Krin Gabbard has written a joyful book about the trumpet, which has as its subtext the eternal quest for masculinity through music, especially black music. Combining detailed biographical sketches of Buddy Bolden, Louis Armstrong, and Miles Davis, and additional chapters elucidating the history of the trumpet, its health hazards, and its manufacturing processes, Gabbard also provides a disarming story of himself as an aspiring trumpet player returning to the horn after decades of idle lips.
In Gabbard's view the trumpet reached its apotheosis in jazz through the work of heroic trumpet players such as Buddy Bolden and Louis Armstrong, who found in the trumpet a perfect way to assert their manhood at a historical moment when U.S. racism insisted that African American men be called “boy.” The trumpet's loudness, the strength required to play the instrument, as well as its historical associations with the military, warfare, and kings, are among the qualities that make that instrument a suitable vehicle for symbolizing manly power and achievement. The seductive sound of the instrument and its ability to earn the adulation of women are, for Gabbard, equal partners in the mystique and allure of the trumpet.
Gabbard evocatively describes the sound of Buddy Bolden's horn as it accompanied couples dancing the slow drag with bodies enlaced in early New Orleans. Louis Armstrong's healthy sexual appetites as well as his virtuosity and originality are much discussed, and Gabbard does not shy away from portraying the trumpeter's enjoyment of scatological humor. Indeed, the instrument as a whole is portrayed as embodying these high/low qualities that stand at the center of U.S. culture—simultaneously brute strength, nerdy obsession, and transcendent beauty.
Gabbard's book provides delightful historical and technical details that will appeal to trumpet aficionados. Who knew, for example, that the oldest surviving metal trumpets date from 1350 BCE and were found when King Tutankhamen's tomb was excavated in 1922? Or that the standard valve type in the modern trumpet is known as the Périnet valve? Or that General George Custer was accompanied on his way to his last stand by a brass band led by Felix Vinatieri?
Trumpeters will especially enjoy Gabbard's account of visiting the factories and workshops that make the Bach Stradivarius, the Martin Committee, and the Monette line of professional trumpets. Bells spun on lathes, the annealing of the metal, the ins and outs of Mt. Vernon (New York) versus Elkhart (Indiana) Bach trumpets, how Miles Davis got a black Martin Committee, and David Monette's transformation of the instrument through fundamental redesign of leadpipes and mouthpieces will light the equipment lust in all of us who have, at one time, thought to ourselves: “If I just opened the throat of my mouthpiece one more notch,” or “if I just took the lacquer off my horn,” or “if I just had a different bell size or heavier horn, then I would have the beautiful sound, consistency, and easy blowing feel of my dreams.”
In Gabbard's account of his own experiences studying the trumpet, we observe someone working very hard to get into the boys' club that he is writing about. From barely being able to play a middle C to playing respectable lead trumpet in a community Latin band, Gabbard's personal narrative has a heroic trajectory that parallels the biographies he includes of Buddy Bolden, Louis Armstrong, and Miles Davis. Gabbard is self-deprecating and humble as he describes his evolution, but it is clear that his process of studying the trumpet is about affirming his own masculinity and getting close to the fraternity of trumpet players he so admires.
Women trumpeters appear as an anomaly in Gabbard's overall narrative, which is committed to celebrating the essentially masculine nature of the instrument and the pathway to an attractive manhood it offers. It is not that he does not write thoughtfully about women trumpet players or does not recognize the sexism they have faced, but, as a woman who has played the trumpet for over forty years, I think he has missed something crucial about what drives trumpet players, male or female. I should reveal that Krin and I have been “trading fours” on this topic for at least fifteen years, that I am one of the women he interviewed for the book (he quotes me), and that we are friends.
In a nutshell, I feel that Gabbard greatly overestimates the physical strength required to play the instrument and consequently essentializes the body type required for trumpet playing. By observing that many lead trumpet players have big barrel chests, arguing that every lead player has something of the brute in him, and stressing the physical difficulty of playing the instrument, he implies that the male body is invariably the one best biologically adapted to playing the instrument. Carmine Caruso, the legendary brass teacher whose legacy has been carried on by Laurie Frink, encouraged women brass players with the same message he gave to men (I had a lesson with him in the early 1980s): the physical demands of the instrument require an athletic sort of training. He viewed his exercises as a series of calisthenics designed to develop the athleticism and efficiency necessary to master the instrument. The development of breath control is just as important as (if not more important than) muscular strength. Indeed, playing with too much mouthpiece pressure and not enough air support is sure to tire out even the most muscularly endowed trumpet player. The trumpet requires less volume of air than other brass instruments—indeed, like the oboe, there is a great deal of back pressure on the air stream created by blowing into a narrow tube. What distinguishes the best players is not the size of their bodies, lungs, and musculature, but rather, the efficiency with which they use what they've got.
Great women players such as Susan Slaughter, Laurie Frink, Ingrid Jensen, and Clora Bryant have been every bit as adept as male players in their physical understanding of the instrument. It is not because they are channeling their inner masculinity, or otherwise engaging in a complex transvestism. Rather, those women who survive in a trumpet culture that is suspicious of them find common ground with male players over the sonorous pleasures of the instrument—the achievement of a beautiful sound, soaring lyrically above an ensemble, a dynamic range from a whisper to a roar, and attacks from crisp to smeared. The sensuous pleasures of the mouthpiece as one nails a perfectly centered note is not something that excites only one gender; it's like kissing intensely, after all. Even the most masculinity-obsessed trumpeters I've encountered are not constantly prioritizing manhood on stage; rather, most focus first on the sound, the music, and the human emotion that resonates through both male and female bodies. Only if these factors are together can they strut.
In his biographical account of Miles Davis, Gabbard complexifies his understanding of the trumpet by addressing Davis's less macho and more vulnerable style of trumpet playing. The intimate and emotional qualities of the instrument are acknowledged, as well as Davis's towering influence in changing the direction of jazz by exploring them intensively. He suggests that even in the most macho player, there may be a geeky nerd lurking under the surface. Here he had an opening to deconstruct his own narrative, but chooses instead to say that such softening of the instrument cannot change the instrument's association over several thousand years with unreconstructed masculinity. The instrument's symbolics may be ancient, but, as his book demonstrates, they have changed over time and have recently included far more women than ever before. Is there really no opening for a more gender-inclusive future? In the final sentences of Hotter than That, Krin gets the handshake of acceptance after playing trumpet well in a Latin band: “Somewhere in the universe of Nuyorican machismo there may now be a tiny place for me,” he writes. It's not just women, it seems, who struggle to get admitted into the various boys' clubs. As irritated as I am that Gabbard concludes with the idea that acceptance into the fraternity of men is the ne plus ultra of trumpet playing, I cannot help but love this book, for it bespeaks a deep love affair with a radiant instrument, my longtime companion, that has never before gotten the respect that it deserves.
