The aim of this book is to provide a broad, multidisciplinary and up-to-date review of academic work in the field of musical creativity. It is partly a report of empirical research, for example in the fields of cognitive neuroscience and education, but also a more theoretical consideration of how musical creativity occurs in, and interfaces with, applied fields such as musicology, music education, sociology and music therapy. The chapters are based on papers first presented at a European Society for the Cognitive Sciences of Music (ESCOM) conference held at the University of Liège in 2002, supplemented with an editorial first chapter and a concluding postlude that presents a ‘conversation’ between one of the editors (Deliège) and the composer Jonathan Harvey on the creative process.
The book is structured around seven themed sections. The first, titled ‘Creativity in musicology and philosophy of music’, begins with a provocative chapter from Nicholas Cook exploring the relationships between musical creativity and music analysis as commonly taught. In the following chapter Merker, somewhat obtusely, considers the concept of ‘musical creativity’ as distinct from other forms of creativity. He argues that the listener's appreciation of a new piece of music is dependent upon a previous listening history, thus musical creativity is constrained historically and culturally. To conclude the section, Mark Reybrouck attempts to define musical creativity from the perspective of cybernetics and systems theory, moving from a consideration of musical creativity as an intuitive act to the presentation of a formal model that operationalises musical creativity. These chapters are challenging reads but definitely rewarding and thought-provoking.
The second section of the book contains two chapters that deal with the cognitive processes involved when someone listens attentively to a piece of music. Deliège summarises her cue abstraction model of listening and argues for the appropriateness of the term ‘creative cognition’ to describe the listening process. She discusses in some detail the role of analogy and comparison during listening, suggesting that the process contains sufficient origination and activity to merit being described as ‘creative’. In the second chapter Baroni concentrates on one aspect of musical listening, that of detecting a particular musical style. He reports a small-scale empirical study in which participants were asked to try to identify the composer of a work. Baroni reports the cognitive processes that were revealed to him during post-procedure interviews and suggests that some of these, but not all, can be described as ‘creative’. His evaluation is somewhat subjective but depends on drawing a distinction between processes that were broadly ‘problem solving’ (in a fairly classical definition) and those which required little active work to reach a solution (i.e. the participant knew the work already).
The third section is likely, at first glance at least, to be of greatest interest to readers of this journal as it deals directly with creativity in educational settings. Hickey and Lipscomb focus on one of the main challenges to music teachers; that of assessing creativity in student compositions and establishing stable criteria for evaluation. They report the results of an empirical study that utilised Alan Lomax's ‘cantometrics’ technique to classify and compare musical works. The authors compared student compositions to a ‘standard’ model that was presented at the beginning of the task: observed differences occurred mostly in the area of melody, perhaps not surprising given that the model was highly rhythmic and did not have a melody to begin with!
In the next chapter, Burnard argues that any understanding of children's creative music making must take full account of the child's individual understanding of the process and the product. Research that removes the contextual aspects of children's composing risks missing much of the richness of the creative process and might lead to a limited understanding of the underlying cognitive and social processes involved. Tafuri, in the final chapter of this section, reports an empirical investigation of processes and teaching strategies in musical improvisation with children. Teachers will find this an insightful and stimulating chapter as it deals with both conceptual and pedagogical aspects of musical creativity.
The fourth section of the book considers creativity in the context of musical performance. Williamon, Thompson, Lisboa and Wiffen discuss notions of creativity and originality and seek to develop a clearer understanding of the relationship between individual creativity and the social context in which creativity is situated. Davidson and Coulam then present detailed findings on elements of creativity within performers’ physical movements. Finally, Chaffin, Lemieux and Chen report findings of a research study into spontaneity within highly practised performances.
Section five is concerned with aspects of musical creativity within therapeutic contexts. Wigram outlines the perceived value in creative tasks with clients, exploring through an empirical study the concept of ‘structure’ in improvisation. Lee then discusses, in a somewhat unfocused and speculative manner, the aesthetics of creativity within the context of clinical improvisation. Finally, Sutton explores from a philosophical perspective the concept of ‘silence’ in music itself and within the context of therapeutic encounters. This was, for me, the least satisfactory section of the book.
The sixth section is concerned with neuroscientific approaches to musical creativity. The chapters (by Lotze et al., Brattico and Tervaniemi, and Bellardinelli) set out to explore whether brain imaging techniques can reveal anything about the neurological aspects of human creativity and report some significant differences in brain activity between expert and non-expert musicians. The authors explore ‘surrogate’ creative activities, such as listening and performing, rather than more conventionally creative musical activities such as composition or improvisation. They do, however, give the reader a stimulating overview of current research in this important area.
The final section of the book deals with computer models of creative behaviour. Two chapters by François Pachet deal with (i) creativity studies and musical interaction and (ii) interactive reflexive musical systems. The first chapter suggests that the study of human interaction with computer systems can provide a rich insight into creative processes, while the second deals more specifically with one interactive reflexive musical system. Todd and Miranda then explore how social interaction can be built into computer-based musically creative systems using biological models as a starting point. This section of the book provides a fascinating insight into how computer-based research can extend both our knowledge of, and our thinking about, human creativity.
A postlude reports a conversation between Irène Deliège and the composer Jonathan Harvey and offers some interesting and stimulating insights into some aspects of creativity, especially the concept of ‘inspiration’. If anything, this section of the book highlights the very individualistic nature of musical creativity (and indeed musical experience) and the challenge of undertaking quantifiable and generalisable research in this area.
The challenges of defining ‘creativity’ within any domain are significant. Satisfactory definitions should be capable of exclusion, as well as inclusion: is every activity in a musical context creative? Many chapters begin with some reiteration of the problem of definition, yet the matter remains unresolved.
One of the strengths of the book is that it demonstrates convincingly that creative behaviour (as might be commonly understood) is encountered not only in the areas of composition and improvisation, but also in performance and listening. The reader is left with the sense that music is a profoundly creative and complex activity, regardless of context or specific activity. For the music teacher, this is encouraging given that ‘creativity’ is most commonly linked in a curricular sense to the activities of composition, an area of pedagogy that is often most challenging to teachers. The sections on listening and performance in particular reinforce the creative cognitive engagement that occurs during those activities. The sections based on neuroscientific research confirm this impression.
In general the chapters are well written though, as is common with edited volumes of this type, there is no real sense of stylistic cohesion between the various chapters or sections. Given that the chapters are based upon papers given at a conference, it would also be misleading to suggest that each section depicts the ‘state of the art’ in each respective discipline. The chapters represent the work of specific individuals or research teams, and other relevant work may be excluded. In its attempt to reflect the breadth of research in musical creativity I feel that the book may not have given each aspect the depth it requires, nor does it provide a strong overarching framework or commentary. Having said that, many of the chapters provide extremely useful introductions to the literature and context of the discipline and will be of interest to anyone wishing to gain a broad overview.
So is the book likely to be of interest to readers of BJME? Well, I suspect it rather depends on what you're looking for. On one level the book works well as a comprehensive introduction to the variety of research that goes under the banner of ‘musical creativity’. It outlines many of the key debates, research methodologies, challenges and lines of enquiry that are current, as well as setting out (in some chapters at least) a clear agenda for future research. On another level, however, those aspects of the book that are most likely to stimulate and challenge music educators are scattered across its sections and readers will need to do significant synthesis for themselves. This is not a book that is concerned directly with pedagogy. Rather, it reinforces to music educators the mystery, wonder and variety of musical creativity and how much fertile territory remains to be explored by researchers.
