The apparent failure of the swine flu virus to live up to its apocalyptic reputation is the latest in a long line of public overreactions to bugs. A nineteenth-century case in point was the Colorado beetle – a more literal bug whose predicted arrival in Britain was prophesied to have dire agricultural effects. To general relief, the invasion did not materialize, and the bug left no more noxious results in Britain than a slew of execrable music-hall ephemera and Punch cartoons. (Did anybody ever actually laugh out loud at Punch?) For J.F.M. Clark, however, this elusive but culturally very real beetle was one of several key turning points in the story of the professionalization of entomology, a story that lasts through a long Victorian era from the 1810s to the First World War.
Clark's account begins with William Kirby and William Spence, whose Introduction to Entomology (1815) is dutifully cited by all historians of entomology, but has rarely (if ever) been properly analysed. Clark tidily maps their view of insects onto their political outlooks. In Spence's case, this was a secular Toryism closely allied to the rural critique of William Cobbett, while for the Reverend Kirby, conservatism was an expression of Anglican conformity. The debates that immediately followed about the nature of insectan instinct (rationally explicable or divinely placed?) are examined in detail, but despite their longevity into the twentieth century these discourses disappear from Clark's purview as the book gets its teeth into its main topic – the professionalizing trends of the late nineteenth century.
In Clark's telling, the history of entomology in Britain went through several phases. A very important one saw the dominance of a generalized intellectual clerisy, favoured by the X-Club and expressed in the entomological endeavours of its member John Lubbock. Lubbock's genteel interest in insectan natural history for the sake of genteel biological problems found an echo in the work and influence of Edward Poulton, second Hope Professor of Zoology at the University of Oxford. Poulton was a lepidopterist who used the markings of his butterflies to pose and resolve questions about evolution in general, latterly from a neo-Darwinian perspective. Nevertheless, Poulton's work was a dead end in the history of entomology per se. The next phase was the absorption of insects into a broader programme of scientific expertise – a technocratic project of the very late nineteenth century, or the turn of the twentieth, linked to enlightened government of the colonies and efficiency and welfare at home. Clark's prose hints at the upsides and downsides of this process: on the one hand, he describes the unquestionable achievements of the discipline of economic entomology in terms of institutional growth; on the other, he alludes to what seems to be almost a disappearance of the study of insects for their own sake. This high price for the success of entomology was articulated in the pseudonymously published Journal of a Disappointed Man (1919), whose author cursed the ‘very low hole of Economic Entomology’, and despaired, ‘Why can't I either have a first-rate disease or be a first-rate zoologist?’ (pp. 199–200). Clark misses his own most striking piece of evidence for this depressing trend: Figure 10.4, a poster warning against the threat of the fly, actually portrays the enemy with eight legs. It is the crassest of zoological errors, yet apparently unimportant in the context of entomological propaganda.
The role of Eleanor Ormerod in the overall story is interestingly problematic. Ormerod, whose dates coincide very closely with those of Victoria herself, was a genteel authority on insect life who worked closely with such organizations as the Royal Horticultural Society, the Science and Art Department, the Royal Agricultural College and the Royal Agricultural Society. All benefited from her great knowledge and ability to marshal insectan information from around the country. Glimpses of Ormerod's personality are intriguing; she was protective of her genteel status – and of that of her knowledge – not least by refusing payment. She was also scrupulous in her anti-feminist demurrals that her knowledge could not have been derived without the assistance of male colleagues. Only when extremely vexed could she be roused to articulate frustration at the limitations imposed on her sex by Victorian scientific culture. Were her demurrals for real, I found myself wondering, or were they part of an instrumental strategy to bolster her credibility at any personal cost? Clark, it appears, has to paint Ormerod as an expert in order to explain the rise of economically oriented entomology, but he is then left with a problem, for, as a woman, she is not a strong historical lynchpin for his posited increase in disciplinary authority. He therefore repeatedly asserts her scientific expertise in order to strengthen his argument, but part of me was left speculating what difference a more sceptical view of her authority would make to his overall thesis. I would like to have heard more from Clark on the topic – always the sign of a good book.
For all its revelations, Bugs and the Victorians does not move much beyond the professional angle. There is little attention to the vast array of popular entomological literature extant in the Victorian era. More's the pity, as it would have been illuminating to know how the public appetite for resolutely amateur writing (and art, and, later, film) on insects diminished or sharpened concurrent moves towards professionalization. Lubbock's Ants, Bees and Wasps (1882), for example, cannot be fully understood except against such a backdrop. But quibbles aside, this book gives a fascinating and historically grounded sense of the multiple lives of insects and their students in Victorian Britain. It is beautifully written, and even readers whose research lies outside the history of Victorian science or the emerging field of ‘animal studies’ are likely to enjoy it.
