The Triconch House of Aphrodisias, previously known as the Bishop's Palace, is one of the best preserved late antique urban residences of Asia Minor. After the 1960s excavations, research was resumed by Michelle Berenfeld as part of her PhD (Institute of Fine Arts, New York University, 2002). Following the preliminary publication of her results (AJA 113.2 (2009), 203–29), the current monograph offers an in-depth overview of the house's developments between the Hellenistic and mid-Byzantine periods within its urban context. B.'s work is thus in line with the increasing research on Hellenistic-Roman and late antique houses in Turkey in the 1990s and 2000s (e.g. at Ephesos, Sagalassos, Hierapolis, Xanthos, Miletos, Laodikeia and Antandros).
The introductory ch. 1 presents the building's history from at least the first century b.c. through the twelfth century a.d., indicating the existence of somewhat obscure ‘micro’-phases alongside the main building phases. She also explains her use of periods and names (justifying her decision to name the complex after its characteristic triconch hall), sketches the residence's urban context and provides an outline and summary. Ch. 2 discusses the fieldwork at the residence in 1963–68 and 1999–2001, paying attention to the investigated structures, stratigraphy and specific small finds.
The organisation of the following four chapters reflects the long occupation history of the residence's site, starting with the hard-to-determine Hellenistic-Roman structures (ch. 3). In the late Hellenistic or early Roman period, a rectangular building with a large courtyard, maybe a prytaneion or gymnasion, was first connected to a pi-shaped complex and from the later second century a.d. onwards to the bouleuterion. In the late third or early fourth century a.d., some rooms of the building, possibly now converted into a residence, were decorated with megalographic wall paintings of Victory and the Three Graces.
Ch. 4 discusses the three main late antique building phases. Around 400 a.d., the Triconch House was built with its triple-apsed hall and northern apsidal room. Here, the organisation of the subheadings is a bit odd since the parts in which B. elaborates upon the interior decoration and furnishings (C) and statuary (D) of this first late antique phase would more logically have been subsections of Phase 1 (B). In the fifth century a.d., the complex underwent significant changes, especially in the courtyard area. Finally, in the sixth century a.d., it was extended with new spaces in the south, blocking the earlier passageway to the bouleuterion and orienting the residence towards the Church in the north. At the end of the chapter, B. concludes that the Triconch House is ‘in many ways a typical example of an elite, late antique domestic building’ (52).
This conclusion is further developed in ch. 5 by comparing the Triconch House with other late antique houses at Aphrodisias and parallels from elsewhere in the empire. B. could have reinforced her argument if she had extended her discussion of recently published upper-class houses in Asia Minor beyond the brief references largely limited to Ephesos and Sardis. For the triconch hall, which is exceptional in eastern domestic contexts, B. mainly draws parallels with rural and urban constructions in the West. Finally, an identification as a possible governor's residence is proposed based on the house's layout and location. As B. points out herself (64), praetoria are not easy to identify in the archaeological record. Indeed, residences of governors, bishops and other late antique elite members shared a common architectural and decorative language. Therefore, the central location of the residence is the strongest element of B.'s identification proposal.
In ch. 6, B. focuses on the building's architectural transformations and new functions from the Middle Byzantine period until its final destruction and abandonment after the eleventh century a.d., placing them against the background of general urban developments. The eighth- to eleventh-century seals of bishops and high ranking imperial officials found in the house (with catalogue) are particularly important. Together with the architectural data, evidence for agricultural and industrial activities and the building's association with the Cathedral and the Bouleuterion area, these seals make B.'s identification as an episcopal precinct convincing.
For all building phases, B. deliberately focuses on architectural and decorative developments and furnishings. As she repeatedly points out (3, 31), it is generally impossible to link objects with the architectural phases since the house was stripped of its contents during its long occupation. B.'s additional attention to the building's broader urban context for each stage of its history is certainly one of the study's substantial assets.
An extremely brief conclusion (ch. 7) in English and Turkish (81–4) is followed by two appendices (an overview of the 2000–2001 excavations and an inventory of sculpture fragments), a bibliography, sources of illustrations and a brief index. Finally, thirty-four well-selected plates complement the thirty-two useful figures accompanying the text itself.
Generally, the text is clearly written, the references to the illustrations are systematic and the entire volume has been carefully prepared (small imprecisions: 21 n. 92: ‘Rumschied’ instead of ‘Rumscheid’; Corridor 12 is not identified on Fig. 18; I. Lockey, The Atrium House (2016) is missing in the bibliography).
Although B.'s monograph could have profited from fuller discussion of the comparative material elsewhere in Asia Minor, it is undoubtedly an excellent contribution to the still under-estimated field of Hellenistic to Byzantine urban housing in this region and the wider Eastern Mediterranean.
