Professor Sir John Rowlinson's book – the first full-length scholarly biography of its subject – is a solidly scientific account of the working life and professional relationships of Sir James Dewar. Through the research questions Dewar chose to investigate we are taken to Edinburgh, Cambridge and the Royal Institution, and introduced to his work on the structure of benzene, on spectroscopy and on cryogenics, via his incidental invention of the vacuum flask. On the way we see him engage in many often fierce disputes over priority, respect for hierarchy, and conflicts of interest. Throughout, Rowlinson gives clear explanations of the science Dewar was involved in and how it was that one problem led onto another. He shows vividly the hard work, patience, perseverance and self-belief required to make progress in science – this is not a heroic tale full of flashes of inspired genius; instead he shows a career and reputation built up steadily over years.
A number of themes recur throughout the book. Almost every chapter shows Dewar quarrelling very publicly with someone. In Chapter 5, Dewar and George Downing Liveing row with Norman Lockyer; in Chapter 7 there is a dispute with Alfred Nobel; Chapter 8 includes his falling out with William Ramsay. Another theme is that of hierarchy, and the idea of knowing one's place. There is also a recurrent tension between ‘pure’ and commercially driven research. All through his life Dewar took on commercial and legal work, in addition to his work at Cambridge and at the Royal Institution, and in some instances used Royal Institution equipment and assistants, though always apparently staying just within the terms of his contract. What was unclear to me, however, was why he kept doing this. It often caused arguments and, as Rowlinson points out towards the end of the book, he already had two salaries giving him and his wife more than enough to live extremely well on. The book, however, is not one for theorizing. Rowlinson mentions on more than one occasion that Dewar's strengths and interests lay in the accumulation of facts, not in using those facts to create theories, and, in keeping with this theme, Rowlinson seems to have done the same with Dewar's life story. We know what he did; we don't always know why.
This book tells us a huge amount about Dewar's professional work and relationship, often giving detailed accounts of the bureaucracy involved in getting appointed and working for these big institutions in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. It is not, however, a biography that gives an account of his whole life. The chapter on his childhood and early education is just three pages long. His wife is mentioned half a dozen times at most, and it is only in the very last chapter that we learn anything of his outside interests (he was, it seems, an enthusiastic supporter of the arts). There is also very little context given concerning the times in which he lived and how these might have affected his work.
One minor criticism I have of the book is with the editing: there are a number of typos and the chapter on cryogenics is inexplicably three times longer than any other, with Dewar's most famous accomplishment (the invention of the ‘vacuum’ or Dewar flask) buried in the middle. While I can see the logic in placing that story within the context of his cryogenics work, I felt the whole cryogenics story might have had more impact if broken up a little.
The book's major strength is Rowlinson's ability to explain contemporary problems in chemistry in a way that does not make the theories we know now seem inevitable. He also has a good eye for observations and quotations that bring to life chemists and their personalities. I loved the idea that Dewar had a ‘favourite molecule’ (picoline, in his early career – p. 15), and Rayleigh's comment about physicists versus chemists showed at once contemporary prejudice and Rayleigh's personality. Rayleigh ‘was later to say’, Rowlinson tells us, ‘that he was glad to get out of chemical discussions and be back among the physicists “where the second-rate men seemed to know their place so much better”’ (p. 136). The list of accidents (some fatal) experienced by Dewar's assistants, and Dewar's often cavalier attitude to danger and, in particular, to explosions, again evoke a different time, with different values and concerns to our own. The book, and indeed Dewar's career, ends as chemistry enters a new phase. At the Royal Institution Dewar is replaced by William Henry Bragg, the first of the RI directors to have his own research school. At the same time, quantum theory begins to emerge. Dewar was not completely blind to new developments – he worked briefly, for example, with Pierre Curie on radium, looking at its behaviour at low temperatures – but these sweeping changes, along with his prickly personality and indecipherable handwriting, nonetheless go some way to explaining why he was so quickly forgotten. Until now, that is.
