As Janelle Reinelt and Gerald Hewitt note in The Political Theatre of David Edgar: Negotiation and Retrieval, British playwright David Edgar has been labeled passé by some critics. Their book is a spirited defense of Edgar specifically and of his type of political dramaturgy generally; they accurately situate Edgar in the role of social commentator and activist, and analyze twelve of his plays as evidence of his activism. According to their introduction, the book “brings together the disciplines of political philosophy and theatre studies to approach Edgar primarily as a political writer and public social critic” (3). The authors' central concern is to reassert Edgar's standing as a significant theatrical force and, indeed, to reassert traditional playwriting as a viable endeavor amid the public and scholarly clamor for physical and devised theatre. “His theatrical style,” they write, “is mostly based on language and rhetoric rather than the now ascendant ‘physical theatre’. . . . Edgar's plays offer a robust reminder of the values of narrative, discursive exploration of character and situation, and above all capacious thinking about social reality” (5).
Reinelt and Hewitt's defense begins in Chapter 1, “Introduction: Political Commitment and Performative Practice,” with a reconsideration of the term “political theatre,” and a critique of the work of those who have sounded the death knell of political theatre for “assum[ing] that while ‘politics’ may be different in any historical moment, there can be only one corresponding theatrical style to suit the times” (8). The authors seek a broader definition of political theatre, hoping to unshackle the term from the “‘state-of-the-nation’ plays” (7) that were widely created in the 1970s and 1980s (and of which Edgar was a leading purveyor). This is a reconsideration that is long overdue.
In their search, Reinelt and Hewitt initially separate the terms “political” and “theatre” from each other, noting that both terms have widely varied meanings. They note that the sum of the term “political theatre” is only as good as its constituent parts: “If any one of these terms is taken to be fixed,” they argue, “the result is inaccurate and unsatisfying” (10). They extrapolate from historian Michael Oakeshott's definition of politics the idea “that people find themselves in certain relations with others in media res, and then attempt to rearrange, transform, or in some cases strengthen the existing arrangements” (9), and note that theatre basically exists as a “micro-political practice” because it allows audiences to examine multiple relationships “among all the humans participating in the event” (9). To define theatre as political, then, becomes an exercise in redundancy, and ultimately Reinelt and Hewitt cite Joe Kelleher to state that “the politics [in theatre] is unavoidable, is bound to come round sooner or later” (11).
If theatre's purpose, in Reinelt and Hewitt's broad view, is to offer a location for people to reexamine their relationships with one another—relationships that, following Stefan Collini's definition of politics, are based in power differentials (10)—Edgar's work can be seen as the perfect embodiment of political theatre. Rather than viewing Edgar's work as outdated, Reinelt and Hewitt describe his dramaturgy as a series of specifically staged interventions into cultural and political questions. Edgar's plays simultaneously examine complicated human negotiations of specific events and offer audiences the opportunity to locate solutions via characters who, in the end, refuse to be daunted by the challenges they face.
The remaining chapters in Reinelt and Hewitt's book each elaborate a different facet of Edgar's advocacy; the authors view Edgar as a “prolific creative writer,” as an “analyst of the contemporary world,” and as an “advocate of complex cultural and political positions” (37). Chapter 2, “Intervening in Public Discourse,” concentrates on Edgar's prolific nontheatrical writing and lays the groundwork for positioning Edgar as a figure more widely relevant than his occupation as dramatist might otherwise suggest. Chapter 3, “Things Fall Apart,” looks at Maydays, Edgar's early-1980s exploration of the British Left, and Continental Divide, his recent two-play treatment of the American political system. These plays, the authors tell us, explore how idealism can degenerate with age; they raise broad questions about the way certain individuals come to terms with political realities. Chapter 4, “Governing Memberships,” examines three of Edgar's plays concerned with ethnic difference: Destiny, Playing with Fire, and Testing the Echo. These plays demonstrate Edgar's ability to encourage his audience to think more intricately about individual identity and the complexities of living in diverse societies. Chapters 5 and 6, “‘A Legend In Your Own Time’” and “Socialism's Aftermath,” deal with plays that explore individual negotiations with state power (The Jail Diary of Albie Sachs, Mary Barnes, and Albert Speer) and the impact of the fall of socialism in Eastern Europe (The Shape of the Table, Pentecost, and The Prisoner's Dilemma), respectively.
Where Reinelt and Hewitt excel is in their willingness (via Edgar) to uphold traditional playwriting, imbuing it with purpose that belies the supposed outmodedness of the political play; however, though they make clear that Edgar's interventions are deliberate and specific, their book prompts me to question the efficacy of these types of theatrical intervention. Edgar is an undeniably important figure, but if his work is viewed as passé, as some critics claim, might we not assume that his plays are being seen only by a small segment of the theatregoing public—those who desire to see such work? This question certainly goes to the wider efficacy of theatre in general, but it is one that Reinelt and Hewitt do not approach. If Edgar's dramaturgy is as critical as the authors claim, a more specific accounting of the playwright's efficacy could have been included in what is otherwise a worthwhile reassessment of political theatre in Britain.
