The WOW Café Theatre is an Off-Off Broadway performance space and social club that has served as a laboratory for the production of progressive lesbian and feminist communities and radical artistic experimentation for more than thirty years, though it rarely appears in mainstream or alternative histories of queer art and activism. Kate Davy's inspired and highly anticipated Lady Dicks and Lesbian Brothers: Staging the Unimaginable at the WOW Café Theatre provides a welcome corrective to the amnesiac underpinnings and historical selectivity of American theatre chronicles. A herculean feat almost three decades in the making, this book has its roots in 1984, the year that Davy's mind was blown after visiting a small hand-to-mouth storefront theatre populated by women, most of whom were lesbians, producing sexually explicit performances in an erotically infused environment that permeated absolutely every dimension of the Café.
Davy has spent the better part of twenty-five years compiling scripts, conducting interviews, and amassing ephemera from WOW participants to create a comprehensive (though nonlinear) narrative of this anarchic collective's emergence and continuing cultural significance. Some of the most celebrated artists of the twentieth century have honed their talent and temerity at WOW, including Split Britches (Lois Weaver, Peggy Shaw, and Deb Margolin); Holly Hughes (one of the notorious NEA Four); Alina Troyano (aka that fruity vixen Carmelita Tropicana); Reno; Lisa Kron; and The Five Lesbian Brothers (Kron, Moe Angelos, Dominique Dibbell, Peggy Healy, and Babs Davy, Kate's younger sister).
In lively and engaging prose, Davy contextualizes WOW in relation to the crucible of creativity that was New York's East Village club scene, to the aesthetics and politics of the LGBT movement, and to the internecine strife precipitated by the feminist sex wars. Davy limits her analysis to productions she personally attended, including influential work that predated WOW in the 1970s, namely the campy antics of Charles Ludlam's Ridiculous Theatrical Company and the mixed-gender troupe Hot Peaches. The lone exception to this rule is a detailed account of WOW's genesis, which Davy was not around to witness. The Café grew out of a pair of international women's theatre festivals in 1980 and 1981 organized by a quixotic quartet calling themselves the Allied Farces (Weaver, Shaw, Pamela Camhe, and Jordy Mark). Emblematic of the industrious spirit of radical feminism and the do-it-yourself ethic that is an integral part of its praxis, these four visionaries managed to stage consecutive Women's One World (WOW) festivals with very little money (not a dime came from grants or institutional support) and even less experience. These carnivals featured an eclectic mix of talent from across the globe, including artists of color. One such act, the aptly named The Flamboyant Ladies—a troupe of “very black, very erotic, very lesbian, and very political women” spearheaded by Alexis De Veaux and Gwendolen Hardwick—was so risqué that it almost got the organizers evicted from their space (74).
Documenting the centrality of women of color to the WOW festivals and the Café is one of Lady Dicks and Lesbian Brothers's most significant contributions to theatre history; the fleshing out of Camhe and Mark's influence is another. While their efforts were equal to Shaw and Weaver's in terms of staging the festivals and fostering innovative, sexually saturated performance practices, Camhe and Mark's names are regrettably absent in most accounts of WOW's dawning. Davy not only restores this eclipsed history of the Café's founding, she cites Camhe and her drag performances of male and female characters as evidence to refute the absurd (but all too prevalent) notion that lesbians did not engage in public forms of sexual expression, experiment with hilarious and hyperbolic self-fashioning, or explore the theatricalization of identity until gay men showed us how. While the Allied Farces parted company shortly after the second festival, Camhe and Mark's imprint on the WOW Café can no longer be ignored.
Davy credits Shaw and Weaver with laboring to establish a permanent space for WOW, first at 330 E. 11th Street, then at its current location on E. 4th Street; for their decades of sacrifice and service to the collective; and for the enormous influence they exerted on subsequent generations of performers. WOW became a social club for bad girls and wayward women, and a foundry for forging outlandish, shamelessly licentious performances rooted in the parodic inversion of genres, cultural norms, and audience expectations. WOW operates, then and now, on sweat equity—you work on my show, I'll work on yours—and the only requirement for membership is attendance at the weekly Tuesday meeting. A model of creative survival and coalition building, the collective's rules are confined to a single sheet of paper, and the theatre functions on an operating budget of less than $20,000 per year.
WOW artists have positioned themselves, consciously and strategically, in opposition to mainstream theatre, avoiding anything (including certain grants) that might impinge upon their creative freedom and political ideals. Though the collective is antibureaucratic (eschewing fixed or even rotational leadership and detailed record keeping), it is not, Davy takes pains to point out, anticonfrontational. Fights at WOW are legendary, and the author details some of the more colorful ones, including the rift that led to the expulsion of Sarah Schulman, who found the Café's structurelessness tyrannical, a recipe for what she termed “a psychological cult” that developed around its de facto stewards Shaw and Weaver (115).
Playing both erudite academic and passionate spectator, Davy shows us how the degenerate denizens of WOW created sexual vernaculars for speaking lesbian desire in/as performance, and produced, in electrifyingly close proximity with their audiences, subversive interpretations of bodies and how they matter onstage and off. Davy's book is by no means an exhaustive or definitive history of WOW—no single study could attend to the hundreds of performances by the hundreds of women who have strutted their stuff at the Café, though the author's massive appendix makes great strides toward this end—and further, it is, surprisingly short on visuals. Given the number of photographs and fliers, tickets and invitations that Davy unearthed, it is a shame that she did not include more images in the book. That said, however, Lady Dicks and Lesbian Brothers is a remarkable scholarly achievement, one that addresses egregious omissions in the historical record and charts an alternative genealogy of feminism and its relationship to queer theory by tracing the impulses, desires, influences, and exigencies that conspired to make the WOW Café an artistic possibility and a material reality.
