Similarly, those identifying as mulatto in Colombia are better off in terms of socio-economic status than either whites or mestizos. Yet when these correlations are compared with those that employ the colour palette, the data arrayed is a more expectable pattern: lighter-skinned respondents have the highest status, darker-skinned respondents the lowest status, and those with medium skin tones have correspondingly medium status measures. For all of the countries, correlations of skin colour with socio-economic status show substantial advantages for lighter skin and very significant disadvantages for darker skin. From one angle then, the picture is clear, perhaps clearer than it has ever been. This is a signal achievement. From another angle, one related to social mechanisms and the disjunctures among public ideologies, consciousness and behaviour, the puzzle of race and racism in Latin America has only been deepened.
The good news in this book resides in its measurement of attitudes related to ethno-racial policies (ranging from affirmative action to protection of indigenous lands). Latin Americans favour such policies overwhelmingly, with 80 per cent being a commonly cited figure. The contributors speculate that this may be partly due to the fact that such policies, where they exist at all, have had a low impact thus far, but an alternative possibility is that mestizaje-oriented ideologies, no matter how contradictory, actually do lean towards fairness. It is encouraging moreover that although respondents favoured a variety of explanations for continued poverty among minorities, most recognised structural barriers as a principal cause.
Pigmentocracies is sure to be widely read and discussed by scholars, and let us fervently hope, policy-makers, who care about inequality in the Americas. In the end, the book succeeds in raising more questions than it answers. And therein lies its greatest contribution to Latin American studies. Young scholars have many puzzles to ponder and the data invite qualitative as well as additional quantitative investigation. Although PERLA ought to produce solid consensus around the conclusion that race, colour and ethnicity have deep and damaging consequences for the region, we still need, now more than ever, interdisciplinary attention to the question of how these socially constructed features of identity operate on the ground. Among other core issues is that whiteness and its privileges need to be problematised by social scientists and policy-makers. (And the authors of the chapter on Mexico make a good start.) Moreover, as the PERLA data become widely available (as the website promises), we can expect a new wave of theorising around both national and regional patterns. Although PERLAs contributors are not listed here, they are all to be congratulated for a landmark, seminal study of inequality, a deepening problem which promises to be among the most pressing challenges of the twenty-first century.
