George Orwell died in 1950, not long after Nineteen Eighty Four made him into one of the iconic figures of the Cold War. Controversy over his political and literary legacy began immediately, with both the Left and Right struggling to don the mantle of his moral authority. Even after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Orwell has remained a moral and literary presence in the lives of many journalists, public intellectuals, and scholars, not to mention the untold number of American students who routinely are assigned his books. The year 2003 marked two occasions to assess his continued relevance: the centenary of his birth and the beginning of the Iraq War. That both the war's defenders and its critics sought to enlist Orwell on their respective sides is reason enough to ask how he gained such high repute as a moral authority. John Rodden has devoted considerable scholarship to just this question, tracing Orwell's “ambiguous afterlife” as a cultural icon and public figure. Every Intellectual's Big Brother, his third book on the history of Orwell's reception, explains why so many intellectuals have made Orwell a writer “well worth stealing.” As with his earlier groundbreaking studies, Rodden's latest book uses Orwell's legacy as a case study to raise broader, theoretical questions on “the dynamics of literary response, the nature of author-reader relationships, the formation of reader's identities, the construction of intellectual genealogies, and the sociology of artistic reputation” (34–35).
Part 1 relates key episodes in the polarized history of Orwell's reception among Anglo-American intellectuals. The focus is not directly on Orwell but rather the various images readers have projected onto him and his works in order to meet their own professional and private needs. For Rodden, a reader's relationship to a writer like Orwell is “not merely a literary but also a complex autobiographical and cultural act” (52). Rodden discusses Orwell's ideologically conditioned reception among a number of intellectual circles of both the Right (Russell Kirk and the journal Modern Age) and the Left (Irving Howe and the New York Intellectuals, Christopher Hitchens and The Nation). He gives lively accounts of how the Orwell image was used in the almost fratricidal polemics that often divided these intellectual cliques. The intramural fighting at The Nation that led to Hitchens's departure in 2002, after he derided the Left for its failure to support the “war on terrorism,” is just the latest of many political debates since World War II that have turned into ideologically charged arguments about the status of Orwell and his work. As Rodden points out, Hitchens's book Why Orwell Matters (2003) is a veiled self-defense of Hitchens's own aspirations to become, like Orwell, “a rebel of the Left” (105).
Rodden demonstrates how “Orwell's politically ambidextrous reception” (4–5) helped to generate conflicting images of him as a public figure. While acknowledging the elusive and ambiguous elements that have made Orwell the subject of diverse interpretations, Rodden's own view is that Orwell is a writer firmly positioned on the Left, albeit in a complex way. And he suggests that the contemporary Left would do well to reclaim the lineage that extends through dissenters like Irving Howe back to Orwell. While he dismisses the neoconservative attempt that sought to enlist Orwell as a Cold War warrior, he concedes that thoughtful conservatives like Russell Kirk are right to call attention to Orwell's “Tory growl” (as Conor Cruise O'Brien once described Orwell's conservative streak). Indeed, Orwell criticized the Left of his day in The Road to Wigan Pier precisely for its failure to incorporate communitarian values in the cause of social justice. Rodden argues that Orwell could be used to reconstruct an egalitarian, anti-elitist liberalism that incorporates the values of tradition, patriotism, and family.
Part 2 consists of Rodden's interviews with scholars, journalists, and writers who constitute Orwell's contemporary “intellectual progeny” and “literary siblings.” The interviews, held at a 2003 centenary retrospective on Orwell's work, address a wide range of topics, including the changing fortunes of the Left, the meaning of Nineteen Eighty Four in the post-Soviet world, and the contemporary relevance of Orwell's views on such matters as patriotism, technology, intellectual life, and women. Not surprisingly, the interviewees confirm Orwell's posthumous moral and literary presence in their lives, though none, of course, would claim to know with certainty “what Orwell would say” on many contemporary issues, such as the Iraq War. Most seemed to think that he would have condemned Saddam's totalitarianism, but not necessarily have supported the US- led war against him. Both apologists for the war like Hitchens and critics like Todd Gitlin identify themselves with Orwell in establishing their own principled positions. While Orwell remains the prophet of the horrors of totalitarianism, Dennis Wrong points out that the era of “powerful mass movements … aiming at total transformation” (125)—the kind of totalitarianism that defined Orwell's historical moment—may be coming to an end. Yet nearly all of Rodden's interviewees, while acknowledging many of the social prejudices he shared with his age, maintain Orwell's contemporary relevance as an exemplary public intellectual. Only Daphne Patai takes exception to this view, pointing to what she argues is undeniable evidence of misogyny, anti-Semitism, and homophobia that pepper his writings.
Why does Orwell continue to command such authority among public intellectuals? Certainly he carries a certain moral credibility for having been right about imperialism, fascism, and Stalinism. Moreover, his highly-crafted prose—direct, honest, urgent—remains influential among intellectuals seeking a public voice. But the one quality that continually draws many to Orwell is his intellectual integrity. As this volume shows, Orwell's persona is still “a counter-symbol to a general feeling today of a lack of integrity among political leaders and ingrown, publicly incomprehensible discourse among academic intellectuals” (46). In Gitlin's words, he is “the guy who invites intellectual courage” (143). Orwell's “breadth and daring” (168) represent a challenge to contemporary intellectual life, which, according to Rodden, has become less public due to academic specialization and ideological fragmentation. Given the proliferation of “think tanks” and advocacy groups that provide institutional bases for legions of highly educated, political professionals, Rodden perhaps overstates the marginalization of today's intellectuals. But he is right to point out that the literary and social settings that enable dissenters and social critics to reach a wide audience have diminished. With the decline of independent literary circles, intellectuals now need to cultivate a personal “literary apprenticeship” with the exemplary public intellectuals of the past; for “one must internalize the tradition of ‘the intellectual’ because the intellectual culture is now gone” (169). Orwell is central to this tradition. His example can still teach intellectuals how to embrace the vocation of social critic by cultivating a healthy skepticism about power while addressing the wider public in accessible and morally urgent language.
Orwell reminded intellectuals of the difference between hagiography and criticism. Rodden warns them against the opposite tendency of confusing criticism with the cynical debunking of exemplary figures because they fall short of contemporary standards. One should admire and learn from intellectual heroes without falling into uncritical worship. “That means that one resists equally the hagiographic urge to canonize Orwell as St. George and the iconoclastic temptation to trash him …” (188). Rather than claiming to speak for the real George Orwell, Rodden concludes instead by proposing an “ethics of admiration and detraction” that articulates preliminary guidelines for how we might claim and disclaim our intellectual patrons. He is to be applauded for writing another insightful book on Orwell, the “benevolent big brother” whose life and writings demonstrate, among other important lessons, “a comradely insistence on holding one's side to the highest standards” (190). He is also to be commended for insisting that public intellectuals be judged by the moral effort they make to keep an independent and self-critical mind and not by the fervor of their ideological commitments. Intellectual life, in other words, should not be swallowed whole by politics. Keeping a critical distance is, after all, Orwell's own advice to politically engaged writers in his essay “Writers and Leviathan,” for genuine writing “will always be the product of the saner self that stands aside.” More than many other intellectuals of the last century, Orwell is still the decent guide to negotiating the torturous conflict between political commitment and intellectual distance, between taking a stand and standing aside.
