John Wilkes, the cross-eyed rake turned demagogue, became an emblematic figure in English politics during the 1760s. An aspiring politician, Wilkes found his hopes for preferment blocked when changing fortunes cast into opposition the patrons he had assiduously cultivated. The decision to apply his scathing wit against George III and the new government as a publicist won him fame as a popular champion but also pushed Wilkes into the role of outsider. John Sainsbury takes a different approach to Wilkes from that of other scholars, focusing on the private life of his subject to consider how it shaped his public persona. A thematic approach structured around family, ambition, sex, religion, class, and money highlights the paradoxes that made Wilkes an intriguing figure to contemporaries.
Sainsbury begins with the paradoxes evident in Wilkes public image. A notoriously ugly man who became a famed seducer, Wilkes also drew compliments on his politeness. A deist accused of blasphemy, he nonetheless made a point to attend church regularly and pay for a family pew. The spendthrift who made great efforts to dodge creditors kept the allegiance of London tradesman. The rake's progress that his quondam friend William Hogarth depicted as ending in despair and ruin brought Wilkes instead to a prestigious post as Lord Mayor of London. A long view of Wilkes's political career reveals further tensions when the rabble-rouser of the 1760s deplored the mob after the Gordon Riots and took a loyalist position in the 1790s. If his political actions might suggest a change of opinion, other apparent contradictions between the private man and the public persona seem to illustrate the aphorism that hypocrisy is the homage virtue pays to vice.
Continuity, however, exists within the contradictions. Sainsbury presents a consistent pattern forged by Wilkes's self-creation as a gentleman. Wilkes had been born the younger son of a prosperous family of London dissenters that had made a fortune in trade and was given a classical education more typical of a gentleman than a merchant's child. Wealth and parental encouragement gave him the means for social advancement, and he embraced the opportunity from his early days. Becoming a gentleman involved more than property; it meant displaying the manners and mores of mid-eighteenth-century England's polite, patrician culture. Politeness had a complex meaning that encompassed far more than courtesy and outward behavior. It defined attitudes toward display, sexual conduct, and honor along with political assumptions of liberties and independence, while providing the vehicle to pursue ambition. Sainsbury cites Lord Chesterfield's letters to his son, with their contrast between a rake and man of pleasure, as an example of the ethos that Wilkes embraced as a guide. Wilkes structured his persona as a latter-day Robin Hood or “rake hero” on aspects of his personality strategically designed to aim at different audiences. Defiance of propriety made him the gentleman defender of the common people.
Sainsbury develops his view of Wilkes around the concept of libertinism. The libertine defied conventional sexual and religious constraints in pursuing pleasure but nonetheless acted with honor and refinement. Such libertinism distinguished from both the self-destructive hedonism of Restoration-era figures like the earl of Rochester and the hooliganism of rakes who disrupted Covent Garden with their rowdiness a generation before Wilkes. Womanizing provided a venue for male sociability and the display of taste, and Sainsbury notes that private debauchery struck contemporaries as perverse. The “sneaking lecher” cut a very different social figure from the libertine. Flouting convention within the bounds of taste and patrician dignity allowed the libertine to display individuality. Indeed, the ability to transgress boundaries with impunity seemed the mark of gentility. Status conferred protection, while incurring penalty or ostracism implied a lack of station. Style rather than morality operated as the determining factor for the libertine, and Samuel Johnson’s view of libertinism as combining the morals of a whore with the manners of a dancing master underlines the point.
Wilkes's determination to become a gentleman made family relations and other aspects of his private life subject to the demands of his ambition. The role of libertine enabled him to combine the pursuit of pleasure with grasping for social mobility, as its interpretation of patrician mores privileged cultured decadence while casting restraint and measured purposefulness as tediously bourgeois. It also opened a path for thwarted political ambition. As a publicist attacking George III and Lord Bute, Wilkes gained a prominence he might never have earned in parliament. Controversy enabled him to stress his independence as a gentleman scorned by society who set popular interests before personal gain or political faction. Wilkes's libertine defiance of moral convention became part of his public persona that made resistance to dependency a badge of honor. Just as the libertine expressed taste through his sensual pleasures and independence through his resistance to convention, he also cultivated reason by disdaining religious dogma. Sainsbury notes that rejecting orthodoxy paralleled general resistance to authority and the superstition, intolerance, and persecution deists associated with religious establishment (139). Attendance at formal public worship marked the “manly and polite” behavior expected of a gentleman (133–34), and Wilkes's sympathy toward Catholic claims reflected disdain toward the bigotry of exclusion. Libertine predilections, Sainsbury argues, became a public asset that associated Wilkes with liberty.
Sainsbury's volume makes an interesting contribution to the literature on eighteenth-century culture that draws on a range of work including Anna Clark's study of political scandal. Readers unfamiliar with Wilkes’s career should begin with a narrative biography and then look to Sainsbury for the wider context. Although beyond the author's purpose, it might be interesting to compare Wilkes more closely with both Lord Rochester in the seventeenth century and such later nineteenth-century moral desperados as Lord Byron and Percy Bysshe Shelley to consider how the concept of libertinism changed over time.
