This book traces welfare policy developments in Germany and the United Kingdom from the late 1970s to 2003. Focusing on three policy dimensions—unemployment policy, public pension policy, and family policy—Jochen Clasen seeks to understand the scope, nature, and timing of welfare reform. To his credit, the author avoids the usual trap of characterizing welfare reform exclusively in terms of retrenchment. Recognizing the complex nature of shifts in social policy over time, his work details and explains patterns of retrenchment, restructuring, and expansion. To understand the pathways of policy transformation, he considers three types of explanatory factors: party politics (mainly actors' preferences), contextual conditions (such as major events and social trends), and institutional parameters (including legal constraints, existing policy programs, and the characteristics of political economy structures). He also considers the relationships among these causal forces.
Clasen's approach can be described as comparative historical analysis, through which he traces the intricate developmental processes of these three different policy families in Germany and the UK. To establish the direction and scope of each reform trend, the author considers qualitative indicators, such as changes in eligibility regulations, in conjunction with statistics on public spending by policy domain. By unpacking social provision indicators, he demonstrates a sensitivity to claims by Francis Castles (see The Future of the Welfare State: Crisis Myths and Crisis Realities, 2004) and others, who rightly contend that aggregate data on national welfare expenditure can be misleading.
Clasen's process tracing yields a series of complex narratives. In spite of similar trends of unemployment policy retrenchment in Germany and the UK, the author finds that each country's distinctive policy profile is rooted in preexisting program structures that are linked to characteristics of the national political economy. He details similar trends of retrenchment in German and British public pension provision, but also finds differences between the two national policy profiles. Here, he argues that national trajectories are mainly conditioned by “national programme-specific institutional parameters, changes therein, and their impact on the dynamics of party policy preferences” (p. 131). With respect to family policy expansion in Germany and the UK, Clasen highlights the importance of sociocontextual factors and party platforms, which appear to be more relevant than institutional factors for family policy trajectories.
The book's content is presented in an accessible manner that capitalizes on the comparative aspect of the study. Chapter 1 sets up the juxtaposition of the German and British cases, which are typically conceptualized as alternative models of the modern welfare state. Chapter 2 situates Clasen's contribution within the academic debates over the direction and causes of welfare reform in industrialized democratic states. Chapter 3 presents the three main explanatory perspectives: preferences, context, and institutions. This chapter also provides a 25-year overview of socioeconomic trends in Germany and the UK.
Chapters 4 (on unemployment support), 5 (on retirement pensions), and 6 (on family policy) offer comparative analyses of developments in the three policy arenas. In these chapters, Clasen describes and empirically substantiates the trajectory in each country for the policy domain at hand, highlighting cross-national commonalities and divergences in policy outputs. He then explains the progression in Germany, followed by a parallel account of the changes in the UK. In summary, each of these analytical chapters offers comparative conclusions that entail consideration of the role played by actors' preferences, broad situational factors, and institutional settings. Finally, Chapter 7 reunites theory and empirics for a review of the findings, and considers the effects of Europeanization on welfare state reform.
The key strength and weakness of Clasen's book are both rooted in his overall approach. The topic under study is extraordinarily complex, and by means of fine-grained analysis, the author manages to capture the nuance of social policymaking in three different policy domains, in two different countries, over 25 years. Through historically sensitive case studies, he is able to provide a rare and detailed view of the mechanistic processes that shape outcomes. When considering the influence of preferences, contexts, and institutions, however, he notes that “their respective relevance has varied across programmes” (p. 188). What he is offering, then, is evidence of a set of processes that seem to fit Arthur Stinchcombe's definition of a mechanism as a “sometimes-true theory” (see “Monopolistic Competition as a Mechanism: Corporations, Universities and Nation-States in Competitive Fields,” in Peter Hedström and Richard Swedberg, eds., Social Mechanisms: An Analytical Approach to Social Theory, 1998). For instance, the author finds that the concept of path dependency is supported mainly in the case of public pensions policy, but less so when examining unemployment provisions. Further, this research suggests that path dependence does not play a major role in the advancement of family policy in Germany and the UK.
Comparative scholars who put little stock in broadly generalizable conclusions about welfare state reform will certainly applaud the author's efforts to present a contextually defined narrative. Others will find the fragmentation of his explanatory account somewhat unsatisfying. On a related note, Clasen's advancement of multicausal explanations may closely reflect the reality of policy development, but his resistance to prioritizing one set of explanations over another leaves the reader without the usual take-home message. If we consider this work in terms of a broader research agenda, however, the book offers many hypotheses that can be tested in other national and policy contexts.
Another trade-off involves conceptual clarity. The author is methodical when it comes to clearly defining his dependent variables, contributing to a focused and valuable study. In contrast, such key explanatory concepts as political economy and context are less theoretically delineated. The inclusion of contextual factors is important, particularly when considering the strains of German unification or the effects of female labor participation in both countries. However, the diversity of factors that qualify as contextual (ranging from the Falkland Islands war to political scandals, normative orientations, and public opinion) suggests a residual category. This interest in context should figure into future work on social policy, but its conceptualization should be more rigorous and theoretically grounded.
Clasen's book will be very useful for academics and policy experts concerned with the current condition of the modern welfare state. Certainly, the author's rich knowledge of his cases offers a tremendous resource for any researcher interested in employment, pensions, or family policy, or in welfare state politics more broadly. Finally, his comparison of policy shifts in these two important national arenas is not simply an investigation of outcomes; it provides a research model that is sure to shape future studies of the welfare state in advanced democracies.
