Modelling state formation processes in pre-Roman Italy has not been an overly popular subject of study, despite the increasing sophistication of approaches available to archaeologists. The fragmentary nature of the evidence and the dispersed state of its publication render the task of building quality datasets to conduct an analysis difficult. Moreover, state formation processes are notoriously difficult to study without literary evidence, for the sheer challenge of defining a clear political process that can be quantified and hypothetically predicted and tested. The aim of Simon Stoddart’s work is to study state formation processes in pre-Roman Etruria by looking at the evolution of territories within the natural landscape, drawing on XTENT modelling to predict expanding territories around central places and to identify potential conflicts rising between overlapping areas of interest. The assumption is that central places seek to increase control over the surrounding landscape to maximise the accumulation of resources needed to support centralisation.
The study consists of eight chapters, including introduction and conclusion, and provides a selection of black-and-white figures, maps and graphs in addition to the text. In the introduction, S. outlines the ambition of his work, which is to provide a radically new approach to the study of Etruscan state formation, diverging from more traditional art-historical and text-based narratives. By adopting a strictly archaeological, quantitative and landscape-oriented approach, S. hopes to draw Etruscan state formation studies out of their particularism and raise interest from a broader, comparative perspective of state formation processes in ancient societies. While the approach itself is not radically new, as S. admits, the scale of his study, ranging from the Late Bronze Age roughly to Classical/Hellenistic times for both southern and northern Etruria and the adjacent Faliscan region and Umbria, is unprecedented and provides a systematic account of development within and between the regions in question.
The second and third chapters outline the theoretical, methodological and historical background to the analytical discussions that constitute the fourth and fifth chapters. Drawing on Joseph Tainter's concept of state as composed of a centre and its dependent territory (The Collapse of Complex Societies, 1988) and J. Friedman and M. J. Rowland's assumption that control over territories increases with the development of political power (in J. Friedman and M. J. Rowland (eds), The Evolution of Social Systems, 1977, 201–75), S. models the expansion of state territories in Etruria using C. Renfrew and E. V. Level's XTENT mathematical model of territory (in C. Renfrew and K. L. Cooke (eds), Transformations: Mathematical Approaches to Culture Change, 1979). In the XTENT model, a state's area of influence is a function of the size of its central settlement and a parameter k, which governs how influence declines with distance. S. models ten successive phases of state formation by assigning ten decreasing values to k, simulating the expansion of territories. The main value of the different models lies in their highlighting corridors of political vacuum, usually situated in geographical features such as river valleys, lakes and prominent mountains. S. points out a marked difference in development between northern and southern Etruria, with more competition and smaller territories in the south in contrast to wider-spaced and larger territories in the north.
The sixth chapter provides a brief overview of previously studied patterns of rural settlement and the location and density of principal settlements. The discussion is anecdotical and limited to selected regions from southern Etruria: the Albegna valley, the Maremma and its hinterland, the Chiusi region and the region of Perugia and Gubbio. The chapter aims at highlighting some localised developments in territories, whose interaction and interdependence is explored from a broader, Mediterranean perspective in the following chapter. The eighth and last chapter situates the book's outcome within a scholarly context. S. highlights the important role that his central places play within trans-Mediterranean networks of exchange, functioning as hubs through which innovations such as terracotta decoration or writing are diffused to secondary sites within the settlement system. S. announces forthcoming work focused on rural settlement in Etruria that will provide a bottom-up view to complement the present, macro-scale narrative.
As S. makes explicit throughout this work, the intended readership of his study is threefold: an English-speaking public of scholars working on state formation processes from a comparative perspective; scholars interested in modelling (Etruscan) social and political interaction from a landscape perspective; and students and scholars interested in the archaeology of Etruria but without the necessary language skills to access the original research, which is mostly published in Italian. The book does exactly what it sets out to do: provide a series of hypothetical models to open a discussion based on material evidence rather than (later) text-based narratives that often have a more limited scope. This is a conscious and somewhat polemical choice, setting the study apart from mainstream research as conducted in Italy and the rest of Europe. The study would have found a broader readership had there been more engagement with current debates. S. justifies his approach by explaining the book's origin in earlier research, which has been expanded and systematised for publication, but without aiming at comprehensive description of all sites or previous research discussed. The result is that S.'s conclusions, while certainly interesting, will be questioned by some for a lack of a grounding in detail and scholarship. The strength of the work therefore lies in providing a macro-scale narrative about the development of power over landscapes in Etruria. It provides a framework for future research by the author and others, whereby, it is to be hoped, micro and macro perspectives can be fully integrated.
