The aim of this book, as explained in the introduction, is to investigate two new statue types — or perhaps more correctly, costumes — for men created in the late antique period; the statue type wearing a long cloak or chlamys (chlamydatus) and the statue wearing a new form of the toga (togatus). It wants to contrast trends in the East and West and, above all, to understand costume in terms of official and social rank. It takes into consideration literary and epigraphic sources as well as visual evidence in all media. The topic has never been comprehensively addressed, and the last fifty years have added many new finds and much new research on various aspects of the subject. The book is, thus, a welcome contribution.
It is ambitious in its scope (four pages are dedicated to a detailed table of contents). The eleven chapters are as follows: 1. ‘The Costume of Late-Antique Office-Holders’; 2. ‘The Introduction of New Forms of Representation’; 3. ‘The Development of Late-Antique Official Representation in The Fourth Century’; 4. ‘Late-Antique Togati and Chlamydati in the East of the Empire’; 5. ‘Late-Antique Honorific Statues in the West of the Empire’; 6. ‘The Iconology of Late-Antique Statues’; 7. ‘Eulogy: Inscriptions on Late-Antique Honorific Bases’; 8. ‘Late-Antique Inscribed Bases in the West’; 9. ‘Considerations on Imperial and Magistrate Portraits in Late-Antiquity’; 10. ‘Conclusion’; and 11. ‘Catalogue’ (of portrait statues and busts divided into categories of Porphyry, East, and West). The organization of these chapters and some inconsistencies in their titles are perhaps traces of the book's origin as a doctoral thesis. The lack of an index and references to pages where each catalogue entry is discussed are related frustrations for the reader.
Importantly, however, the book presents an overwhelming amount of interesting factual information and is well-researched and well-documented. The initial discussion of late antique clothing provides a good example of this encyclopaedic approach. The distinguishing costume features of the chlamys and new toga (colobium, belts, tablium, segmenta etc.) are all described in detail (sometimes twice, if they occur on both types). The individual entries in the catalogue and the discussion of each piece are full, and the conclusions are clear. Gehn believes that the two new costumes are to be associated with specific ranks. The chlamys, with its long-standing military connotations, was suitable for all high-ranking officials from praeses to praetorian prefect; it marked its wearer symbolically as a miles and an executor of imperial justice. The toga costume was used in more specific cases with particular reference to traditional consular privileges, as in the case of the proconsular governor of Asia or Africa, or to the title consularis. The monuments of the East and West are essentially distinguished by their traditions: in the East public locations and poetic dedications and in the West domestic settings and emphasis on the traditional cursus honorum. Other points are to be inferred from the discussions and the catalogue. Notably, G. considers only ten honorific statues from the West, all from Rome and Ostia or Puteoli (as opposed to forty-seven from the East), and among those from the West there are no chlamydati.
The book has perhaps two weaknesses, one methodological and one practical, which diminish its impact. Firstly, it relies too much on the same kind of stylistic dating as its predecessors, and thus perpetuates subjective arguments and old-fashioned methods. References to such dating as fact and discussion of groups of portraits based on modelling or eye-markings distract the reader from the main iconographic and historical points. For example, the Ostia togatus from the Forum Baths (W 2), sometimes identified with Ragonius Vincentius Celsus, cannot be securely dated, and entering into the scholarly debate on stylistic grounds does not move G.'s work on togati forward. The reader really wants to know whether G. thinks that it is possible that the new toga form (which appears in other media in Rome, see p. 187) is found only twice in statuary in the West (W 9 and 10) because of continued re-use of old monuments even in the Theodosian period for economic reasons, because of an ingrained and/or deliberate conservatism or simply because of a lack of evidence. How might the Ostia togatus fit into these different possible scenarios? If it were Celsus, how might he compare to the securely-identified and virtually contemporary statue of Virius Audentius Aemilianus from Puteoli (W 8)? These approaches would do better justice to his arguments about rank and honorands and East and West.
Secondly, the book lacks a simple presentation of the datasets required to follow and assess its arguments: lists of the offices and their hierarchy, the numbers of these monuments and their geographic distribution. Some of the following would have been helpful: a diagram of the two statue types with all their elements labelled, a table of the offices of Late Antiquity and the office-holders most likely to be honoured, some representation of the numbers of statues in these costumes related to statues in other costumes, of statues to bases, of monuments in the East to those in the West, of chlamydati to new togati. Fortunately, much of this hard data is now available in the searchable on-line database ‘The Last Statues of Antiquity’ (http://laststatues.classics.ox.ac.uk/), to which G. was a major contributor. The database can give answers to these questions and provides a fuller catalogue of the statuary combined with the bases.
Although the book has flaws, it is a valuable contribution to scholarship, offering an up-to-date and comprehensive analysis of an important body of material and giving impetus to further debate.
