No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
In his welcome analysis of the formation of mosques in the United States over the past five decades, Akel Ismail Kahera reaches beyond the specific history he has written to explore the links between Islamic thought and Islamic architecture. In addition, Kahera's book can be considered a contribution to comparative research on Islamic and Western architecture.
Following a remarkable Introduction, Chapter 1 examines spatial characteristics of American mosques, relying on the author's notion of “spatial sunnah,” which is analogous to the major spatial configurations of the Prophet's mosque built at Madinah in 622. In Chapter 2, Kahera looks for an “aesthetic autonomy” for the mosque in North America as he examines the visual affinities between the American mosques (from the avant-garde design of the Islamic Cultural Center in New York City to the traditional-looking Islamic Cultural Center of Washington, D.C.) and those from Islamic lands. The third chapter considers the relevance of culture and identity to the making of the American mosque as a place for Muslim public gathering. In this chapter, Kahera also devotes a section to an aspect of Islamic architecture that has been largely neglected by most scholars: issues of gender.
One might assume from the title that Kahera's analysis owes much to Jacques Derrida's philosophy of deconstruction. However, in this book deconstruction refers to the concepts of subject and object introduced in the 13th-century by Ibn

Arabi. Indeed, in all three chapters, Kahera bases his analyses on the key elements of traditional Islamic thought as found in the hadith literature, Qura

nic texts, Sunni Islamic law, and medieval Islamic philosophy.
Diverging from the dichotomy of subject and object (as advanced by Hegel), Derrida rejected the subordination of art to any form of logocentrism, thus reinforcing the instability of binary oppositions. To Ibn

Arabi, however, the dichotomy of subject–object conjures up the antithesis of the two in which subject and object will merge into one. This idea “allows for the possibility that beauty—aside from being one of the attributes of God (al-Jamāl)—also expresses qualities of created existence” (p. 12). Correspondingly, “Ibn

Arabi considers the architect(s) … authorized agent of creativity” (p. 12). According to Kahera, this interpretation originates in tawḥīd, “which considers the human being an authority figure … blessed by … Allah” (p. 12). Moreover, “tawḥīd affects the use of imagery…in religious aesthetics” (p. 146) and gives birth to harmony and stability. Kahera's use of Ibn

Arabi's “theory of deconstruction” contributes to three debates about American mosques—first, “a careful analysis of … design”; second, “an interpretation of the semantics of the term ‘masjid’”; and third, “a critique of space, gender, and aesthetics” (p. 21).
Although he seeks to bridge the gap that divides conceptions of space—as they relate to philosophy and other realms of thought—in Islam from the West, Kahera tends to belittle Western contributions. For example, he emphasizes that it is important to avoid “meaningless and obvious generalities” (p. 25) in describing the mosque, yet he alludes to Western endeavors in just such terms: “in the West beauty is commonly trivialized, reduced to decoration, or equated with the insipidities of bad taste” (p. 13). Further, while emphasizing that his use of deconstruction is “significantly unrelated to Derrida's philosophy” (p. 1), the author's argument would have been stronger had he fully addressed the advocates of the Derrida's notion of deconstruction in relation to Ibn

Arabi's philosophy.
In search of a genuine visual expression for the contemporary American mosque, Kahera makes a distinction between Islamic aesthetics and those of the West. He maintains that there are two unique orders that shape the structural patterns in the mosques: “first, their essence … (bāṭinī), and second, their external appearance (ẓāhirī)” (p. 77). This notion introduces his discussion of classic binary oppositions between the body and the soul and ultimately conveys the importance of both in Islamic architecture—a belief central to Ibn

Arabi's philosophy.
According to Kahera, René Descartes's “Cogito ergo sum suggests that thinking … [is] the real substance of being, but it also celebrates the separation of the mind from the body and … activities of being” (p. 116). Kahera argues that “this Cartesian maxim … adopted in the West … is related to the crisis of architecture, which is … also a human crisis” (p. 116). By relying mainly on the 17th-century views of Descartes, Kahera neglects classic studies of corporeality established by Plato and Aristotle, as well as contemporary trends in Western philosophy—in particular, feminist theory and deconstruction—which have also influenced Western architectural design.
In Chapter 3, Kahera discusses the history of the position of women in the mosque. This section needs to be expanded to incorporate the diverse narrative of women from various Islamic countries. Kahera's examples from Egypt and Saudi Arabia provide an incomplete picture of women's access to the mosque in Islamic societies. In both Chapter 3 and the Conclusion, Kahera offers considerable analyses of Muslim gathering in American mosques, but he makes little reference to the bigoted attitudes that Muslims have often faced.
Aside from these concerns, the book provides an excellent study of the historical elements of mosques and their influence on all types of contemporary American mosques. Although some of the discussion tends at times to be overly generalized, Kahera's attempt to trace the key elements of contemporary Western theory, such as semiotics, representation, power, and subjectivity, to Islamic (mostly Sunni) cultural, legal, and religious patterns is a worthy contribution to the study of Islamic architecture, material culture, and religion in America.