While most monographs on the Western Greeks include a critical review of previous work, dedicated studies on the history of scholarship of Magna Graecia are a relatively recent development. An early example would be De Angelis' 1998 paper in Antiquity (‘Ancient past, imperial present: the British empire in T. J. Dunbabin's The Western Greeks’), which sketched how Dunbabin's Australian identity coloured his perception of ancient Greek colonization. The potential of such studies to cast light not only on the mindsets of previous scholars but also on the framing of contemporary debates is difficult to overstate. Ceserani's volume breaks new ground in its breadth of focus. Rather than concentrating on the career of an individual scholar or the study of a particular class of data (as R. Higginson did in his recent monograph, A History of the Study of South Italian Black- and Red-Figure Pottery (2011)), C. traces the study of Magna Graecia and its place in the writing of Italian history from the Renaissance until the end of the Second World War. Much of this story will be unfamiliar, even to those working in the field. The narrative is adeptly interwoven with the threads of political and intellectual history, encompassing, inter alia, the Renaissance, the vibrancy of Naples in the Enlightenment, the revolutions and wars of the early nineteenth century, the growth of nationalism and its impact on scholarship, the Risorgimento, and Fascism and its post-War legacy. This is a significant achievement, made all the more impressive by the book's stylish prose.
Naples figures strongly in this book. The decline of the city, after the Napoleonic Wars, as a centre of culture, political influence, and scholarship, mirrors and, to some extent, compounds the increasingly marginalized status accorded to Magna Graecia. Previously, the region had enjoyed significant prominence among those on the Grand Tour as their point of closest encounter with ancient Greece. A key strength of the work is how it maps the connections between antiquarian scholarship and travel writing. This relationship helps articulate the trajectory from centrality to marginality. As Greece and the Aegean became more accessible and increasingly romanticized by travellers and scholars, so Southern Italy came to be seen as impoverished, peripheral, and, with the notable exception of Paestum, scarcely worth a visit.
Nationalism and imperialism figure, too. The mood for unification in Italy saw intellectuals and political theorists look to the past for inspiration. As a cultural import, Greek South Italy, for all its achievements, sat somewhat uncomfortably in narratives devoted to the potential of the Italian nation. Although some scholars sought to integrate Magna Graecia into their theses by emphasizing the importance of native peoples in the success of the colonies, this only served to affirm the inferiority of the Italiotes at a time when cultural purity was stressed by those engaged in contemporary colonial enterprises. The rôle of native peoples in the development of the Greek cities of South Italy remains contested, although in our pluralistic and post-colonial world, the mixing of traditions is celebrated rather than reviled. For non-Italian scholars, nationalism and imperialism were equally significant in terms of both the founding of foreign academies in Italy and of viewing ancient colonization through the lens of modern imperial experience. Once again, the effect was a diminution in the status of Magna Graecia. Another important factor was the ‘Southern Question’. As Italy unified and modernized, the perceived backwardness and corruption of the South served to categorize the region as problematic. Magna Graecia, which was already described as impoverished in Roman times (Cic., Amic. 4.13), became symptomatic of the Southern malaise.
The scope of this monograph, which spans roughly four centuries, inevitably means that the coverage is at times uneven. For example, Campania receives more attention than Puglia. To a large extent, this reflects the evidence; Naples was a centre of learning and the terminus for many on the Grand Tour. Likewise, the best-preserved architectural remains of Magna Graecia are to be found at Paestum. As the volume progresses, its emphasis shifts to the writing of the history of the region from an Italian perspective, with the result that the work of foreign scholars is somewhat downplayed. Thus, Maximilian Mayer, author of Apulien vor und während der Hellenisierung (1914) and Director of the Archaeological Museum at Bari for ten years in the late nineteenth/early twentieth centuries, goes unmentioned. The same tendency can be seen in the discussion of the inter-War period. Here the impact of Fascism on the study of Magna Graecia is ably explored through a comparison of the careers of Ciaceri and Zanotti Bianco. This focus is understandable but it leaves little room for those scholars whose work was not defined by their support for or opposition to the political regime. Consequently, Dunbabin warrants only a paragraph while Trendall, whose first major work, Paestan Pottery, was published in 1936 during his tenure as librarian at the British School at Rome, is not discussed at all. These small quibbles aside, this is a major work of scholarship in a relatively undeveloped field. Italy's Greece was not always lost. C. is to be congratulated for the compelling manner in which she traces how it became so.
