The Fourth Annual Ename International Colloquium, entitled “Between Objects and Ideas: Rethinking the Role of Intangible Heritage,” was held in Ghent, Belgium, March 26–28, 2008. Focusing on the intellectual and practical relationship between tangible and intangible heritage and its implications for the shaping of international heritage policy, it featured 40 speakers representing universities, museums, universities, and heritage organizations in Belgium, Canada, China, France, Greece, Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland, Thailand, Turkey, Sweden, the United Kingdom, and the United States. As in previous years, the colloquium was organized by the Ename Center for Public Archaeology and Heritage Presentation, with support from the Province of East Flanders.
Plenary addresses dealing with heritage policy and the official treatment of intangible heritage were given by Andrew Hall (International Council on Monuments and Sites [ICOMOS] South Africa), “The Space Between Object and Idea—Is there Room for Officialdom?”; Christian Hottin (Direction de l'Architecture et du Patrimoine, Mission Ethnologie, Ministry of Culture France), “Intangible Cultural Heritage and the Culture of Tangible Heritage: Fortunes and Misfortunes of the Implementation of the 2003 UNESCO Convention in France”; and Marc Jacobs (FARO—The Flemish Support Centre for Cultural Heritage), “A Goose Laying Golden Eggs? Quick Wins or Long Runs: Intangible Cultural Heritage, Safeguarding and the 2003 UNESCO Convention.” Plenaries dealing with theoretical dimensions were presented by Neil Silberman (Ename Center, Belgium), “Wrestling with Change: The Role of Intangible Heritage in Economics, Society, and Collective Memory,” and Laurier Turgeon (Laval University, Canada), “Intangible Cultural Heritage: Policies, Politics and Practices.”
The goal of the Fourth Annual Ename Colloquium was to provide a forum for discussion of the concepts, definitions, context, and implementation procedures of the 2003 UNESCO Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH). To that end the contributed paper sessions concentrated on the following themes.
DEFINING THE BOUNDARY BETWEEN TANGIBLE AND INTANGIBLE
Is intangible heritage merely a new category of heritage subjects? Or does it represent an entirely new approach that must effectively integrate curated objects, protected places, living traditions, and collective memory? Through examples and case studies we examine how we can identify the tangible dimensions of intangible heritage, the intangible dimensions of material heritage, and complexity of their interrelation. Is the concept of ICH merely one of classification, or is it perhaps of an entirely different interpretive quality?
THE CHALLENGE: SAFEGUARDING OR FACILITATING?
The UNESCO Convention defines ICH as “transmitted from generation to generation” and “constantly recreated by communities and groups in response to their environment, their interaction with nature, and their history.” In light of this dynamic definition, to what extent can we ever capture or safeguard essential expressions of ICH when they are necessarily and constantly evolving? Does this challenge require as much attention to the frameworks of public participation in heritage as to specific expressions or sites? What innovative projects or programs have succeeded in bridging this gap?
WHO OWNS INTANGIBLE HERITAGE?
The traditional structures of heritage administration are often focused on a national level. Certainly, this is true in the case of both UNESCO conventions (1972 World Heritage and 2003 ICH), where state parties are the critical voices. But if ICH is an expression of community identity on all levels, what of local or regional expressions of culture and identity that may actually be in conflict or tension with the state? What role do traditional rituals, art forms, and crafts play in the political, economic, social, and cultural lives of the individuals and communities that maintain them?
Because of the dynamic, experiential nature of intangible heritage, the colloquium concluded with participatory workshops—led by practitioners, rather than scholars—of West African percussion and Flemish puppeteering, as well as special interest tours of Ghent that highlighted the city's cuisine heritage, folk art, and local high art of its opera house.
