
As with Al Santhouse’s earlier Head First, No More Normal is an easy and considered read, within which the author takes a purposeful journey through areas of his work he has found fascinating and difficult. From the standpoint of an experienced teaching hospital neuropsychiatrist, Santhouse examines the complexities inherent in psychiatric diagnoses when these have been defined by expert consensus interpretation of subjective internal experiences and what we believe the research evidence shows. Since what is considered to constitute normality is not absolute, and the boundary between normal and abnormal is therefore subject to movement, criteria for recognising diagnosable mental or developmental disorders will necessarily be changeable. Santhouse gives the obvious example of autism spectrum disorder, which has expanded from a description of people with severe intellectual and communication disabilities to include individuals who may be socially awkward or idiosyncratic but are able to function well, often with successful careers and relationships. This expansion matters, he argues, because receipt of a diagnostic label can have enormous consequences. While some individuals will embrace the explanation and support that can come with diagnosis, others will experience the process as removing their feelings of autonomy or agency to struggle against life’s everyday challenges. It matters, too, because this potentially challenges the legitimacy of the making of psychiatric diagnoses: ‘The overlap of diagnoses with character traits previously considered as normal variations has become blurred. Perhaps our very definition of what is normal is changing at the same time. Yet it feels as if we, as a profession, are failing in our goal to differentiate the two.’
Santhouse puts his cards on the table early, telling us that he firmly believes in the soundness and value of psychiatric diagnoses, that they represent carefully thought-out, research-based positions and that they are much more than mere manifestations of professional faith. However, he also explains that even what may appear to be psychiatry’s most well-established and clear-cut diagnoses, such as schizophrenia or dementia, are subject to complexity, and their boundaries and expression have changed over the years. Historical changes in international diagnostic criteria for schizophrenia are well known and exemplified by diagnostic abuses made in the old Soviet Union. But symptoms of memory impairment, once synonymous with a dementia diagnosis, are now frequently recognised as part of functional cognitive disorder and post-concussion syndrome. Such patients may complain more bitterly about their memory impairment than people who have Alzheimer’s disease, yet it is the impact of anxiety on their memory, compounded by the effects of anxious monitoring for further memory lapses that is responsible for their symptoms, and they do not have dementia, although they may be mistakenly diagnosed with this.
Santhouse looks at the rise in cases of depression and antidepressant prescriptions. Were we previously failing to recognise depressed people in the population or has increasing awareness of depression altered how we define the condition in relation to our own experiences? It’s probably a bit of both, as feelings of sadness and emptiness alone are now sufficient to satisfy diagnostic criteria for depression, and doctors (not just psychiatrists) actively look for depression in patients as a condition they know they can treat successfully. The book takes a more critical swipe at the contemporary preoccupation with trauma, exemplified by society’s constant concerns for ‘trigger warnings’, yet – as Santhouse points out – there is no evidence that these are helpful, even for people with post-traumatic stress disorder.
The democratisation of knowledge, flattening of hierarchies of expertise and the emergence of a consumerist view of healthcare have made everyone an expert on where the bounds of health and normality can be set for the expression of personality, sexuality and gender. These have become battlegrounds, where any clinical attempts to make diagnoses or define what is normal are likely to be fraught with anger and pain.
Towards the end of the book, Santhouse bemoans psychiatry’s current obsession with risk and looks ahead to what the future might hold for his discipline, based on extrapolation from the changes he has witnessed over his working lifetime. Fascinatingly, and as in his earlier book, the author reveals as much about himself, his (entirely endearing) doubts and anxieties and his perspective as a responsive but fixed-point observer through a quarter of a century of change in psychiatry, and the wider world that it has responded to, as he does about the patients and diagnostic practices that the book is ostensibly concerned with. I think of Al Santhouse as an old and fond friend and would be surprised if readers of his book don’t find they feel the same.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.