These days photography is widely accepted as an objective medium; scientists routinely submit photographs as evidence of an event, circumstance or thing observed instead of the thing itself. In this way, photography has proven an invaluable lubricant, greasing the wheels of scientific investigation. Long gone are the days when scientists gathered at the Royal Society or Académie des sciences to see a discovery with their own eyes before they believed it. Though scientists still gather, debate and collectively observe, they share the results of their experiments remotely – with written and visual representations that can be analysed and, if necessary, re-created in the laboratory.
Photography is an essential tool in this process. Whether a zoologist wishes to unveil a new species, a molecular biologist wishes to share the results of a gel electrophoresis, or a particle physicist wishes to show the trajectory of subatomic decay, it is photography, more often than not, that will be used to convey the results. Though sceptics may question whether a photograph depicts what a researcher says it does, it is rare, if not unheard of, that photography itself is challenged as an appropriate means of recording and transmitting visual information. Photography is so ubiquitous in research culture that photographic documentation is often viewed as a stand-in for the situation it records. Assuming a photograph is made honestly and according to protocol, it is accepted as data – as a matrix of facts that can be measured and studied in much the same way as that which it represents.
It is tempting to think that photography has always enjoyed such status. However, as Jennifer Tucker details in her rich and eloquent examination of the rise of scientific photography, Nature Exposed, the medium that existed in the 1830s and 1840s was decidedly different from the one that came to prominence some thirty or forty years later. At the time of its invention, photography was slow, frequently indistinct and difficult to reproduce; moreover, to make a photograph required specialist skill and training, as the materials needed had to be prepared and processed on the spot. By the 1880s the situation had changed dramatically. Gelatine dry-plate negatives, factory-made papers, ‘foolproof’ cameras and commercial processing facilities made the act of creating photographs relatively easy, and the results increasingly compelling.
Tucker leads the reader on a subject tour of Victorian scientific photography, treating near-simultaneous developments in a variety of fields and noting parallels that arose in them. She describes developments in meteorology, botany, astronomy, criminology, microbiology and even, somewhat puckishly (though quite revealingly, it emerges), spiritualism, as they relate to photographic picture-making. The cumulative effect of this wealth of historical information is to cast light on the element of witnessing in the photographic enterprise, and to explore the ways in which academic notions may be shaped by popular prejudice.
The first scientific photographs were made by enthusiasts who recognized the medium's potential as a scientific tool, but who were constrained by technical limitations and occasionally their own naivety. In such an unsettled landscape, it was easy for unscrupulous practitioners to test the limits of credulity. One marvels, for example, that nineteenth-century viewers could have been convinced by the photograph purporting to show a Martian wearing a turban and holding a laurel branch; by the turn of the twentieth century, as Tucker recounts, the same medium was not only being used effectively to study the real geological properties of the planet, but clear photographic depictions of the canals of Mars were coveted, and the substitution of drawings for photographs for the sake of convenience was roundly criticized. This pattern of tightening public and scholarly scrutiny occurs within each of the subdisciplines Tucker examines. On the whole, technology had advanced so much by the 1880s that researchers felt confident submitting photographs as proof of things occurring beyond the threshold of human vision.
Along the way, Tucker explains, achievements were made, deceptions committed and failures lamented. The attitude towards photography that emerged as a result was surprisingly ambivalent at times. ‘The idea that people over a hundred years ago accepted photographs at face value is exaggerated and misleading’, she argues (p. 4). Accordingly, Tucker describes how photography gradually achieved its semi-automaton status, linking the desire to develop a prima facie objective medium to the trend towards objectivity in scientific representation, notably referencing Lorraine Daston and Peter Galison's influential 1992 paper ‘The image of objectivity’ (Representations 40, 81–128).
In this vein, Tucker considers not just the circumstances in which photographs were created and how their makers conceived them, but also how they were received; hers is a history of experience more than a history of practice. Of particular interest in this regard is the author's attention to popular as well as academic perceptions – the interplay between ‘high’ and ‘low’ views of the medium is a recurring theme in the book. She makes a strong case for the convergence of commercial and scholarly interests in photography's formative years. For the medium to have achieved acceptance as objective, Tucker argues, required a broad cultural shift. ‘Nineteenth-century consumers shaped the meanings of photography, whether or not they knew how to take pictures or even had direct access to cameras’, she explains (p. 66). This occurred even as publishers occasionally sought to exploit growing (and frequently misguided) public recognition of photographic empiricism. As a result, she observes, there evolved an ‘often tensely negotiated association between democratization and science … the public culture of scientific photography appeared to widen, even though the boundaries around professional science were becoming more tightly drawn’ (p. 124).
Meticulous at every turn, Nature Exposed on nearly every page contains a paragraph that would, on its own, be a superb subject for a doctoral thesis – postgraduates take note. For the rest of us, it is an impressive, long-overdue critical companion to the early history of scientific photography in Britain that leaves few stones unturned. It is also an enjoyable read, as it delves into some of the quirkier and more entertaining chapters in photographic history.
