With her first book, Runaway Daughters, Sloan makes a valuable contribution to the study of republican governance and its relationship to changing attitudes about parental authority, sexuality and honour in nineteenth-century Mexico. Using 212 rapto cases from the capital city of Oaxaca de Juárez, mostly from the era of the Porfiriato (1870s to 1890s), she explores intergenerational conflicts between adolescent children and their parents over abduction and marriage choice. At the centre of these cases are Oaxaca's mostly indigenous popular classes: the city's bakers, shoemakers, domestic servants, weavers, carpenters and sellers of tortillas and sweets, who worked and courted in marketplaces and church plazas under the watchful gaze of family, friends and neighbours. Runaway Daughters is one of the few books in which working-class youth, children between the ages of 13 and 21, hold a central place in the narrative of nineteenth-century Mexican history. In this well-written monograph, Sloan uses rapto disputes to take up questions about the role of the state in the lives of Oaxaca's artisans, farmers and petty merchants, and she ultimately reveals that republican judges more often sided with rebellious daughters and their suitors and limited parental influence over marriage choice.
Sloan identifies the Porfirian legal definition of rapto as ‘abduction by seduction’, when a man forced or deceived a woman to run away, often to have sex, and sometimes in exchange for the promise to marry (p. 33). Through careful case analysis, she reveals the ambiguous relationship between rapto, seduction, rape and elopement. While the law portrayed the abducted women as passive victims of predatory men bent on deception, in practice, Sloan finds the daughters were more often the ones who planned and orchestrated their own rapto. According to Sloan, the children of these cases engaged in an act of personal and political rebellion against parental authority, seeking legal emancipation from overbearing and exploitive elders who often depended on the labour and wages of their older children to sustain the household.
For Sloan, Oaxaca's liberal state played a fundamental role in intergenerational conflicts between children and parents, a sphere of family life that had once been under the firm jurisdiction of ecclesiastic courts during the colonial era. She argues that by choosing to emancipate minor daughters, republican judges increased the state's power to regulate intimate relationships among Oaxaca's mostly indigenous popular classes. Sloan views Oaxaca de Juárez as ‘the crucible of liberalism during the nineteenth century’ (p. 31), and asserts that its distinctive status in the development of liberalism in Mexico shaped how Oaxacans used the courts and presented themselves before the state. It is with this argument that Sloan takes on the difficult task of demonstrating that republican judges were acting on liberal ideologies that celebrated individual liberty of runaway daughters over parental authority, when the colonial Church had followed a similar practice of supporting young couples in elopement disputes, albeit to respect the free will of children to choose their marriage partners.
Sloan also deftly explores how parents and children brought notions of honour into play as they struggled to justify their actions and bolster their authority before elite judges. She firmly defends the idea that Oaxaca's popular classes held their own, alternative definitions of honour and respectability that emphasised hard work and good conduct. Mothers who laboured as washerwomen and petty merchants highlighted their good reputations among neighbours and their honest efforts to support their families. Young women and their suitors readily admitted to sex before marriage, showing how female virtue was not strictly bound to virginity, at least so long as a marriage promise had been part of the bargain. Sloan's work contributes to broader questions about how honour codes changed during the nineteenth century, perhaps not only for Oaxaca's popular classes, but for elites as well. Were the men and women appealing to Oaxaca's courts expressing an alternative notion of honour, or were they also participating in changing the overall definition of honour under a new, republican order that emphasised conduct as a measure of reputation? Sloan's work enriches the discussion of honour codes as they relate to sexuality, work, ethnicity, status and conduct.
In addition to the exploration of Oaxaca's working-class youth and their parents, Sloan places these conflicted relationships in the broader context of the community and the nation. She identifies a collective aspiration for community peace in the resolution of family conflicts, especially among indigenous Oaxacans. This emphasis on reconciliation certainly echoes the findings of anthropologist Laura Nader, who studied judicial culture among Zapotec villagers a century later. Sloan, however, explores further how the desire for community tranquillity limited the degree to which overbearing husbands, fathers and mothers could assert authority over wives and daughters. Sloan also makes creative use of Mexico City's penny press, broadsheets and chapbooks. These publications hailed from the nation's capital, and many spoke to the anxieties of parents about the corrupting influence of life in the big city on local youth. Sloan demonstrates how the vivid stories of patricide, incest, seduction and suicide that appeared in these pamphlets found their way to villagers living on the outskirts of Oaxaca de Juárez, many of whom sent their own daughters to work in the market squares and elite households of their neighbouring state capital. Runaway Daughters is an engaging and worthy monograph that is certain to inspire discussion about the reach of parental authority, and about changing notions of honour, marriage and sexuality among the youth and popular classes of Oaxaca, a place so vital to the history of nineteenth-century liberalism in Mexico.
