For all that the liberal arts dominated elite education in early modern universities, outside the walls of the schools elite and craft practitioners cooperated in a more utilitarian-oriented inquiry into nature. Deborah E. Harkness's latest book illustrates the close marriage of scientific theory and practice in the period by taking readers on a phantasmagorical journey through a major European urban centre. She aims to produce ‘a kind of Baedeker's guide to a strange and unfamiliar City’ (p. 14). She has succeeded admirably. Elizabethan London in her pages comes to life as a sprawling network of colourful people engaged in diverse sciences. Her achievement adds much-needed flesh to the bones of the claim, made in the mid-twentieth century by Edgar Zilsel and others, that an artisanal and technical undercurrent created propitious conditions for the rise of modern science. She even makes a persuasive case for the restoration of the term ‘science’ (the word that, as she shows, many of her Elizabethan subjects used to describe their efforts) for what is considered by many historians nowadays to be the less anachronistic ‘natural philosophy’.
In the first of six chapters we encounter a schism in Lime Street's community of botanical and natural-history practitioners following John Gerard's publication of The herball. At the eleventh hour, the publishers were informed that The herball was nothing more than a hotchpotch of plagiarized passages, yet it went on to become ‘a monument of early botanical knowledge’ (p. 19). Harkness argues that although Gerard may be widely regarded as ‘the father of English botany,’ this honour belongs instead to the city's indefatigable but unsung community of botanists – ‘the Lime Street naturalists’. This dynamic group was so self-assured and integrated within a network of naturalists at home and abroad that it failed to publish, relying instead on face-to-face communication and manuscript exchange. This is a fascinating story of what Harkness calls the ‘egregious misuse’ of a community who welcomed collaborative opportunities, by an unscrupulous author who is remembered as ‘Elizabethan England's premier naturalist’ (pp. 18, 55).
In the remaining chapters, Harkness demonstrates the value of revisiting archival materials to support novel interpretations of familiar territory. In Chapter 2, she examines the contest over medical authority between the itinerant German surgeon Valentine Russwurin and the English barber-–surgeons. Like Gerard, the barber–surgeons turned to print as they attempted to increase their presence within the city's fiercely competitive medical arena. However, in contrast to the case of the Lime Street naturalists, where failure to publish proved fatal, Harkness finds that London's unlicensed medical practitioners benefited from a vibrant and anarchic medical market that resisted regulatory control. In the latter case, the day-to-day social dynamics between patient and practitioner meant that print was not as important to survival.
Chapter 3 focuses on the impact of the publication of the Billingsley-Dee edition of Euclid's Elements in 1570. This innovative work endorsed mathematical literacy as a means to further England's economic growth. Harkness suggests that the resurgence in mathematical education which flowed from the Billingsley-Dee approach, with its equal emphases on theory and practice, led to the expansion of mathematical literacy among ordinary Londoners. In the following chapter, Harkness examines the growth of what she terms an ‘Elizabethan Big Science’ that depended upon the increased technical facility with instrumentation and the political willingness of the Crown to finance the city's projectors (p. 143). Here we encounter William Cecil, who brokered patronage disputes for Elizabeth and oversaw high-risk alchemical and metallurgical projects, including making gold in a period facing a currency crisis. In Chapter 5 we are introduced to the merchant Clement Draper, imprisoned for debt in the King's Bench prison in the 1580s and 1590s. Whilst incarcerated, he filled his notebooks with all manner of experiments relating to medicine, mining and chemistry. For Harkness, Draper's method of digesting and circulating natural knowledge drawn from a wide variety of sources shows the error of separating prima facie literary exercises (reading and taking notes) from manual activities of ‘making and doing’ (p. 209). However, she argues that it was another Londoner, Hugh Plat, who transformed Draper's fundamentally encyclopedic manner of recording into a more methodical approach to experimentally derived knowledge.
Harkness ends by comparing Hugh Plat's and Francis Bacon's approaches to experimental practice, focusing on Plat's Jewel House and Salomon's House in Bacon's New Atlantis. She argues that ‘whereas Hugh Plat was deeply embedded in the messy, decentralized world of Elizabethan London science, Bacon was an outsider to that world and held himself aloof from it, severely criticizing its values, practices, and personnel’ (p. 13). According to Harkness, Bacon, who was ‘never fully comfortable with the inductive world of experiments and those who performed them,’ avoided ‘the empirics, alchemists, old women, compilers of recipe books, manual laborers, artists, and craftsmen’ (p. 247). But a brief glance at Bacon's Catalogue of Particular Histories reveals the crucial role of practitioners in his Instauration. Among the arts listed there, we find medical history of cures, history of cooking, history of weaving, history of gardening, history of the blacksmith's art – in other words, the very subjects with which Harkness is preoccupied throughout her book. Bacon repeatedly laments that without a collection of the experiments of all mechanical arts, his Great Instauration will undoubtedly fail. It is regrettable that Harkness fails to marshal this evidence in support of her main claim, namely that the Scientific Revolution has its roots in vernacular science.
This book is undoubtedly a staggering achievement. It demonstrates the success of the ethnographic approach to early modern science outlined in the Coda. Harkness's meticulous archival scrutiny, her ability to trail such a motley crew of fascinating characters and her effortless and graceful prose all contribute to her compelling narrative. She has shown that when analysing the rise of modern science, Elizabethan London's abundance of scientific expertise must be taken into account. Harkness's journey through the ‘jewel house’ of Elizabethan London vividly illustrates how elite learning allied to practical expertise created favourable conditions for the burgeoning of early modern English science.
