The decade of the 1940s intrigues historians of twentieth-century South Africa; many believe that significant opportunities to reform white supremacy existed that would not present themselves again for more than thirty years. The issue of entering the war on Britain's side realigned white politics, bringing openly into question some of the settled policies of the inter-war period. The segregationist order appeared vulnerable as the mobilisation of domestic resources and white personnel for fighting abroad undermined the state's ability to keep pace institutionally with rapid wartime industrialisation, black urbanisation and black workplace and community militancy. In January 1942, Prime Minister Smuts, one of the principal architects of the South African system, famously recorded that ‘isolation was gone and segregation had fallen on evil days, too’.
Looking forwards from the perspective of the early 1940s, the contributors to this volume suggest that the restorationist rigour of post-1948 apartheid was not the only possible, or even necessarily the most plausible, historical sequel to these developments. In areas from housing, education and outdoor leisure to health care, industrial relations and welfare payments, influential elements within the white establishment were willing to contemplate blacks as social, if not (yet) political, citizens in a shared South Africa. Tellingly, Smuts's 1942 address returned repeatedly to the theme of ‘trusteeship’: Africans were not being urged to take their destiny into their own hands, and the first six substantive chapters detail the scope and limitations of the many top-down initiatives that white officials and experts entertained. Most of the remaining chapters help us to locate the boundaries of officially sponsored reformism by exploring the careers and ideas of individuals not easily accommodated within it – the Africanist politician A.P. Mda, the enterprising Benoni squatter leader Harry Mabuya, the liberal intellectual Guy Butler, the eclectic leftist Yusuf Dadoo, and the Anglican human rights campaigner Michael Scott. It might well have been more difficult for Smuts and the United Party leadership to draw back from the reformism that the exigencies of wartime had caused them initially to encourage, had this reformist impulse been sufficiently capacious to draw upon the energies of even the least threatening of such ‘outsiders’. A further chapter, on nationalist attempts to redirect Afrikaner workers' leisure pursuits, is interesting in its own right but less consistent with the volume's ‘counterfactual’ emphasis.
Historiographically, this is a timely book. Historians writing in the late apartheid period, with the evidence of the regime's fragility before them, were willing to explore how the economic and social upheavals of the 1940s informed the contradictions and compromises of early apartheid ideology and policy. Now, well into the post-apartheid era, the liberal nationalist, social democratic and black entrepreneurial alternatives on offer in the 1940s can be considered in some senses as precursors rather than historical dead ends.
